This reminds me of the National Mosque issue of 1999. Umno whacked the opposition for allowing Tian Chua, Gobalakrishnan and other ‘unclean’ non-Muslims to enter the National Mosque. But it is okay for Japanese, Taiwanese and ‘Mat Salleh’ non-Muslim tourists to enter the mosque because they are foreign tourists and not opposition supporters.
NO HOLDS BARRED
Raja Petra Kamarudin
PM wants full investigation into 'doa' issue
(Bernama) - Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak wants the police and Penang Islamic Religious Council to conduct a full investigation into the alleged use of Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng's name, replacing the Yang di-Pertuan Agong's, in the "doa" after the Friday sermon at some mosques in the state recently.
He said action must be taken against those responsible under the existing rules.
"I ask that this matter be fully investigated; who did it... as the delivering of Friday sermons is determined by the state Islamic Religious Council and people are not allowed to use our own script," he said at the handing of Raya goodies for the Malaysian Armed Forces, here, today.
Penang Umno liaison chief Ahmad Zahid Hamidi was this week reported to have revealed the use of Lim's name in the "doa" recited after the Friday sermon at some mosques in the Permatang Pauh and Jelutong areas recently.
"What happened was clearly against the state Islamic Religious Council's ruling and this should be investigated by the relevant authorities, and action taken in accordance with the stipulated procedures," said Najib.
******************************************
Umno denies lying, says six mosques dropped King’s name
(The Malaysian Insider) - Penang Umno has denied lying about state Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng’s name replacing the Yang di-Pertuan Agong in Friday sermons, saying that it has happened in six mosques since last February.
State liaison deputy chief Datuk Zainal Abidin Osman told The Malaysian Insider that he was unsure if Guan Eng knew of the trend but disclosed that six mosques had used the term “Chief Minister” or “Lim Guan Eng” in their sermons to replace that of the King, Tuanku Mizan Zainal Abidin.
The mosques are Masjid Jalan Baru in Seberang Prai Tengah which mentioned Lim’s name on Aug 13, Masjid Padang Menora, Seberang Prai Utara (June 25), Masjid Pengkalan Tambang, Permatang Pasir (in May), Masjid Jamek Jelutong, George Town (in April) and Masjid Permatang Binjai, Kepala Batas (Feb 26).
“And yesterday, Lim Guan Eng’s name was mentioned at the Masjid Kubang Buaya, in Butterworth by imam Ustaz Zakaria Ahmad... it was still being used despite media reports about the issue,” he said in a telephone interview yesterday.
“This is not an issue that was created, it actually happened,” said Zainal Abidin, who sits on the powerful Umno supreme council.
He also criticised DAP parliamentary leader Lim Kit Siang and Pakatan Rakyat (PR) de facto leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim for saying Umno and its newspaper Utusan Malaysia had created stories and racial ill-feelings towards the Penang government.
“It isn’t good for Lim Kit Siang to say we created this on purpose. Now there is proof, what are they going to say,” he said, asking the PR leaders to retract their statements.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak told the police and Penang Islamic Religious Council last night to conduct a full investigation into the matter, saying action must be taken against those responsible under the existing rules.
“I ask that this matter be fully investigated; who did it ... as the delivering of Friday sermons is determined by the state Islamic Religious Council and people are not allowed to use our own script,” he had said.
PR leaders have denied the Penang government had directed Guan Eng’s name be used to replace the King’s name but admitted it has been used by guest prayers leaders, who are out of their control.
Meanwhile, Zainal Abidin said Anwar had purposely defamed Umno by claimimg Penang Umno chief Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamid’s accusation was unsubstantiated as he had read the text of the sermons.
“Kit Siang should also retract his statement as this is something that happens at the grassroots,” he said, adding the practice of not mentioning the King’s name had started before Election 2008.
“Before the 2008 general elections, several mosques controlled by PAS did not mention the name of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong or the Governor but after the 2008 general elections, it has become a normal phenomenon in Penang,” he added.
He described it as a bad act that can divide the people in the state especially the Muslims.
“It is as though we don’t acknowledge the existence of royalty and the Yang di-Pertuan Agong. This is not good,” said Zainal Abidin.
When asked if the chief minister’s name was mentioned with the knowledge of Guan Eng, Zainal Abidin said he was unsure.
“I still believe ... Umno hopes the State Islamic Affairs Council, that every order made by the head of the State Islamic Affairs Council, is not influenced or controlled directly or indirectly by the Penang Chief Minister.
“We take a serious view ... the Islamic Affairs Council must control and ensure the sermon text is read fully. They must have full control,” he said, adding people must disregard the past and follow the decision of the Penang Islamic Affairs Council.
The Sermon Writing Committee is headed by the Penang Mufti Datuk Hassan Ahmad.
Zainal Abidin also said that those delivering the sermons should get approval from the Penang Islamic Affairs Council even they were guest prayer leaders.
He said this in response to an Utusan Malaysia report yesterday which quoted the Masjid Jamek Padang Menora imam Ibrahim Ishak as admitting that a guest prayer leader had mentioned the chief minister’s name when reading the Friday sermon recently.
