(IANS) Former Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad has singled out India as an Asian country that has “made the mistake of being too democratic” and compared it unfavourably with China’s authoritarian regime.
Mahathir said: “India, of course, will grow, but more slowly than China. It has the numbers but is not making use of them well.”
He identified China, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan and, “to a lesser extent”, India as the countries which would lead the Asian charge, New Straits Times said Tuesday.
Mahathir, who ruled Malaysia for over two decades, told a seminar on Asia and 21st century that people “do not understand the limits of democracy”.
“Democracy can be a hindrance to progress because you spend so much time politicking that you don’t have time to develop your country.
“In China, there’s not much politics. So, they can spend more time developing their country.”
He blamed the West for making democracy and freedom the cornerstone of progress.
It is the West’s focus on democracy, civil rights and individual liberties - attributes flaunted by Western governments - that Mahathir identified as being the reason behind “its economic flaccidity”.
“The British believe a lot in so-called freedom. Their workers must be allowed to go on strike all the time. So, they have the problem of being a very unproductive population.
“They must be free of everything. When you do that, productivity will drop. When productivity drops, you cannot compete.”
Talking about Asia, Mahathir ruled out a role for “strife-torn” West Asia.
“They are not going to make much progress, unfortunately. They are not going to contribute to the Asia of the 21st century. But it doesn’t matter because Asia is such a big place,” Mahathir said.
East Asia’s emerging economic dominance over the West is due to its productivity and strong work ethic, he said.
However, the former premier warned of the increasing trend among young Asians to ape Western culture.
“Today, there are places in Tokyo where you see young people with multi-coloured hair. They look like Red Indians. These are the young Japanese who have adopted Western values,” said the octogenarian who continues to draw crowds six years after he quit office.
“They want to be free and be able to change the place they work, hop from one place to another and take marijuana. This is what the Europeans do. This is progress for those young people.”

written by roadbarra, November 22, 2009 01:37:45
written by Mirage, November 21, 2009 15:43:05
written by Steven Ong, November 18, 2009 13:23:58
Democracy is good ,better even if it is perfect. It is corruption that hinders progress and advancement and not the freedom to choose . Because the people are corrupt and selfish, they choose the wrong people to run the country. And because they are selfish that leads to corruption, , they would not allow others to make changes. That is the truth and the truth will set every nation free.
written by Jit Dharma, November 18, 2009 13:13:19
tripe is fodder for the dumb asses that don't know better. That's why he spouts off, eager fools
are always ready to swallow this shite. India is a democratic country, the feudalists are being
beaten back, their time is up. China is a one-party state, the Communist's are the latest
dynasty in a country which has only known tyranny and dynastic rule. The bloodshed in
Tiananmen Square reveals the depth of their cruelty and their eagerness to hold on to
power, whatever the wishes of the people will be. The one-party tyrannies of this world are
all continuing simply because of their unrestrained use of violence against any dissent.
The people that live there are slaves. The people of India will never exchange their hard won
freedom for the bogus promise of tyrants and their business stooges. They are poor but
that can be taken care of over time. It takes hard work and character to change what is worst
in any nation. Mahathir only knows the quick fixes of tyrants and tyranny. Thankfully he is just
a pipsqueak with a big mouth.I shudder to think what he would do if he had the power of say,
Hitler. Germany was also very well developed and disciplined. And of little use to the
human race.
written by jaz, November 18, 2009 11:53:47
written by jaz, November 18, 2009 11:46:33
That is how it used to be. But now the Indians are making progress already. It would become a fully developed country soon and the economics is booming and could possibly rival China. Did I mention they also produce the best doctors and surgeons?
written by Kilam50, November 18, 2009 10:58:21
written by asguard, November 18, 2009 09:13:59
written by imanj, November 18, 2009 02:11:28
Just to add Indai produces some of the most beautiful women in the world,like Ashwariya Rai who is the most beautiful woman in the world....!!!
They are expressive and certainly have more talent in arts/drama making them Internationally known..!!
We have the maknyas,mat rempits,the ' I ' & ' You ' speaking kind,the pakcik/makcik/abang/adik/kakak attitude when addressing anyone and no ability to understand the need to speak English and be at par with many other countries but at the same time are big users of everything made by someone else...oh let's not forget about the only wanting to be materialistic and glamourous!!!
If we were democratic for 50 0dd years by one and only one Government,is it the fault of the people who fail the country or if is it not having the ability to understand democracy and govern???
written by Sutha, November 18, 2009 00:50:06
Has he forgotten that some twenty years ago, he received an award for being a successful Overseas Indian?
