A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow No Holds Barred arrow Malaysia’s two systems of justice

Malaysia’s two systems of justice PDF Print E-mail
Posted by admin   
Tuesday, 03 June 2008 12:27

Image

Last month, Umno Johor said that the greatest mistake they made was in giving the non-Malay immigrants citizenship in August 1957. Now that they have been given citizenship they show their ingratitude by voting for the opposition.

NO HOLDS BARRED

Raja Petra Kamarudin 

Verse 13, chapter Al-Hujurat of the Quran, can be translated to read: "O Mankind! We have created you from a male and female, and made you into nations and tribes, that you may know one another. Verily, the most honourable of you in the sight of Allah is he who has most righteous (taqwa) among of you. Verily, Allah is All-Knowing, All-Aware."

With this verse from the Quran, Islam declares equality for all mankind. Islam respects a human for being a human and not for any other reason. Islam does not distinguish between the different races, different groups of people, or different ‘colours’.

The Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.) addressed the people signifying that concept during his last pilgrimage, saying: "O People! Your God is one; your father is one; no preference of an Arab neither over non-Arab nor of a non-Arab over an Arab or red over black or black over red except for the most righteous. Verily the most honoured of you is the most righteous."     

This is to assert that, in Islam, no nation (community) is created above other nations and therefore no nation can be placed above another. Man's worth in the eyes of men and in the eyes of God is determined by his skills, by the good he does, and by his obedience to God.

In another tradition, the Prophet, peace and blessings of God be upon him, was asked, "Who among men is most favoured by God?”

The Prophet replied, "A man who does the most good to people."

Excerpts of a speech by Imam Mohamed Baianonie at the Islamic Center of Raleigh, N.C.

ABIM is upset that I have used coarse or abrasive language when whacking them. They don’t mind being whacked as long as I do it politely. Okay, let us humour them then. If they like it gentle then let us give it to them gently. After all, not everyone likes their sex wild so I suppose that goes for how they get whacked as well, in and out of bed.

Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad said that 90% of the tax is paid by the non-Malays, in particular the Chinese. Tun Dr Mahathir cried during one Umno general assembly because, he said, he had failed to change the attitude and mentality of the Malays. When asked, after he had retired on 1 November 2003, what was his greatest regret; Tun Dr Mahathir replied that his greatest regret is not being able to change the Malays in the 22 years that he was Prime Minister of Malaysia. Tun Dr Mahathir once lamented: why can’t the Malays be more like the Chinese?

Yes, I know, many Malaysia Today readers hate Tun Dr Mahathir. Nevertheless, as much as you may hate the Tun, we should not overlook the good things he has done or said even though you may hold the opinion that he did more bad than good. After all, the British were colonialists and there can be nothing good about colonialism. However, when the British left, they left behind a good education, administrative and legal system.

Unfortunately, after we took over the running of this country, we Malayans messed the entire thing up beyond recognition. Notwithstanding all that, we still need to recognise the good the British did amongst all that bad, as much as we may dislike the British. Imagine if the Portuguese, Dutch or Spanish had been our masters until 31 August 1957. Malaysia, today, would be an absolute mess and we would not need Umno to mess the county up any further.

Okay, back to the issue of the day: whacking ABIM, Umno and the Malays-Muslims as gentle as I can. Read what Imam Mohamed Baianonie said. The message is clear. And it is the message of the Quran and of the Prophet Muhammad. Do I really need to explain things further or is what Imam Mohamed Baianonie said self-explanatory enough?

What is Islam? Is Islam just about rituals? What would rituals be without akidah? And what is the foundation of Islam? The foundation of Islam is justice. Islam is all about justice and nothing but justice. Without justice there would be no Islam. Muslims talk about the syariah and about the hudud legal system. Is not the syariah and hudud about justice? Are Muslims not taught that they must subscribe to the syariah and hudud because these are God’s laws and God deals with justice?

