.

MT COLUMNS GUEST COLUMNISTS No such thing as ‘Malay unity’

No such thing as ‘Malay unity’


Monday, 19 March 2012 admin-s
E-mail Print PDF
Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!MySpace!Yahoo! Twitter!LinkedIn! 

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_oBKN-yzJ03o/TTov52xD8yI/AAAAAAAABbk/usK3nPL14W4/s1600/Perdana+Menteri+Msia+1-5.jpg

(Hafidz Baharom, TMI) - Tunku Abdul Rahman was partially Thai, the Onn family line were partially Turkish or at least Eurasian as I recall, and Tun Mahathir Mohamad himself isn’t purely local either. Tun Abdullah Ahmad Badawi is also partly Arabic and heck, Datuk Seri Najib Razak is in fact partly of Indonesian descent. And I haven’t even begun to go into the history lessons we had in Form 3 on the royal families yet.

 

Currently, some people are calling for unity among one race in Malaysia — the Malay race. And this call is being heeded by political and non-political factions; this includes Perkasa, Umno and, of course, some people in PAS who still believe in the concept of racial unity contrary to their so-called conservative Islamic beliefs. Some leaders have spoken out against it being a reality and one of them is my much-admired once-bankrupted former Finance Minister Tun Daim Zainuddin.

Now let me ask a question. How many prime ministers are really, truly, Malaysian Malay? Meaning that their parents, grandparents and perhaps even two generations beforehand were all from Malaysia?

Look back some 60 years, if not further.

Tunku Abdul Rahman was partially Thai, the Onn family line were partially Turkish or at least Eurasian as I recall, and Tun Mahathir Mohamad himself isn’t purely local either. Tun Abdullah Ahmad Badawi is also partly Arabic and heck, Datuk Seri Najib Razak is in fact partly of Indonesian descent. And I haven’t even begun to go into the history lessons we had in Form 3 on the royal families yet.

Let us consider what to look at when you look at the Malays. Historically, the Malays were given the role of administrators by the British, but only the elites. The rest of the Malays toiled in the kampungs, focusing on agriculture while the Chinese focused on industry and manufacturing and the Indians were coolies. I am not being disrespectful, I am stating facts. Not all Indians came off a boat from Chennai and straight away became lawyers in good ol’ Malaya.

And then came 1969 when the Malays apparently had a clash with the Chinese because someone apparently took the wrong route in a victory parade that led to killings and the burning of buildings which could be seen by Tunku Abdul Rahman himself as he stood on his balcony. 

But after that, everyone thought the Malays should unite, and the Chinese should do the same, which was why Gerakan and PAS both decided to join in the emergency government set up after that under Tun Abdul Razak. PAS would never have united under Tunku Abdul Rahman because the guy loved his horses and whiskey too much.

If these people want to unite the race, let me just ask this question. Under what banner? Do you want to unite under Perkasa, Umno or PAS?

Just pick one of the three and you would see that there, right there, is where the shit hits the fan. Personally on my side, I think all three are similar. The only difference is that one of them talks shit, the other is shit and the third thinks the nation is shit and needs to be saved so it is worthy of Allah’s grace. And if anyone has an objection, take it up with Shahnon Ahmad.

The Malays can’t unite because we believe in different things. Some believe that everyone should convert to Islam. Others think we should put race ahead of nation and religion. Well, fine by me. Go tell that to the Indonesians here. Let’s go ahead and join them, why don’t we? After all, they’re Malay too.

Read more at: http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/opinion/article/no-such-thing-as-malay-unity/


 

Language Translation

subscribe to Malaysia Today news

RosseberryShop.com

MT Cartoon

GUEST COLUMNISTS

Ignore the scaremongering and let's move forward

News image

 For the ruling politicians to describe these voters as being easily "duped" and "taken for a ride" – or basically plain stupid – for exercising their democratic rights is not ...

Reflecting on Malaysia’s Election

News image

 Toppling him now for his deputy, Muhyiddin Yassin, could lead to very costly rifts in the UMNO, which the party might not be able to afford. Any change in the ...

Did two million rural voters decide for Malaysia?

News image

 "This point shows the inherent unfairness of the electoral system in Malaysia," he stated. "You would not find such a case in other mature democracies using FPTP." Stephanie Sta Maria, ...

Advance or retreat?

News image

Many political analysts predicted that the 2008 general election was the worst case and the BN would be able to rise from the bottom. The MCA believed i...

Tossing reason away like flip of a coin

News image

Unlike the parties graciously accepting the results in the Philippines, the coin toss if used here could invite disastrous consequences. By Syed Nadzri Syed Harun, FMT Coming just a...

Malaysia: An Irreconcilable Divide?

News image

Of all the kernels of facts about the elections, we know that along with rural voters, a higher proportion of females also leaned heavily towards BN. Thus far, relatively large rallies ...

A tale of two Islamist parties

News image

 PAS and Indonesia’s PKS ponder their political future in the wake of new challenges ahead. In the case of PAS, will it make up for its failure in Kedah and ...

Protesting against Utusan

News image

 AT 4pm today, former Utusan Malaysia senior journalist Hata Wahari plans to protest against what he calls the "racist attitude" of the editors and journalists of the Umno-controlled Malay newspaper in their ...

Careless with facts or deliberate in distortions?

News image

Eric Loo, fz.comA friend emailed a photo story on May 3 of "foreign workers" arriving at the Low-Cost Carrier Terminal, KLIA, in Sepang. It said the workers w...

Soi Lek’s wrong bet

News image

To join or not to join the Cabinet, either way is a dead end for MCA. All I can say is, why the brainless bet in the very f...



This Site is AnswerTips enabled. Just double click on any word on this site to get a quick reference.
You are here: Home MT COLUMNS GUEST COLUMNISTS No such thing as ‘Malay unity’

Latest Posts - Guest Columnist

Popular Posts - Guest Columnist