.

MT COLUMNS When you got your degree from the back of a cornflakes box

When you got your degree from the back of a cornflakes box


Thursday, 02 August 2012 Super Admin
E-mail Print PDF
Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!MySpace!Yahoo! Twitter!LinkedIn! 

 

In 2006-2007, Ramli was about to expose Musa’s relationship with the crime syndicate in the Goh Cheng Poh @ Tengku Goh case. Also, Ramli was about to expose the shenanigans in the plundering of MAS, which was later proven true. Malaysia Today had, in fact, revealed that Nazri Aziz had directed MAS to sack their lawyers and settle its claims with Tajudin Ramli ‘out of court’. Malaysia Today also revealed that Gani Patail had gone on a Hajj with Tajudin’s proxy, Shahidan Shafie.

THE CORRIDORS OF POWER

Raja Petra Kamarudin

Allow me to repeat what I have said so many times before. Yes, I just love saying ‘I told you so’. But then we all have our fetishes, so what can I say? To you your fetish and to me mine, I always say. Anyway, back to ‘I want to repeat what I have said so many times before’.

What I said before was: you need to have a brain to become a lawyer, but you do not need to be a lawyer to have a brain. I am not a lawyer but I certainly have a brain and I know how to rationalise. So allow me, a non-lawyer who has a brain, to walk you through the story of why, today, the government withdrew its case against lawyer Rosli Dahlan.

Just to digress a bit, sometimes I wonder where the Attorney General, Gani Patail, obtained his law degree from. I am beginning to suspect that he pinched it from the back of a cornflakes box. Some of the issues involving the law are so fundamental that you do not need to be a lawyer to understand how the law works.

Let me give you an example. Say someone is charged for the crime of robbing a bank and you are charged for the crime of being the driver of the get-away car. Hence you are facing trial as an accomplice to a bank robbery.

Then the court finds the bank robber not guilty. In fact, the court rules that the robbery did not even happen in the first place. However, although the robbery did not happen and the so-called bank robber of the non-existent bank robbery is acquitted, you still face trial on charges of being an accomplice to a bank robbery that never happened.

You then win the case and the court finds you not guilty. Earlier, the bank robber was acquitted and the court ruled that the bank robbery never happened. However, the Attorney General refuses to admit defeat and continues to appeal against your acquittal.

Can you now see why the whole thing puzzles me and causes me to suspect that the Attorney General obtained his law degree from the back of a cornflakes box? How can they continue to pursue a case against you when the court already said that the robbery never happened? You just cannot be guilty of abetting a crime when there was no crime.

For those who may have forgotten or were not following this case from the beginning, five years ago, during the month of Ramadan in 2007, a few MACC officers went to Rosli Dahlan’s office to arrest him and in the process brutalised him. They alleged that he had failed to declare his assets in the manner they required but they manhandled him like he was a terrorist.

Now, note that the MACC did not arrest Rosli for failing to declare his assets. He had, in fact, declared his assets when asked to do so and even the court said so. They arrested Rosli for failing to declare his assets in the manner that they required. Hence, declaring your assets is not enough. You must also declare it in the manner that can satisfy them.

In other words, they ask you to do something and when you do as they ask they move the goalposts and allege that you did not do it in the manner they required. Hence they can still get you even if you comply with their demands.

Very convenient, don’t you think so? This means, if they want to get you, they can get you anyhow by just changing the rules and then allege that you did not follow the rules.

Actually, the truth is they wanted to get Rosli in any way they could -- by fair of foul means. Hence they sent him a letter asking him to declare his assets and when he did they then went to his office to arrest him on the allegation that he did not do what they wanted him to do in the manner it should have been done.

I suppose if you had replied to MACC’s letter on a blue piece of paper they can still arrest you because the ‘proper manner’ would have been to reply on a white piece of paper. That is, of course, if they want to get you by hook or by crook.

The Attorney General, Gani Patail, was determined to get Rosli because the former was upset that the latter had thwarted their attempts to fix up the then director of the CCID, Ramli Yusuff, on several trumped up charges.