You just can’t separate justice from Islam. Without justice there would be no Islam. Islam would not exist without justice. Islam, with mere rituals minus the justice, would not be Islam. Saddam Hussein performed the rituals of Islam. But Saddam was not just. So Saddam was ousted and hanged by the neck until he died because he just performed the rituals of Islam minus the justice that Islam makes mandatory. Justice, justice, justice. That is what Islam decrees. And a ‘good’ Muslim who performs the rituals of Islam but is not just is put to death. That is Islam and that is how Islam dispenses justice.

ABIM says we should not whack the Muslims. And since, by law, Malays are Muslims then we should not whack the Malays as well. But is it okay for Malays to whack the non-Malays and non-Muslims?

What if the non-Muslims were to say they do not recognise Islam or the Quran because Islam and the Quran have been distorted over the last 1,400 years? What if the non-Muslims were to say that Islam and the Quran have been changed and are no longer the original Islam and Quran that Prophet Muhammad introduced 1,400 years ago? If the non-Muslims say this then they would be committing a crime under the Sedition Act. The non-Muslims would face punishment because they are not sensitive to the feelings of the Muslims.

But Muslims are permitted to say they do not recognise Christianity and the Bible because Christianity and the Bible have changed and have been distorted over the last 2,000 years and are no longer the original Christianity and Bible which Jesus introduced 2,000 years ago. Muslims can openly say this in the Friday prayer sermons and it is not seditious, even if this is not sensitive to the feelings of the Christians.

And why can Muslims say this but Christians can’t? Because Islam is the official religion of Malaysia and Christianity is ‘tolerated’ as long as it stays out of the way of Islam.

Sure, there are certain beliefs in Islam and certain beliefs in Christianity and both are entitled to their own beliefs. But while Muslims can openly express their beliefs, Christians may not. And Christians may not because Islam is the official religion of Malaysia. And Muslims say that Islam is a tolerant religion and that Islam believes in justice.

Muslims do not understand the meaning of the word justice. Justice, to the Muslims, is only what is good for the Muslims. And what is not good for the Muslims is unjust. And justice to the non-Muslims does not matter. Being unjust to the non-Muslims is not being unjust. This is because non-Muslims do not have equal rights to Muslims. Non-Muslims are immigrants and immigrants are second-class citizens.

Last month, Umno Johor said that the greatest mistake they made was in giving the non-Malay immigrants citizenship in August 1957. Now that they have been given citizenship they show their ingratitude by voting for the opposition. Yes, non-Malays, even those born in Malaysia, are immigrants. And, being immigrants, they must vote Barisan Nasional. And if they do not vote for Barisan Nasional then they are ungrateful.

Yes, voting is your right. This is your right according to the Federal Constitution of Malaysia. Malays can vote for whomsoever they would like to vote for because the Constitution allows them to do so. Malays, therefore, can vote for the opposition. But, if you are non-Malay, then you must vote for Barisan Nasional because you are an immigrant. If you vote for the opposition then you are a traitor, you are ungrateful, and it was a great mistake giving you citizenship in 1957.

Tun Dr Mahathir’s father was born in India. But Tun Dr Mahathir can vote opposition. He can even oppose Umno like he is doing so now. In fact, he can even become the Prime Minister. He is not an ungrateful immigrant who should be sent back to India. Tian Chua, however, can’t oppose Umno. Tian Chua, whose family settled in Malaya long before the Portuguese came in 1511, is an immigrant. And if he is not happy and if he opposes Umno then he should go back to China. And Umno Johor regrets giving Tian Chua citizenship in 1957 but does not regret giving Tun Dr Mahathir citizenship.

Why? Because Tun Dr Mahathir is Muslim while Tian Chua is not. But if Tian Chua circumcises and takes on the Muslim name of Musa Bin Susah and marries a Malay woman, then he need not go back to China and Umno does not regret giving him citizenship in 1957.

The Malays have a very warped view of justice. Malays practice two standards of justice. There is one standard for the Malays and another for the non-Malays. And 90% of the tax is paid by the non-Malays and 10% by the Malays, says Tun Dr Mahathir. But 10% of the scholarships must go to the non-Malays and 90% to the Malays. And when they propose to change this to 40% for the non-Malays and 60% for the Malays, the Malays raise a hue and cry. And they call this justice. And they say Islam is about justice.

