.

ARCHIVES What’s in a name?

What’s in a name?


Tuesday, 08 December 2009 Super Admin
E-mail Print PDF
Digg!Del.icio.us!Google!Live!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!MySpace!Yahoo! Twitter!LinkedIn! 

 


By Deborah Loh, The Nut Graph

IF there is one enduring debate in Malaysia, it is whether this country is an Islamic or secular state. No less because successive prime ministers keep making declarations that it is an Islamic state to much public confusion.

Islam is the official religion of the federation. But what does "official" mean? Are we being made to choose between an Islamic state or a secular one?

At the Bar Council's launch of its Constitutional Law Committee's MyConstitution or PerlembagaanKu campaign on 13 Nov, the public forum that followed the launch saw this issue being raised again with a question from the floor.

What is Malaysia?

The panel of lawyers and academics were divided. Human rights and constitutional lawyer Malik Imtiaz Sarwar said a secular state was good for Islam to flourish.

Universiti Malaya law lecturer Assoc Prof Dr Azmi Sharom said the Federal Constitution was a secular document, from which even the syariah courts derived their powers. The state was secular, he argued, because none of its institutions got their powers from religious authority, but from the constitution.

READ MORE HERE 


Comments (5)Add Comment
...
written by SeriousLy, December 08, 2009 21:47:33
Well, Now MALAYSIA IS AN UMNO STATE, NO BODY IS CONFUSED ABOUT THIS. More 50 years ago; the British that wanted to have this State knows that Chinese are big trouble so they decided better to call this State a Malay State! Definitely, this country is not a DEMOCRATIC STATE!smilies/grin.gif Even though that Malaysia is a Commonwealth State, we do not need to be stupid to keep the laws that the British set up to keep us in a CONFUSED STATE! The UMNO Kings, Queens, Prices' and Princesses thinks that this country belongs to them and the people of Malaysia will forever vote and serve them! smilies/grin.gif Then it may be a PROBLEMATIC STATE that now UMNO continue to rule Malaysia as a POLICE & CORRUPTED STATE! smilies/cheesy.gif Worse at this point of time that now we are in DIVIDED STATE even that the Opposition won a few STATE! smilies/tongue.gif
...
written by BAYANGKARA, December 08, 2009 21:36:49
Malaysia is a secular state.

Assoc Prof Dr Azmi Sharom is the most logical, well-reasoned and substantive of the lot. He draws the highest authority for his argument from the constitution, the mother from which all legislative power is derived, including the power pass sharia laws. Our first PM said so. He also said that Islam was the official religion for ceremonial purposes only. The Reid and Cobbold Commissions reports also referred to the constitution as a secular. Is that so hard to understand?

Aziz Bari and Sulaiman Abdullah? Have a good laugh!! What shallow interpretations!

The picture was first muddled by none other than Mamakutty and then later by the muddle-headed, wavering Bodowi and the medieval hordes from UMNO.

To all the protagonists of an Islamic state, be true to the religion and to yourself. What's so Islamic about Malaysia? Rituals, banning beer, banning concerts, praying five times a day and going through the motions of what you perceived to be Islamic do not constitute the essence of Islam. The worst crimes have been committed by people who professed to be Muslim. As RPK so boldly and so often put it, Muslims themselves are responsible for the worst perceptions of Islam and Muslims.

Practise the wholesome principles of justice for all, equality for all races, governance for the people, protection of the weak and minorities, tackle corruption and bring the perpetrators of murder, rape, theft, robbery and other crimes to account including the rich and powerful, then Malaysia would have some semblance of a true Islamic state. Never mind if the label says "secular". You can be Islamic in deed and practice so long as you are fair, non-racist, just and honest. Preach the truth and practise what you preach.......lIke Tok Guru. I can live with that.