You see, Rosli was Ramli’s lawyer and he successfully defended the latter and got him acquitted. The Attorney General then appealed against Ramli’s acquittals but several High Courts and the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeals. Hence the Attorney General lost and in two of the trials the judges even accused Kevin Morais and Gani Patail of lying.

The MACC, however, continued to pursue their case against Rosli and when he was acquitted they pursued an appeal against him. But Rosli’s case is linked to Ramli’s case and if the latter is not guilty how can there be a case against the former? That is what I meant when I said you could not possibly be guilty of the crime of being the driver of a get-away car in a bank robbery that never happened.

The real issue is: Rosli defended Ramli, who was in line to become the IGP of PDRM. However, Ramli had gone against the powerful unholy trinity of Musa Hasan, Nordin Hassan and Gani Patail. So they wanted to block him from becoming the IGP.

In 2006-2007, Ramli was about to expose Musa’s relationship with the crime syndicate in the Goh Cheng Poh @ Tengku Goh case. Also, Ramli was about to expose the shenanigans in the plundering of MAS, which was later proven true. Malaysia Today had, in fact, revealed that Nazri Aziz had directed MAS to sack their lawyers and settle its claims with Tajudin Ramli ‘out of court’. Malaysia Today also revealed that Gani Patail had gone on a Hajj with Tajudin’s proxy, Shahidan Shafie.

The Musa Hasan, Nordin Hassan and Gani Patail relationship goes way back to the time when the three had forged a close alliance when they fixed up Anwar Ibrahim in the Sodomy I trial. From an incompetent, mattress-carrying investigating officer, Musa Hassan rose to become the IGP. Nordin Hassan rose to become the Director of Prosecutions of the ACA (MACC’s former name) while Gani Patail became the all-powerful Attorney General.

That was Rosli’s biggest mistake. He defended Ramli against this very powerful unholy trinity and thereafter experienced the most painful lesson of his life.

This morning, 2nd August 2012, the MACC’s appeal against Rosli came up before High Court Judge Dato Azman Husin. To everyone’s surprise, the MACC DPP withdrew the appeal. But there is a story behind the MACC’s withdrawal of the appeal. And the story is set out clearly in the two affidavits filed by Dato Ramli and Rosli Dahlan, which you can read in the links below.

Apparently, the MACC appealed against Rosli's acquittal in order to force him to withdraw his RM50 million civil suits against the various rogue MACC officers, which Rosli filed in 2008. That is why the MACC waited until the last minute to withdraw its appeal against Rosli in the hope he would cave in to their demands. Gani Patail also wanted to put Rosli on tenterhooks and inflict the maximum pain on him since the appeal was doomed to fail.

In Ramli’s and Rosli’s Affidavits, they reveal how they were fixed up and the malicious prosecution and prosecutorial misconduct by Gani Patail, Nordin Hassan and Kevin Morais (see paragraphs 6-10 of Rosli’s affidavit). Paragraphs 10-12 of Ramli’s Affidavit also makes interesting reading.

Note that the MACC DPP’s letter to the court is dated 26th June 2012. However, it was never served on Rosli until yesterday. The glaring discrepancy in that letter is that although it is dated 26th June 2012, the Notice of Withdrawal was purportedly filed almost a month later on 20th July 2012.

In other words, the letter talks about an incident that did not happen until about a month later. Hence, in short, the letter was backdated and is a fabrication. And this is proven by the date/time of the fax transmission signal of all the documents, which bears yesterday's date and time -- 1/8/2012 @ 1627- 1628hr.

If you want to cheat at least be clever about it. You go and backdate a letter regarding an incident that happens one month later and then you make the mistake of faxing it where the date shows that everything was done only yesterday.

Do you really need to go to law school to spot all these mistakes and come to a conclusion that mass fabrication is involved here? Aiyoh, maybe the AG should stick to what he knows best -- bonking his staff. He is so poor at fabricating documents.

Actually, the real reason they want to drop this case is because they do not want the two Affidavits below to become public knowledge. If they continue with the case then these Affidavits would be discussed in court. By dropping the case they hope that the Affidavits can be buried and would go unnoticed.