If this is an example of Islamic justice then I just shudder to think what would happen if Muslims start becoming unjust.

Comments (180)Add Comment
...
written by Rusty Hammer, June 03, 2008 12:44:08
I had my share of voting for ruling and opposition parties when i had the chance to do it.

As much as i love my Malaysia, being born in a chinese family had it's disadvantages to my family and me for all my 44 living years.

Which caused me to find a job overseas and avoids me paying tax in Malaysia. Indirectly i don't need to feed those in power to oppress me a valid Malaysian citizen. I'm sure there are alot more Malaysians working overseas like me for the same reasons.

Will i return to Malaysia one day? i will for sure. it's still my country - not China!
report abuse
disagree 20
agree 870
...
written by lennonist, June 03, 2008 12:45:20
Wow, this is a strong and nicely written slam dunk! Thank you for conveying exactly the thoughts on rational Malaysian minds about this issue.

Thanks for your fairness! That's all us non-Muslims, non-Malays ask. Great piece!
report abuse
disagree 13
agree 774
...
written by oknyua, June 03, 2008 12:48:14
A masterpiece again from RPK. But the one set me roaring was this paragraph:

Why? Because Tun Dr Mahathir is Muslim while Tian Chua is not. But if Tian Chua circumcises and takes on the Muslim name of Musa Bin Susah and marries a Malay woman, then he need not go back to China and Umno does not regret giving him citizenship in 1957.


I am thinking, had UMNO never existed, how would they hammer Tian Chua bin Susah ah?
report abuse
disagree 9
agree 297
...
written by malsia1206, June 03, 2008 12:51:07
A person need not be a true Muslim to practice the good and pursue the truth. Neither is he to be a Christian, Hindu or Buddhist. It's all essentially plain common basic human values. The religion is supposed to reinforce these values. The non-Malays have been accomodating the inequal and differntial treatment practised by the Alliance and Barisan Governments for 50 years. But for how long could they accomodate? Their grandparents did it. Their fathers did it too. But this new generation is not likey to acede what their former 2 generations had done. Even the slaves were set free. Even the coolies had become successful enterpreneurs. When is Malaysia prepared to accept these challenges? Are the Malays really proud in themselves to hide behind the NEP, quotas and preferential treatment? Do not all these make you inferior comparatively? And do they expect the Chinese and the Indians to owe them any favour or obligation just because they have Malaysian citizenship? Go down and and ask around to get your answers.
report abuse
disagree 12
agree 493
...
written by alberttan, June 03, 2008 12:53:40
A major cause of deviating from Islam was when a few "thinking" Malays decide to call themselves and other Malays "Bumiputera". Believe that long enough, and it has been long enough, and the Princes of the Earth starts believing Bumi owes them a good living, especially in BumiMalaysia. Empirically speaking, many bumiputeras are behaving exactly like their namesake where handout seeking, hiding behind righteousness and resorting to racial slurs are more important than Islamic truth and the Islamic way of life.
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 249
...
written by cwy, June 03, 2008 12:53:44
It is so good to be a Muslim in Malaysia!
If Tian Chua will ever circumcise to be called Musa bin Susah,
I won't hesitate to cut off some foreskin to be called Musang bin Buaya.
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 205
...
written by malaysianohope, June 03, 2008 12:54:18
Abang Pete,
It is without doubt these people in power still didn't get the message that they lost big time 0803 due to their arrogance and continue with the same shits post election day. Their ketuanan mentality seem embedded in their brains cannot to removed lest we have to have a second round of lesson for them and in time if Anwar carries with his promise, shall forever banish the thoughts of Malaysia for Umno but Malaysia for Malaysians.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 178
...
written by joeawk, June 03, 2008 12:56:17
I owe no allegiance to anybody or any party but my country andf my country is malaysia.

I can vote for anybody and any party and no one need question me because it is my prerogative.