Podah Malabari Kaka.
written by jason, November 18, 2009 00:05:27
Dr.Mamakthir what happened to Malaysia?. I thought we are going to be a developed country in 2020.
Shouldn't we be leading the charge?. What happened to your grand vision?. None of your vision works.Your heavy industries, MSC, Bangsa Malaysia, Malaysia Boleh. Only one thing is working, CORRUPTION.
written by Proarte, November 17, 2009 23:40:46
In Mahathir's world, if the elite put on a good show and rob the nation, it is OK. The will and interests of the majority do not matter. They will be cruelly supressed if need be to maintain the rule of the elite. In short, Mahathir supports mafia rule.
written by Ocassey, November 17, 2009 23:40:29
NOW THAT HE HAS BEEN OVERTHROWN BY HIS OWN EVER VORACIOUS ELITIES, HE NEEDS TO PLAY THE ROLE OF LUCIFER. THE MORE HE IS BEING RIDICULED BY THE RAKYAT THROUGH THE VARIOUS MEDIAS THE LIVELIER WILL HE BE. CURSES AND CONDEMNATIONS WILL BE HIS NUTRIENTS THAT WILL ENABLE HIM TO LIVE ON ------- HIDUP ! YOU INDIAN TURNCOAT.
written by Vertigo Cure, November 17, 2009 23:14:34
Not too long ago, when you turn on the news you will see South Koreans striking and demonstrating yet they progress way faster then your regime.
Mamakthir, it's racism and not democracy that stifle the progress. Just admit it, YOU SCREW UP!
written by miwaki, November 17, 2009 22:12:53
written by Just Gan, November 17, 2009 21:58:29
The Indians should not just listen to your advice but invite you to become their primeminister. You are far more qualified than Manmohan Singh or anyone else in India to restructure the country so that it can beat China. As the self-proclaimed world's top-most expert in democracy and economics, your "genius" and "decisive actions" are required by India. There is no one in India who can match your genius. India needs you. Given your Indian ancestary, I am sure India will welcome you as a citizen and offer you the PMship. Go for it, Mahathir. Apply to become an Indian citizen and PM.
written by philip25, November 17, 2009 21:57:47
written by talk2stop, November 17, 2009 21:11:06
written by penangboi, November 17, 2009 21:08:05
Oh, I forgot. Of course it is UMNO and Mamakutty in particular who killed off democracy in Malaysia. Natural for him to say such moronic words.
Democracy and transparency do not go hand in hand with corruption and abuse of power. Of course Mamakutty and UMNO will never allow full democracy to flower in Malaysia. They need to dip their hands in the till to line their bank accounts.
No, of course for Mamakutty and UMNO democracy will not do at all.
written by archie, November 17, 2009 21:06:18
The dictatorial rule of Mugabe (Zimbabwe) and Marcos (the Philippines) have turned their countries into banana republics.
China started to grow rapidly only after the late Deng Hsiao-ping embarked on his economic reform and opening-up policies 30 years ago.
written by jchew, November 17, 2009 20:58:50
Twist and shout!...Twist and shout!
Cmon cmon, cmon, cmon, kuty, now, (come on kuty)
Come on and work it on out. (work it on out)
You know you’re a twisty little shit (twisty little shit)
You know you twist so bad (twist so bad)
Come on and twist a little looser, now, (twist a little looser)
And let me know that you're full of shit. (let me know you’re full of shit, wuu!)
Well, shake it, shake it, shake it, looser now. (shake it up looser)
Well, shake it, shake it, shake it, kuty now. (shake it up kuty)
Well, shake it, shake it, shake it, looser, now. (shake it up looser)
Ahhhhhhhhhh(low) Ahhhhhhhhhh(higher) Ahhhhhhhhhh(higher) Ahhhhhhhhhhh(high)
written by batsman, November 17, 2009 20:54:08
written by eagle22, November 17, 2009 20:38:59
I love freedom.
No water canon .. no tear gas. ---> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DOTZbCPhfiI
written by onnetline, November 17, 2009 20:37:28
What the fcuk are you truly good at besides suppressing human rights and abuse of power ? ? ?
written by corpuscavernosa, November 17, 2009 20:29:54
written by arazak, November 17, 2009 20:25:25
Dear Toon Kutty,
The thing is not the degree of democracy that hinders progress and development. . ., but the degree of "corruption". Please refer to the Corruption Perception Index table by Transperancy international and compare that with of the countries with highest/lowest Per Capita Income! I bet you will find the correlation there!