...
written by eloofk, December 08, 2009 20:32:13
Whether the government in this country declares that the country is an Islamic or a Secular state is of no importance as long as the country, being a multi-racial, multi-religious society must be governed with tolerance of each other different racial and religious mix and adhere to the basic foundation as enshrined in the Constitution.
...
written by Watchdog, December 08, 2009 20:05:59
Mahathir gave this issue a life of its own and it has now grown beyond control. You cant rein it in. He will die and we have to live with the demon he has conceived for political expediency ( I do not mean to say Islam is demonic lest those goons go and cut a dog's head)
...
written by michael chick, December 08, 2009 19:30:31
Good thoughts. Brave for articulating them. But dUMNO will try to silence you.
Watch out for the legendary C-empat

People who are confused, go to have a nice chat with Sisters-in-Islam.
Yes, you can tell them that I sent you there too.

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comments.

busy
 

Language Translation

TwitterFacebook Twitter


 
 

NO HOLDS BARRED

Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen

News image

Malaysians in general, Malaysia Today readers included, do not appear to understand the me...

About respecting sensitivities

News image

I had always assumed that the Malays are backward thinking and superstitious whereas the non-Malays are enlightened. I had always wanted the Malays to break out of their feudalistic and ...

Just the tip of the iceberg (Updated with Chinese Translation)

News image

When I am lying all alone in my bed at home and dying from the bitter cold and starvation I really don’t care two fucks about colours of envelopes or ...

About orphanages and old folks’ homes (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Yeah, sure, they are victims, they are poor, they are ignorant, they have been used for political purposes, they have been tricked, yada, yada, yada….But what have you done for ...

Prostitutes can kill you (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Inilah Cina! If you go to a prostitute and you die after swallowing your dentures that is your problem. Stop screaming and shouting! And if you go to Perkasa’s Chinese ...

Malaysia Today’s Annual Report

News image

As follows are the statistics for Malaysia Today from 1st January 2011 to 31st...

When English is not your mother-tongue

News image

What is even more irritating is that these people are pretending they do not understand what Anwar said (like they are pretending they do not understand what Karpal said). Actually ...

This is what I am talking about

News image

As I said earlier, the government that is going to plan Malaysia’s future beyond 2020 is not about a popularity contest between two people. It is about what ...

What do you mean by ABU? (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

So, no, do not say if you are not with us then you are against us. That is a line borrowed from President Bush. Look at the bigger picture. It ...

We need to educate the VOTERS

News image

Like I said, it is not the 6 million Unique Visitors that I am monitoring but the NEW visitors. We need to reach new readers -- the not yet committed ...

THE CORRIDORS OF POWER

EPISODE 1: How East Malaysia and Terengganu were robbed of their wealth

News image

In 1973, Barisan Nasional was launched and PAS became part of the federal government. In 1974, the new ruling coalition in Parliament (where all the opposition parties e...

Would MCA dare do what it’s telling DAP to do?

News image

Hence, Malaysia is already implementing Islamic laws and has been doing so long before Merdeka or Independence of 31st August 1957. So why is MCA talking as if Malaysia d...

Dear Muhyiddin Yassin

News image

In Islam, Saudi Arabia would not exist. Neither would Iran, Iraq, Turkey, or whatever. All would no longer exist. And Malays too would cease to exist. In Islam, a n...

The mind is willing, the flesh is weak

News image

So, what we are seeing here, which Tony Pua did not address, is actually a fight to become the next Prime Minister. And for those (other than Anwar) who w...

Understanding the voters’ psyche (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Currently, the election campaign is based on who do you want as the next Prime Minister: Najib Tun Razak or Anwar Ibrahim? If you want Najib then vote Barisan N...

Understanding the voters’ psyche (part 2) (UPDATED with Chinese Translation)

News image

Right and wrong is a point of view, not about evidence. And no 63,000 information campaigners can change this perception. Those who think that Anwar is innocent will continue t...

The super virus

News image

And this is what the then Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad said back in the 1980s. He told Malaysians that the Sultans are not above the law. The S...

To file or not to file, that is the question

News image

This is not about Anwar. I repeat: this is not about Anwar. It is about Najib’s survival. Najib has seen what happened to Abdullah Badawi. He knows that this w...

It's all about DUIT

News image

In 2005, the court ruled in favour of the residents and declared the flats illegal. It also awarded damages to the residents and declared MBPJ's development order issued to M...



This Site is AnswerTips enabled. Just double click on any word on this site to get a quick reference.
You are here: Home ARCHIVES What’s in a name?

Latest Posts - Malaysia Today

Popular Posts - Malaysia Today