This does not apply only to me but to all malaysians and all malaysians means those that carry the yellow and black mykad who can register and vote if they are of voting age and those with red ICs and who are being discriminated over the new comers among them the Indonesians and filippinos who were given ICs with one eye closed.

This also applies to all UMNO members who need not vote for UMNO or the BN if they are not happy with the UMNO candidates or their party. Th ey can always vote for the opposaition or throw their votes like what happened on March 8.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 125
...
written by lpfee, June 03, 2008 12:58:20
What to do, this is their mentality. Having this type of people,Malaysia can't progress far

I find this piece amusing ---

" But if Tian Chua circumcises and takes on the Muslim name of Musa Bin Susah and marries a Malay woman, then he need not go back to China and Umno does not regret giving him citizenship in 1957."
Ha! Ha! Ha!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 108
...
written by Richard Lo, June 03, 2008 13:00:51
RPK,

Thank God that you are bangsa malaysia!
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 239
...
written by Hockchew, June 03, 2008 13:01:02
Tun Dr Mahathir Mohd messed up the educational system of Malaysia, screwed up the Judiciary, politicised the civil services and neutralise the monarchy. R.I.P
report abuse
disagree 10
agree 192
...
written by Spear Bing, June 03, 2008 13:02:01
Justice and Injustice, Love and Hatred, Right and Wrong, Darkness and Light,Happiness and Sadness, Laughter and Sorrow, Peace and War etc., are all experienced in the playground of 'FORM', on the level of the relative.

The nature of politics is also a play of FORM, being dramatized by mortal beings like us and those time-trapped egoic mindsets mired in ignorance of their essential nature.
report abuse
disagree 5
agree 21
...
written by SocratesI, June 03, 2008 13:04:12

The problem with the Malays and Muslims in Malaysia is that they rationalize that since the non-Malays (hence also non-Muslims) are non-belivers, then they are infidels, and the normal Islamic justice should not "apply" to infidels. This conveniently circumvents the necessity of Justice in Islam and now is how the whole of Malaysia being administered ... one set of laws for the Muslims/ Malays, and another set for the non-Muslims/ non-Malays.

And parties like the Barisan Najis and UMNO perpetuate this "silent" implication that all these non-Muslims/ non-Malays should not enjoy Islamic Justice. This is the crux of the problem in Malaysia. Unfortunately for those of weaker mindsets in the Malay/ Muslim community, this sounds good to them as it guarantees preferential treatment, just because they are Malay/ Muslim. I guess these are the really mentally handicapped people in Malaysia who are unable to face Life's challenges squarely and fairly.

report abuse
disagree 1
agree 143
...
written by Motherchell, June 03, 2008 13:04:18
Justified with aLL fairness Pete, wonderfully argued. I have to admire the learned numbers of erudite Muslim Malay who totally agree with your facts. I wish the misguided will wake up and see the light to make Malaysia a country to reckon with in this global" village".

We must also say NO!! to racially grouped entities to see a better dawn .

Thank you Pete for your gem!!
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 107
...
written by Daryl, June 03, 2008 13:04:23
Maybe muslims need to think that Allah is not only a powerful one but with sense of humor. If someone insult him he will make it go away not by violence but with a smile. I think this is what Muslims not able to get away. They need to be the protector of their Allah when He knows that he just want them to led a good and honest life. If you believe your God is almighty you don't need to protect Him everytime some one throw an insult.
So. lead the life your Allah want you too not to end up be a protector of Allah because he can take better care of himself. Muslims need to be a walking testimony to others not an image of terrorist that only know how to solve problem with violence.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 108
...
written by Richard Lo, June 03, 2008 13:09:59
Indeed UMNO practise two standards. It is ok for UMNO to have racist policies because they stand to gain from these racist policies. It is ok for UMNO to make racist remarks because they feel that they are the prince of the soil. It is ok.

