.

MT COLUMNS We need political reforms, not just electoral reforms

We need political reforms, not just electoral reforms


Sunday, 15 July 2012 Super Admin
E-mail Print PDF
Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!MySpace!Yahoo! Twitter!LinkedIn! 

 

We had sent invitations to all the political parties in Malaysia, even those in Barisan Nasional, to attend the signing ceremony of The People’s Declaration. Only six responded, three of them from Pakatan Rakyat. The others ignored us. Hence I owe loyalty to only those who endorsed The People’s Declaration. And if they reneged on their commitment then I no longer owe them any loyalty since they have betrayed us and have sold us out.

THE CORRIDORS OF POWER

Raja Petra Kamarudin

Dear Raja,

I hereby inform you that the DAP has decided to endorse The People’s Declaration.

It’s indeed a great effort by your team of esteemed citizens. I was instructed by the party Secretary-General, Lim Guan Eng, to deliver the decision to you and your team.

Makkal Sakhti!

Berkhidmat untuk Rakyat dan Negara!

Ronnie Liu Tian Khiew

DAP CEC member and NGO Bureau Chief

http://mt.m2day.org/The_Peoples_Voice.pdf

http://mt.m2day.org/The_Peoples_Declaration.pdf

http://mt.m2day.org/Deklarasi_Rakyat.pdf

http://mt.m2day.org/Declaration_Chinese.pdf

Photographs of the signing of ‘The New Social Contract’ by the six non-Barisan Nasional parties in the run-up to the 12th General Election

******************************************

When the Liberal Democratic Party (LibDem) of the UK announced that it is seeking not just electoral reforms but political reforms, I immediately signed up as a party member. I too felt that Britain needed political reforms, not just electoral reforms. After all, the UK too has declined into a ‘sick society’, if you know what I mean.

When the UK saw a hung Parliament and both Labour as well as Conservative could not form the government without LibDem, I was in agreement that LibDem form a coalition with Conservative instead of Labour, although before the elections LibDem had said that in the event of a hung Parliament it would go with Labour. This is because Labour talked about electoral reforms while Conservative agreed to go for political reforms.

Earlier, in Malaysia, we too talked about political reforms, as opposed to Bersih, which talks just about electoral reforms. I felt that mere electoral reforms are not good enough. We need more than that. We need political reforms, electoral reforms being just one component of political reforms. We need an entire change of system, not just better elections, because better elections and a change of government will not guarantee us a change in the political system.

I was elated when Ronnie Liu sent me that official letter above indicating that his party, DAP, had endorsed The People’s Declaration, which is a document regarding an entire reform package. Subsequent to that, an official signing ceremony was held with six non-Barisan Nasional political parties, three of them within Pakatan Rakyat -- PKR, DAP and PAS (as the photographs above show).

Post-2008 General Elections, Pakatan Rakyat appears to have done a U-turn on its promise, which was earlier made with no conditions attached. Now it appears like there are other priorities that first need to be addressed before we can talk about ‘the bigger picture’. This was not declared during the signing ceremony. During the signing ceremony, The People’s Declaration was accepted with no conditions attached.

I felt betrayed in 2010 during the talk in London attended by Anwar Ibrahim, Tian Chua and Tunku Aziz Tunku Ibrahim (that was before I decided to go to the mainstream media). When I raised the issue of the promise that Pakatan Rakyat had made before the 2008 General Election that The People’s Declaration, which had been accepted prior to the election, would be implemented, the response I received was that it could not be done yet for various reasons. It appears like what was promised more than two years before could not be delivered after all.

In a talk in Australia soon after that, Anwar told the audience that Pakatan Rakyat cannot listen to Raja Petra, who lives thousands of miles away in England. That was not just a slap in my face but a violation of the people’s trust and a betrayal of the cause. Pakatan Rakyat can’t seem to understand that this is not about me but about the promise they made to the voters. But they are making it appear like this is about what I want rather than about what they promised the voters and are now telling the voters they cannot deliver on this promise.

Of course, with the spinning by the alternative media, they made it look like I was becoming personal and that my grievances were a personal issue. The issue that this was Pakatan Rakyat’s promise to the voters and not at all a personal agenda of mine was downplayed. It would have been more honest for Pakatan Rakyat to declare that although it had committed itself to The People’s Declaration, that pre-election commitment could no longer be met. Pakatan Rakyat should make its stand clear instead of spinning the whole issue as something personal on my part.

The next general election will be upon us in the next few months, maybe nine months from now. Pakatan Rakyat should state now whether it is still committed to The People’s Declaration. I cannot force them to agree to The People’s Declaration. I am in no position to do that and in a democracy no one should be forced to do something that he or she does not want to do. However, at least we will know where we stand and we will not be under the misconception that this is the agenda whereas this is not so.

If Pakatan Rakyat feels that The People’s Declaration is not workable and is no longer an opposition agenda then I am prepared to drop the whole issue and no longer pursue the matter. The important thing is I will know where I stand and also where Pakatan Rakyat stands. Then there will be no confusion as to what each of our agenda is.