Amongst others would be the revelation of how Razak Musa tried to make a deal with Rosli. They told Rosli they would drop their case against him if he would withdraw his civil suit against them. They realise that the manner in how they manhandled Rosli when they arrested him in 2007 would open themselves to damages. Hence they wanted to make a deal -- you withdraw and we will also withdraw.

And that is why they waited until yesterday to withdraw their appeal but backdated the letter so that it would not look too obvious. But they made the mistake of faxing all these backdated documents and then the real dates show up in the fax transmission. Bodohnya Melayu ni semua!

ADDENDUM

http://www.malaysia-today.net/files/Aff-Dato-Ramli-Yusuf-1-8-12.pdf

http://www.malaysia-today.net/files/RD-aff-1-8-12.pdf

http://www.malaysia-today.net/files/TARIKBALIK-RAYUAN-TPR.pdf

 


 

Language Translation

subscribe to Malaysia Today news

RosseberryShop.com

MT Cartoon

NO HOLDS BARRED

Time and place decides what’s fair

News image

For all intents and purposes, this article is a purely academic exercise to discuss the issue of fair or fairness. I have attached the issue of election boundaries (in t...

The Sedition Act (1948)

News image

The Sedition Act started life as the 1351 English Statute of Treasons. Hence sedition is closely associated with treason. In the 1500s, King Henry VIII broke away from Rome a...

And then came CHINRAF

News image

The absence of Chinese representatives in the Cabinet should it happen will not pose major problems to the government or Chinese community, an academician said today. Selangor DAP chief T...

Tan Sri Wong Foon Meng (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Can you see that long before the 2008/2013 Tsunami, the Malays and Chinese of Kuala Terengganu already set aside their racial/political differences and supported the candidate rather than the r...

Shaping the mind of the Malay

News image

You can see the Malay swing in 1946. Then they swung back and took another swing in 1959. Then they swung back and took another swing in 1969. Then t...

Zahid Hamidi should be asked to resign (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

So, yes, we too in the UK were not happy with the system. And we ‘sold out’ the ruling party and ‘toppled’ the government because we were not happy w...

Is beer halal or haram? (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Now, what I do not understand is: why emphasise ‘on a Chinese woman’? The Chinese scream that they are not racists. Yet they send me this very racist e-mail. T...

Should I leave Islam if I am not happy?

News image

Okay, I am also not happy with some Muslims, even some Muftis for that matter. I think they are very intolerant, unreasonable and narrow-minded. What are you going to n...

Citizenship, Bahasa, the Constitution, and the Police Force

News image

The IGP, Ismail Omar, will be retiring tomorrow. Do you know that many senior police officers do not think highly of him? That is because he is considered too l...

The wheat from the chaff

News image

Now, just like many of you, I was ecstatic in March 2008 when Pakatan Rakyat won five states and managed to deny Barisan Nasional its two-thirds majority in Parliament b...

Racism (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Racism is usually defined as views, practices and actions reflecting the belief that humanity is divided into distinct biological groups called races and that members of a certain race s...

Another well laid trap, maybe?

News image

But since March 2008 many of you have become very arrogant. You no longer care about what you say. And you no longer care whether anyone gets hurt by w...

So what is it then?

News image

In the run-up to the 13th General Election, the Chinese were boldly and proudly screaming that this time around the Chinese are going to unite and vote against Barisan N...

Understanding the “first past the post” voting system

News image

Professor John Curtice, of Strathclyde University, said: “The Lib Dem vote is more concentrated than it was, because they have targeted certain seats. But it is still more evenly d...

GE13 and the 13 predictions that came true (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Many are waiting for my ‘I told you so’ article. No, I am not...

What it all boils down to (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Now, if I were to bet RM100,000 on Pakatan Rakyat winning more than 100 seats, I might most likely win RM100,000. However, if I were to bet R...

Fallacies are not truths (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

However, I have monitored the news reports from both the mainstream media and alternative media over the last week since Nomination Day and what are the issues they are t...

Now do you understand? (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Say Pakatan Rakyat does win the general election in two weeks time. How many of those pro-Umno or pro-Barisan Nasional people will remain pro-Umno or pro-Barisan Nasional? Would they n...