It is ok for God the almighty to have two standards. One standard to judge those who truly love and fear Him. The other to judge those who look like a muslim, act like a muslim but not a muslim no matter how you dissect him.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 75
...
written by teo siew chin, June 03, 2008 13:11:07
"..they left behind a good education, administrative and legal system..."
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

and for how many years did these 3 good systems continue to be effective?
can we not emulate those good systems again for surely they were not religion-based?
and if i am not mistaken, the Lady-of-Justice is blindfolded.
from YM RPK's copy of the Quran, all of us can expect justice and benevolence.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 36
...
written by kennyeu, June 03, 2008 13:12:03
The fact that as a Malay, Muslim and Malaysian you RPK, have the ability to see the truth and value true justice gives me hope for Malaysia.

Undermining all other races and religions benefits the Malays, but as a Malay you reject the idea because you know it is wrong. You give me hope that more Muslims and Malays will come to understand this and Malaysia will finally mature into a truly progressive nation. You are a gift that keeps on giving.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 161
...
written by smpadayachi, June 03, 2008 13:15:41
Pete thanks once again for making it possible for us to voice our opinions. Inspite of the disparities for some who feels your disparaging remarks to make your point across, we the steadfast community in Malaysia Today, strongly stand by your credence and word of honour to table a notion for everyone to understand in simple layman language what is been deprived been constitutional rights. Bravo Pete..and don't let those ABIM as well many more from the wood block are coming down in droves to attack any way they want.

Malaysians are no longer sitting and waiting for something to happen, and some are taking this strong measures & approaches for true democracy to flourish in the name of diversity. We've come this far, and there's no way turning back to see that we're retracting to our snail shells again. Everyone that loves true democracy to establish a strong pedestal for diversity to survive, must speak now, and forever not be silence by lompat tinggi lompat sikatak, and anything to that nature to sway people from not speaking up. Thanks Pete..from the bottom of our hearts to make this possible.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 76
...
written by amoker, June 03, 2008 13:15:55
Thanks for such a wonderful piece of writting. Indeed, it seemed that the whole movement is to convert everybody to become Muslims if you want to be a first grade citizen. A bumi who believes in other faith is ranked 2. Dunno how to rank Orang asli but if the OA converts, then he/she is a Malay (1st Class) and can get land title.

Why can't we utilize our strength of multiculturism. If we can enjoy each other's food, why can we enjoy each other's differences?
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 64
...
written by ez24get, June 03, 2008 13:16:20
The Malays have a very warped view of justice.


By and large, most malays that I know have a good sense of fairness. The only ones that have a very warped view of justice are the ones that evolve around UMNO.

Because of money and power, they are like flies that are attracted to the warped bulb that is UMNO, growing ever dimmer by the day! Everything that they touched will be twisted to the warped image that they see. In doing so, they will warp the things that they touch - Islam, education, justice, economy, whatever.

Not only do they have a warped view of justice. In sitting in a wheel chair and holding a tongkat, they see a warped view of themselves as handsome, towering giants whose expectation are for people to respect them as "tuan"!

Funny, isn't it? Those UMNOputras and the flies that evolves around them!
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 130
...
written by Kuku Burung, June 03, 2008 13:18:19
If this is an example of Islamic justice then I just shudder to think what would happen if Muslims start becoming unjust.