During the 2008 General Election, I campaigned for Ronnie Liu and Nurul Izzah Anwar. At Ronnie’s request, I also campaigned for DAP, but only in Selangor and Penang. I made it clear that I do not wish to campaign for anyone other than Ronnie and Nurul Izzah and I turned down all the invitations I received from PKR and PAS to speak at their ceramahs.

During the 2008 General Election, I was not a party member of PKR, DAP or PAS. I presented myself as a Blogger, an independent political activist, non-partisan although political. In my speeches during the ceramahs, I made it very clear that I support those parties that support The People’s Declaration.

We had sent invitations to all the political parties in Malaysia, even those in Barisan Nasional, to attend the signing ceremony of The People’s Declaration. Only six responded, three of them from Pakatan Rakyat. The others ignored us. Hence I owe loyalty to only those who endorsed The People’s Declaration. And if they reneged on their commitment then I no longer owe them any loyalty since they have betrayed us and have sold us out.

Pakatan Rakyat needs to do the honest thing here. They must make a declaration as to whether they are still with us on The People’s Declaration. If the answer is ‘no’ I can live with that. Then at least the confusion can be cleared up.

As I said, I am not a member of PKR, DAP or PAS. In fact, I am a member of the LibDem in the UK. My interest in Malaysia is only as far as political reforms are concerned. If there are going to be no political reforms then I no longer have any interest in Malaysia. I can then put Malaysia Today to sleep and not waste so many hours a day of my time doing what I have been doing for the last 14 years since the birth of the Reformasi Movement.

I am not pro-Barisan Nasional. I am not pro-Pakatan Rakyat either. I am pro-political reforms. And I will support any grouping that aspires for political reforms.

I have no interest in changing the government. To me, who gets to form the government is not crucial. What is crucial is what that government stands for. And if the government commits itself to political reforms then I will support that government.

Governments are mere vehicles. It is a vehicle for getting from point A to point B. What vehicle we use is not important. Getting from point A to point B is. Hence let us focus on the journey, not on the vehicle. And the vehicle that serves this purpose must be the one we choose.

So tell me, is this vehicle going to be Pakatan Rakyat? If my journey into seeing political reforms is met through Pakatan Rakyat then well and fine. If it is not going to be met through Pakatan Rakyat, that is also well and fine. But we will need to know before we go to the ballot box and not after we have voted. I am sure that is not too much to ask for.

 


 

Language Translation

subscribe to Malaysia Today news

RosseberryShop.com

MT Cartoon

NO HOLDS BARRED

Time and place decides what’s fair

News image

For all intents and purposes, this article is a purely academic exercise to discuss the issue of fair or fairness. I have attached the issue of election boundaries (in t...

The Sedition Act (1948)

News image

The Sedition Act started life as the 1351 English Statute of Treasons. Hence sedition is closely associated with treason. In the 1500s, King Henry VIII broke away from Rome a...

And then came CHINRAF

News image

The absence of Chinese representatives in the Cabinet should it happen will not pose major problems to the government or Chinese community, an academician said today. Selangor DAP chief T...

Tan Sri Wong Foon Meng (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Can you see that long before the 2008/2013 Tsunami, the Malays and Chinese of Kuala Terengganu already set aside their racial/political differences and supported the candidate rather than the r...

Shaping the mind of the Malay

News image

You can see the Malay swing in 1946. Then they swung back and took another swing in 1959. Then they swung back and took another swing in 1969. Then t...

Zahid Hamidi should be asked to resign (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

So, yes, we too in the UK were not happy with the system. And we ‘sold out’ the ruling party and ‘toppled’ the government because we were not happy w...

Is beer halal or haram? (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Now, what I do not understand is: why emphasise ‘on a Chinese woman’? The Chinese scream that they are not racists. Yet they send me this very racist e-mail. T...

Should I leave Islam if I am not happy?

News image

Okay, I am also not happy with some Muslims, even some Muftis for that matter. I think they are very intolerant, unreasonable and narrow-minded. What are you going to n...

Citizenship, Bahasa, the Constitution, and the Police Force

News image

The IGP, Ismail Omar, will be retiring tomorrow. Do you know that many senior police officers do not think highly of him? That is because he is considered too l...

The wheat from the chaff

News image

Now, just like many of you, I was ecstatic in March 2008 when Pakatan Rakyat won five states and managed to deny Barisan Nasional its two-thirds majority in Parliament b...

Racism (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Racism is usually defined as views, practices and actions reflecting the belief that humanity is divided into distinct biological groups called races and that members of a certain race s...

Another well laid trap, maybe?

News image

But since March 2008 many of you have become very arrogant. You no longer care about what you say. And you no longer care whether anyone gets hurt by w...

So what is it then?

News image

In the run-up to the 13th General Election, the Chinese were boldly and proudly screaming that this time around the Chinese are going to unite and vote against Barisan N...