Again. . ., degree of "corruption" and not degree of "democracy" that determines a country's progress.
And you tell others they do not know about economics. . .?
(Note: In communist China, they would have shot corrupted leaders like you and your elk for enriching your/their families and cronies with the peoples' money and stealing the nations' wealth)
written by OilMan, November 17, 2009 19:58:22
written by advocatusdiaboli, November 17, 2009 19:27:13
written by cheekhiaw, November 17, 2009 19:13:43
xxx
written by Nixcloud, November 17, 2009 18:51:14
Maybe you are nyanyuk and should just go back to jaga cucu di rumah!
written by Rainbowseahorse, November 17, 2009 18:35:46
hmmmmmmm...now that explains why he kept democracy in Malaysia at such a low level. But then how come Malaysia, with suppressed democracy, is not progressing as it should?
"...increasing trend among young Asians to ape Western culture."
What about our local youths of mat-rampits? Maybe mamathir should introduce this as a solution to 'multi-coloured hair red Indians looking" youth all over Japan.
Did mamakthir mentioned that 'corruption in government' is the single most contributing factor in hampering a country's progress? And also stiffening none Malays/Bumiputras from growing is also another major2 factor that Malaysia is not growing as it should?
mamakthir, clean up our country before advising other country how to run theirs.
Do us a big favor and go play badminton!
written by Wahyu, November 17, 2009 18:31:55
Ia hanya ada satu parti sahaja di negara itu!! Jika anda mengingkari sebarang arahan kerajaan maka anda akan terus dipenjarakan.
Cuma bayangkan jika Malaysia cuma ada parti BN sahaja dan tiada pembangkang? C4 akan digunakan dgn lebih kerap lagi.
written by KotaDamansara73, November 17, 2009 18:12:20
written by KotaDamansara73, November 17, 2009 18:11:02
What is the root cause of the Malay problem? You tell me the Malay civil servant got more work ethics than the INdians in India. You got to be kidding me. The richest and wealthiest Asians are Indians. Just look at Forbes magazine.
written by AsamLaksa, November 17, 2009 17:37:02
written by MSIABOLEH, November 17, 2009 17:30:54
written by taxi90, November 17, 2009 17:30:30
written by Raja Chulan, November 17, 2009 17:28:41
This is the problem with Iskandar Kutty, he always engages his mouth before the brain is in gear.
written by rocky, November 17, 2009 17:20:44
as for China, the leaders from Deng Xiaoping have taken a capitalist way to grow the country and they practise a 'democratic' system within the communist party. And the past and present govt stand against corruption is very clear, you can get executed for it regardless of who you are. Also there is lots of accountability by the present Chinese leaders and govt unlike in india or malaysia even if they are not elected by a democratic system. China prior to 1990s also had lots of issues and corruption and was not developed. what made the difference was leadership and changes in the communist system and adopting meritocracy in business. deng said he doesn't care what color of the cat as long as he catches mice. in India they care too much what family tree the cat belongs to and same as in Malaysia.
There are couple of Indian states that are ruled by communist party but yet they are unable to rule like China. Why? What India needs is a drive against corruption lead by an independent agency supported by leadership of the govt. It also needs an accountable govt and accountable leaders. they do not need to be a communist country. It should also allow competition which brings benefit to the locals.
India is progressing, it will take 10-15 years for parts of India to be ahead of malaysia. Catching China will be difficult unless China screws up.
written by KingSolomon, November 17, 2009 17:11:06
written by KingSolomon, November 17, 2009 17:06:23
What authoritarian regime in China is he talking about? People there are fairly treated and adequately compensated in compulsory land acquisition for infrastructure and other development projects. Look at how their govt lead the public and private sectors to build a big economic cake for the people. Look a how they fast they respond to tragedies, corruption and other crimes - speedy. People there are happy with their govt.





















LKS was appointed adviser to China before they boomed; perhaps he gave them good advice. Sadly India did not or does not need your advice; I wonder why?
Perhaps it is because of your treatment of Indians in Msia, or is it your blatant racism, kaka?? No matter what you do, India does not need this it-piece has-been racist despot / dictators like you for sure.
Why, they may even tar & feather you in Kerala, try it and see kaka; make your senile statements in India and they will probably whack your racist ass with coconut lidi...
You are a fakir Malay. Even Msia does not want you, kaka.....Ask humNoo