If not because of internationals and investors watchful eyes, they would have done more injustices. They try to claim that Malaysia is a model Islamic country, with beautiful Muslims. In international arena, they preach that justice is the way of life here. They even accuse the western countries of being unjust.
I like what you say, RPK, that if I change my name to Kuku binti Burung, and marry a Malay, suddenly all forms of justice become reality. Interesting country, out of this world.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 72
...
written by binkah1, June 03, 2008 13:19:34
Dear Pete, after following your posting over the years, i feel it is really God sent that Malaysia has a son which can be certified truely Malaysian. We Malaysian is forever grateful that in this time of darkness and man's selfishness, you have continue to bring on the light. May Allah bless you and your family.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 142
...
written by ringgo, June 03, 2008 13:20:20
dear rpk, your knowledge and understanding on islam is much better than those wearing ketayap,beard and jubah.i have a lot friends who never skip praying,recite quran (of course without translation) but beyond that know nothing.cannot differentiate rasuah and hadiah , mengumpat and racist.why? seldom read buku agama written in english by islamic thinkers, recite quran without knowing the meanings.and our ustaz? mostly backwards and read only buku buku ugama lama
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 59
...
written by Paramjothy, June 03, 2008 13:21:47
If the Johor UMNO member were good muislims and followed and understood the teaching of the Quran then they will not make such statements. Further more this moron's from UMNO Johor does not know their history well.They think they are the chosen people of Allah. Wait till they get there and see what they are in for.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 69
...
written by indianputra, June 03, 2008 13:23:34
A very powerful article by RPK. If such an article is written by a non-muslim, he will be immediately charged under sedition and jailed. After reading this article, as a non-malay and non-muslim, I am feeling small. I am feeling like a unwanted Malaysian. I feel I am not respected as a Malaysian. I feel like a second class citizen. I feel like a negro suppressed in my own country.

But I am a human being. I want to fight back for my rights. I want to tell all these upper class people to go to hell. I want to walk tall in society and if anybody says anything, I want to punch their face. I want to go and see the King and tell him to put a stop to this double standard in Malaysia. I want the non-Malays in this country to stand tall, not to be frightened, stand and demand the rights as a full fledged Malaysian.

Actually what am I asking for?
report abuse
disagree 7
agree 123
...
written by Raja Gasper, June 03, 2008 13:23:42
Good article.Citizenship..Does that matters now.What has given to Non-malays
can be taken back if there is a law to do so just like revoking the passport
of Hindraf leader P Wathamoorhty who is living in exile like Tibatean leader
Dalai Lama who was expel by China and yet received by the Rep of India.

It wouldn't be a suprise move if all the Indians and Chinese are deported
back from where they originated as a matter of cleansing excerise.By the
will of Allah this can be happen if that is the best way to protect malays
and Islam in this country from insult.

The Government can say from dust you came and to dust you return.We the
people who born with honey and the choosen race to dominate and to rule
the state by protectorship of Allah wills and unto us the rights given.

There is no mistaken in giving but if there is,than it was fake vs original
report abuse
disagree 115
agree 12
...
written by RickK, June 03, 2008 13:30:19
Hello Sir
Thank you for calling a spade a spade and doing it in your usual incisive wit and irrepressible logic. I believe and thank God that there are many other Malays out there who think like you. You all are the answer to my prayers!

report abuse
disagree 1
agree 73
...
written by quietguy, June 03, 2008 13:37:58
The Malays have a very warped view of justice. Malays practice two standards of justice.


As a Malay, I have to take offence with the above. I don't believe even RPK himself would presume to lump all Malays together. I for one believe in equality of justice regardless of race, and I believe many other Malays would too.
report abuse
disagree 9
agree 140
...
written by Flex65, June 03, 2008 13:41:21
Abang RPK how I wish you are the Prime Minister of Malaysia.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 94
...
written by malsia1206, June 03, 2008 13:43:16
This one is for YB Tian Chua. You have to consider "Musa bin Susah" with some serious thought. You could get all your motions deliberated in Parliament and passed by vote on show of hands. Get this passport for the easy ride. Like what they are doing for all these 50 years. Hidup YB Musa bin Susah @ Tian Chua!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 31
...
written by malgal, June 03, 2008 13:45:06
looks like only malays can vote any part, non malays must vote bn or risk being frogmarched back to wherever spot on earth their progenitors came into existence. like that one ah. if we didnt vote, we are not practising our democracy, if we did, we cannot choose of our own free will unless we are malay malaysians. maybe next election they will pass a law where only malays are allowed to vote ? damned if we do damned if we dont.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 29
...
written by Democrats, June 03, 2008 13:50:26
Quietguy,

Agree with you. I think although RPK is generalizing, it's not good to lump them all together. I've got many Malay friends who are Muslim, proud to be Muslims but ashame to be classified as Malays since UMNO seems to take Islam and mixed it into politics and race, saying they represent Malays and Islam.....