The prayer leader had invoked Allah to open Guan Eng’s heart to accept Islam as his faith, the imam told the Umno-owned newspaper.
Ibrahim also admitted that the Yang di-Pertuan Agong’s name was not mentioned and he had censured the prayer leader for his mistake.
The imam had also said the mosque has a guest prayer leader to deliver the sermons every month, which will include a prayer for national leaders.
The Sinar Harian newspaper had quoted Jelutong Umno chief Abu Kassim Ismail as saying that sermons mentioning Guan Eng’s name is not new and has occurred between two and three months ago.
Zainal Abidin said the spate of incidents showed that guest prayer leaders must get permission from the state’s Islamic Affairs Council before being allowed to work.
“Don’t use the chief minister’s name in a sermon. Don’t use it in a prayer, if it is for good, OK but what if it is used to criticise, then it will cause dissension,” he added.
******************************************
Asri sees no wrong in praying for leaders’ well-being
(The Malaysian Insider) - Popular Muslim preacher Dr Mohd Asri Zainul Abidin has urged Pakatan Rakyat (PR) and Barisan Nasional (BN) to stop politicising the Penang sermon issue, saying it was acceptable to pray for the well-being of leaders.
Stressing that he was unsure if Umno’s allegations were true, the Penang-born Mohd Asri said that praying for Lim Guan Eng’s well-being in his capacity as Chief Minister was a minor issue.
“Don’t politicise this issue. I told Pakatan and also BN not to politicise it,” he said, adding that political parties need to work for the country and not always limit themselves to a partisan view.
“I am not siding with anyone... There are a lot of important things to be done for the people of this country... This issue is not really that important,” the former Perlis mufti said after returning from Mecca on Friday.
Penang Umno chief Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi claimed on Thursday that several mosques in the state had replaced the King’s name with Lim’s in their sermons.
PR de facto leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim hit back by claiming the allegations were a desperate attempt by BN to remain relevant, pointing out that he had personally read the text of the sermon.
When contacted yesterday, Mohd Asri explained to The Malaysian Insider that prayers fell into four categories. The first two involved praying that a leader receives guidance, and for a leader to be fair and sympathetic to the people.
“These prayers can be read whether or not the leader is Muslim or not,” he said.
He said the other two prayers involved wishing for the well-being of a leader even if he were unfair and outright praising of his leadership.
“These two cannot be done,” he said.
Mohd Asri also questioned why the prayer issue was being made a big deal of now despite the fact that there were political parties that prayed for a non-Muslim candidate’s election victory before.
He said if a prayer for victory could be read for a non-Muslim candidate, then a prayer for the well-being and guidance of a non-Muslim leader should be similarly permitted.
“There are prayers that can be done and prayers that cannot... Prayers for the sake of good, we can do,” he said.
He also advised that the sermon issue be solved fairly and factually from a religious point-of-view and not through emotional political platforms.
When asked about the alleged use of the chief minister’s name to replace that of the King, Tuanku Mizan Zainal Abidin, Mohd Asri said he was not aware of the claim having just arrived back in Malaysia.
Penang Umno deputy chief Datuk Zainal Abidin Osman told The Malaysian Insider yesterday that those delivering the sermons should get approval from the Penang Islamic Affairs Council even they were guest prayer leaders.
He said this in response to an Utusan Malaysia report the day before which quoted the Masjid Jamek Padang Menora imam Ibrahim Ishak as admitting that a guest prayer leader had mentioned the chief minister’s name when reading the Friday sermon recently.
Zainal Abidin said the spate of incidents showed that guest prayer leaders must get permission from the state’s Islamic Affairs Council before being allowed to work.
The police have so far received three reports over the Friday sermon issue involving some mosques in Penang. Home Minister Datuk Seri Hishamuddin Hussein said police were now investigating the allegation contained in the reports.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak yesterday ordered a full investigation into the matter by the police and the Penang Islamic Religious Council.
written by Divine, August 23, 2010 21:50:23
-
- +11
-
-
written by Davy McChester, August 23, 2010 13:08:24
-
- +33
-
-
written by Angela Ooi, August 23, 2010 12:17:20
RPK is so right - many Muslims are doing a great job dissing their own religion.
What puzzels me is why the majority decent moderates who do not subscribe to these acts or words, stay silent or unaffected, when their religion is being used for political and selfish gains are also doing their religion a dis-service. Please SHOW us Islam is just, good and loving.
-
- +49
-
-
written by IbnAbdHalim, August 23, 2010 11:56:09
-
- +36
-
-
written by eskay, August 23, 2010 11:14:27
-
- +50
-
-
written by Aria, August 23, 2010 05:56:08
-
- +80
-
-
written by NollanBD, August 23, 2010 05:25:52
Now tell me if there is anything wrong with these. It is after all God's wish that Lim Guan Eng becomes the Penang Chief Minister.