Understanding the “first past the post” voting system

News image

Professor John Curtice, of Strathclyde University, said: “The Lib Dem vote is more concentrated than it was, because they have targeted certain seats. But it is still more evenly d...

GE13 and the 13 predictions that came true (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Many are waiting for my ‘I told you so’ article. No, I am not...

What it all boils down to (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Now, if I were to bet RM100,000 on Pakatan Rakyat winning more than 100 seats, I might most likely win RM100,000. However, if I were to bet R...

Fallacies are not truths (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

However, I have monitored the news reports from both the mainstream media and alternative media over the last week since Nomination Day and what are the issues they are t...

Now do you understand? (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Say Pakatan Rakyat does win the general election in two weeks time. How many of those pro-Umno or pro-Barisan Nasional people will remain pro-Umno or pro-Barisan Nasional? Would they n...

When we have to lick back our spit

News image

Can we Malaysians ever play the game with sportsmanship? Can we ever fight using Queensberry rules? Unfortunately when we Malaysians play or fight there are no rules or sportsmanship. E...

The NATO Syndrome (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

And how many of you signed the petition asking for Dr Wan Azizah to be given a seat to contest the coming general election? Do you know and do y...

THE CORRIDORS OF POWER

It’s all about strategy (UPDATED with Chinese translation)

News image

Then came the 2008 general election and the impressive results gave everyone a lot of hope. So everything that was said earlier was now forgotten. But what they forgot is ...

The day ‘they’ sold out Sarawak (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

The Chinese who kept Taib in power were rewarded for their support and all the transgressions, abuse of power and corruption that is being perpetuated by Taib and his family, ...

The rats leaving the sinking ship

News image

So they are now embarking on an asset-stripping exercise. Chua Soi Lek, Tan Chai Ho, Vincent Lee Fook Long, Kat Swee Sang, and a few other MCA taikos are shifting ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 13) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

While Barisan Nasional was confident it is guaranteed no less than 130 parliamentary seats -- with 145 as an achievable target -- Pakatan Rakyat, in turn, was equally confident it ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 12) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

If I were to hazard a guess I would say that Khairy is the man to watch. He is going to be the ‘face’ of the reformed Umno who will ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 11) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

They recently did a poll in Pakistan and 11% voted in favour of a democracy, 22% in favour of military rule, and 53% in favour of the Khalifah system. The ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 10) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Out of the 89 parliamentary seats that Pakatan Rakyat won, 53 are non-Malay/Muslim seats while only 36 can be said to be Malay/Muslim-majority seats. Umno, however, won 88 seats just ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 9) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

You may argue that the Chinese voters have rejected the Chinese from Barisan Nasional and hence the Chinese should not be in the government. But if the Sultan ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 8) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Hence the percentage in votes has never matched the percentage in seats. This has always been the case since Merdeka and is called gerrymandering, perfectly legal all over the world ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 7) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

The problem is not so much what to do with Najib. If Najib were to be ousted, just like Pak Lah was soon after the 2008 general election, then Deputy ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 6) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

We once found a few names registered at a cemetery (now that is what I would call real phantom voters). In fact, Azmin Ali’s dead father was still a registered ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 5) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

And that would mean Umno’s days are numbered when more Malays move away from Umno and swing over to PAS and PKR in the spirit of Pakatan Rakyat. And this ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 4)

News image

Anwar’s knee-jerk reaction when the results were announced on Sunday night was that Pakatan Rakyat won 51% of the votes so this means Pakatan Rakyat won the election. In 1933, ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 3) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

What Najib did not suspect was that some other Barisan Nasional leaders from Sabah and Sarawak wanted to follow Lajim Ukin and Wilfred Bumburing when they crossed over. However, Anwar ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 2) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Umno has still not recovered from this shock and even Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad is pissed big time. He is blaming Najib for wasting his time and the government’s resources ...

In the aftermath of May 5th (part 1) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Once the election results are officially gazetted, Pakatan Rakyat should immediately file Election Petitions in court. In the meantime they should gather the evidence in preparation. Umno and Barisan Nasional ...

The expected happened

News image

Now do you understand the reason behind all this talk regarding the Chinese Tsunami? You may hate Umno but you have to take your hat off to them ...

Have you heard of Catch 22?

News image

The problem is we are in a Catch 22 situation. We need a two-thirds majority in Parliament to be able to change the system. But the system will ...

Towards the 14th General Election (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Would PAS agree to separate religion from politics when religion is what puts them in power? Would Umno, MCA or MIC agree to separate race from politics when race is ...

The horse-trading in 2004

News image

I have been saying for years that Umno does not need to win 50% of the votes to win 50% of the seats. In 1969, the Alliance Party of Umno, ...



This Site is AnswerTips enabled. Just double click on any word on this site to get a quick reference.
You are here: Home MT COLUMNS We need political reforms, not just electoral reforms

Latest Posts - Malaysia Today

Popular Posts - Malaysia Today