Ex-judge: Huge Hindu, Buddhist statues against Islamic teachings

batu cave

(The Rakyat Post) – A retired Court of Appeals judge has expressed his view that the “huge” statues at a Hindu temple in Batu Caves and a Buddhist temple in Penang were against the teachings of Islam as the religion forbids idol worship.

Datuk Mohd Noor Abdullah said such statues of deities should not be out in the open, but should be placed within an enclosed building instead.

“With such a huge statue, you’re showing that your religion is all mighty and powerful,” Mohd Noor told the Malay Mail Online and Bernama in an joint interview yesterday, referring to the 42.7-metre high statue of Lord Murugan, the Hindu deity, at Batu Caves in Selangor.

Pointing to the Federal Constitution which states that Islam is the religion of the nation, the former judge insisted Islam was above other faiths.

“When non-Muslims build such big idols, it hurts people’s feelings,” he said, adding non-Muslims had freedom of worship, but such freedom must be exercised in a way where “Muslims don’t feel threatened”.

The retired judge also criticised the 30.2-metre high statue of Kuan Yin, the Goddess of Mercy, at a Buddhist temple in Air Itam, Penang.

“Islam forbids images (of gods). Here, you allow images of Buddha in the country. That’s not consistent with Islam. But if you cover it up, you can allow it.”

Mohd Noor also called for Malaysians to set aside their racial identity and to think of themselves as Malaysians in order to foster national integration.

“The Constitution does not divide the community into Malays, Chinese, Indians and others.

“In the Federal Constitution, Malaysia is composed of the Orang Asli, natives, and non-native community.”

He noted that the Constitution defines natives as the Malays from the peninsula and the Bumiputeras in Sabah and Sarawak.

“Malays now are inclusive Malays, not exclusive.”

Mohd Noor said that based on the Federal Constitution’s definition of a Malay — one who is defined as a Muslim who speaks the Malay language and conforms to Malay customs — Malaysians who convert to Islam should be considered Malay.

“Why should the Malays be jealous and reject them as Malays?

“People tell me that if Muslim converts are considered Malay, we’re selling off Malay rights to the Chinese and Indians.

“But Islam says that you should share and share alike with Muslims.”

Mohd Noor also called for the abolition of vernacular schools and said that Mandarin and Tamil could be taught at national schools instead.

“We can make English, Malay and Mandarin compulsory in national-type schools,” he said, noting that Mandarin had become an international language.

He added that Putrajaya should allocate more funds to develop the Orang Asli and native communities in Sabah and Sarawak, and also urged the Malays to “work hard like the Chinese”.

Mohd Noor first stirred controversy last year when he reportedly warned the Chinese of a Malay backlash for purportedly betraying the Barisan Nasional at the May 5 general election, which saw the ruling coalition’s worst-ever electoral performance.