-
- +116
-
-
written by Motherchell, August 23, 2010 02:09:25
Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak wants the police and Penang Islamic Religious Council to conduct a full investigation
-
- +84
-
-
written by Fart Fart Wah, August 23, 2010 01:53:34
But we have people who do not want to pray for kafirs ( because he is not a muslim) But Kafirs are praying that the non-kafirs will be good, fair and follow their religion well, however this is not appreciated because a kafirs prayer is not accepted by Allah...because Allah is also a Muslim...QED. and that is how the degenerative brain of MOOOfti Ass a rani works. And those who follow UMNO will agree that kafirs who pray for them are praying ineffectually ..for Allah ONLY HEARS A MUSLIM'S prayer...when the others pray he shuts his ears and turns down the volume of the loud speaker or MIC system or maybe he cannot hear as the others do not use a 200 kilowatt loudspeaker 5 times a day...strange this Allah.. I cannot understand him as the Moofti and Muslims in UMNO explain to me....I must be bloody stupid or I must be praying to Satan who is playing God...
-
- +51
-
-
written by mikemui, August 23, 2010 01:28:01
-
- +76
-
-
written by Daryl, August 23, 2010 01:11:20
-
- +122
-
-
written by Navigator, August 23, 2010 01:07:24
-
- +81
-
-
written by temanmu, August 23, 2010 00:55:20
Penang State govt should sue those rumour-starters which will compel them to provide hard evidence.
Proceeds from the civil suit go to the poor.... courtesy of Utusan Malaysia!
-
- +55
-
-
written by Malaysiaputra, August 23, 2010 00:07:48
-
- +70
-
-
written by onnetline, August 22, 2010 23:19:57
-
- +98
-
-
written by OrangKaya, August 22, 2010 23:17:53
-
- +67
-
-
written by onnetline, August 22, 2010 23:13:13
Then, what would be strange about these same Malays lying and framing innocent people ?
-
- +97
-
-
written by Eskay345, August 22, 2010 23:08:21
It all boils down to "wang, wang and more wang.
With money to be collected from those foreign tourists, semuanya OK.
-
- +74
-
-
written by onnetline, August 22, 2010 22:49:48
You, ARMNO mudderfcukkers may be moronic idiots but the rest of the Malaysians are not !
-
- +121
-
-
written by a guest, August 22, 2010 22:41:23
-
- +85
-
-
written by cheekhiaw, August 22, 2010 22:15:41
You don't visit they say you no respect. You go they say you dirty.
-
- +43
-
-
written by Motherchell, August 22, 2010 21:58:55
-
- +120
-
-
written by Better My, August 22, 2010 21:27:40
Islam nd politics must not mix, other than the relgion acting as a guide for malaysia leaders to do the right things.
This is not Islam bashing, as what Malay Ultraman said before. This is about getting on with good government and not allowing religious issue get in the way to improve the Penang Malays/others races standard of living and help Malaysia, as a whole.
-
- +78
-
-
written by Semuaok, August 22, 2010 20:55:53
-
- +142
-
-
written by zeus, August 22, 2010 20:32:38
-
- +138
-
-
written by educationist, August 22, 2010 20:23:57
Even if they are not lies, the perpetrators of the sinister act and those who ordered it must be exposed!!
I believe it's part of the plot to ferment the right condition to justify the UMNOputras use of the ISA!!
-
- +87
-
-
written by Hanuman, August 22, 2010 20:22:07
-
- +137
-
-
written by wali10, August 22, 2010 20:15:07
Pray to yg Esa. Doalah yang baik2 untuk semua manusia didunia ini, Doalah untu keamanan dunia, tak salah.
-
- +111
-
-
written by philip25, August 22, 2010 20:09:52
-
- +204
-
-
written by Den, August 22, 2010 20:08:24
-
- +99
-
-
written by malgal, August 22, 2010 19:05:53
-
- +83
-
-
written by malsia1206, August 22, 2010 18:33:58
2. UMNO's profess of their religion in such preconceived and distorted nature among their members is ruining the country.
3. The so-called primary leaders and the Cabinet Menteris sitting cosy in Putrajaya are ruining this country.
4. Their puppet Institutions like the Polis, AG, Election Commission and MACC are all ruining this country.
5. The common sense of the rakyat with their discipline and maturity is the one and only remaining ingredient that holds the true harmony and brotherhood of all Malaysians. We can all manage to hold the country together better and more efficiently than all those destructive elements above.
-
- +125
-
-
written by Kacang Tanah, August 22, 2010 18:05:23
-
- +232
-
-
written by Nunuk Ragang, August 22, 2010 17:58:54
Do you know that R.C (Roman Catholics)never fail to pray during every Mass( Prayer Session) that our country's leader(i.e the PM will rule upon Malaysians justfully??)
Every mass without fail... and i repeat..every mass without fail....
-
- +243
-
-
written by sleeper, August 22, 2010 17:47:27
yawn... same old granny tactics.. its kinda bored thou... anything new?
Some how.. what I can noticed is that.. they put Islam at their side of their lips.. but do they really practise that hard?
All religion in the world teaching is peace to the world... not fighting each other...
day and nite.. they preaching.. they fighting for Muslim... the real question ... do they?
yawn...
-
- +128
-
-
written by hellosunshine, August 22, 2010 17:23:09
-
- +317
-
-