When we have to lick back our spit

News image

Can we Malaysians ever play the game with sportsmanship? Can we ever fight using Queensberry rules? Unfortunately when we Malaysians play or fight there are no rules or sportsmanship. E...

The NATO Syndrome (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

And how many of you signed the petition asking for Dr Wan Azizah to be given a seat to contest the coming general election? Do you know and do y...

THE CORRIDORS OF POWER

It’s all about strategy (UPDATED with Chinese translation)

News image

Then came the 2008 general election and the impressive results gave everyone a lot of hope. So everything that was said earlier was now forgotten. But what they forgot is ...

The day ‘they’ sold out Sarawak (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

The Chinese who kept Taib in power were rewarded for their support and all the transgressions, abuse of power and corruption that is being perpetuated by Taib and his family, ...

The rats leaving the sinking ship

News image

So they are now embarking on an asset-stripping exercise. Chua Soi Lek, Tan Chai Ho, Vincent Lee Fook Long, Kat Swee Sang, and a few other MCA taikos are shifting ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 13) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

While Barisan Nasional was confident it is guaranteed no less than 130 parliamentary seats -- with 145 as an achievable target -- Pakatan Rakyat, in turn, was equally confident it ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 12) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

If I were to hazard a guess I would say that Khairy is the man to watch. He is going to be the ‘face’ of the reformed Umno who will ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 11) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

They recently did a poll in Pakistan and 11% voted in favour of a democracy, 22% in favour of military rule, and 53% in favour of the Khalifah system. The ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 10) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Out of the 89 parliamentary seats that Pakatan Rakyat won, 53 are non-Malay/Muslim seats while only 36 can be said to be Malay/Muslim-majority seats. Umno, however, won 88 seats just ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 9) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

You may argue that the Chinese voters have rejected the Chinese from Barisan Nasional and hence the Chinese should not be in the government. But if the Sultan ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 8) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Hence the percentage in votes has never matched the percentage in seats. This has always been the case since Merdeka and is called gerrymandering, perfectly legal all over the world ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 7) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

The problem is not so much what to do with Najib. If Najib were to be ousted, just like Pak Lah was soon after the 2008 general election, then Deputy ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 6) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

We once found a few names registered at a cemetery (now that is what I would call real phantom voters). In fact, Azmin Ali’s dead father was still a registered ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 5) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

And that would mean Umno’s days are numbered when more Malays move away from Umno and swing over to PAS and PKR in the spirit of Pakatan Rakyat. And this ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 4)

News image

Anwar’s knee-jerk reaction when the results were announced on Sunday night was that Pakatan Rakyat won 51% of the votes so this means Pakatan Rakyat won the election. In 1933, ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 3) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

What Najib did not suspect was that some other Barisan Nasional leaders from Sabah and Sarawak wanted to follow Lajim Ukin and Wilfred Bumburing when they crossed over. However, Anwar ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 2) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Umno has still not recovered from this shock and even Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad is pissed big time. He is blaming Najib for wasting his time and the government’s resources ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 1) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Once the election results are officially gazetted, Pakatan Rakyat should immediately file Election Petitions in court. In the meantime they should gather the evidence in preparation. Umno and Barisan Nasional ...

The expected happened

News image

Now do you understand the reason behind all this talk regarding the Chinese Tsunami? You may hate Umno but you have to take your hat off to them ...

Have you heard of Catch 22?

News image

The problem is we are in a Catch 22 situation. We need a two-thirds majority in Parliament to be able to change the system. But the system will ...

Towards the 14th General Election (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Would PAS agree to separate religion from politics when religion is what puts them in power? Would Umno, MCA or MIC agree to separate race from politics when race is ...

The horse-trading in 2004

News image

I have been saying for years that Umno does not need to win 50% of the votes to win 50% of the seats. In 1969, the Alliance Party of Umno, ...



This Site is AnswerTips enabled. Just double click on any word on this site to get a quick reference.
You are here: Home MT COLUMNS When you got your degree from the back of a cornflakes box

Latest Posts - Malaysia Today

Popular Posts - Malaysia Today