That is why true Muslims are open for inter religious forum to bridge the difference and understanding, while UMNO Muslims are against it, because without the religoius card as part of their justification, UMNO have nothing to fall back on other than just being pure "racist".
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 102
...
written by Zapper, June 03, 2008 13:52:51
I really do not understand what UMNO wants?? No matter how hard the non-malays try to be part of the country, they ended up on the chopping board whether in good or bad times. But the most of the malays do not behave like what UMNO portray them to be...equal respect and human decency irrespective of race and religion. Therefore, the more UMNO becoming a racist party, their relevancy in Malaysia politics come to nothing. Thats why PKR is acceptable.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 41
...
written by NRR, June 03, 2008 13:59:08
May be someone should pass a copy of the Constitution to the UMNO Johor so that they can see for themselves that UMNO did not give citizenship to the non-malays. It was a tacit agreement between all those who were involved in getting Independence for Malaya. It is like what Zapper says above. No matter how hard the non-malays try to be accommodative, UMNO will come from some corner of Malaysia and throw spanner in the works. This is mainly for their own survival. I have very good Malay friends and their families who will not hesitiate to give me helping hand anytime I am down and I will do the same for them. It is these politicians who ought to be disciplined and educated.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 62
...
written by mgeo, June 03, 2008 13:59:23
Brilliant! Many of us sincerely want to avoid serious thought, and will take form over substance. This is exactly what our public sevants usually offer. They constantly try to equate
Country = Government = Ruling Party.
and use "sensitivity" to supress rights.
But at least they do not claim, as in a neighbouring "developed" country, that it is illegal to insult a public servant!

Many of us seriously do not understand
(a) that the cultural viability of apparently homogeneous societies is
superficial, restrictive and comes at some cost.
(b) we have a major advantage in multiculturalism. Why do you think the "developed world" grabbing graduates from South-east and South Asia?
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 15
...
written by mountainking, June 03, 2008 14:00:04
aren't malays immigrants from Indonesia many years ago? so are the aussies in australia. then should we tell the indigenious ppl to kick the malays back to indonesia as they are being ungrateful in robbing peninsular, sabah and sarawak?

ultimately, the UMNO and ABIM are just twisting and creating sentiments amongst malays that they are going to lose their countries and the non-malays are going to rule this country. is so shallow for UMNO and ABIM to think that and i have faith in many malays who are smart enough not to take the bait.

what we are hoping now is to build a truly Malaysia that does not discriminate against race and religions.

let ABIM and UMNO be buried for they are not sincere in what they preach. all that they want is to stay in power to ensure the rest of the non-umno malays to remain stupid and use them like pros.

if UMNO is concerned for their own brother, let them donate most of their wealth to rebuild the poor malays all over malaysia. i hope many more malays are reading MT to realise that UMNO has bloody used their own ppl to enrich their own pockets all these years........
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 101
...
written by jchew, June 03, 2008 14:02:27
What UMNO wants is very simple, I am the boss, the rest are my servants!
Supreme race......
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 38
...
written by sampalee, June 03, 2008 14:04:51
This is 'Islam for Dummies'One cannot removes the sweetness from sugar[essence].But not all canes[forms] contain sugar.After this aticle,no one can even pretend they do not understand Islam[for the non-muslim malay basher too]
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 16
...
written by amjoem, June 03, 2008 14:07:35
YM Bapa Bangsa Malaysia,
You have God's gift of discernment.
We the 90% tax payers, but 2nd class citizens; perhaps thats what ABIM meant, yet they call themselves Muslims. The Umno Malays and the ABIM Muslims are not worth the salt of this earth. 100% of the UMNO Muslims are hypocrites. It is a shame for the Christians of Sabah & Sarawak to have voted for the BN. It is even more shamfull for the MPs of Sabah & Sarawak to yet remain as BN MPs in Parliament.
report abuse
disagree 5
agree 39
...
written by cwy, June 03, 2008 14:15:58
I suppose that I'm not wrong in saying that most Muslims in Malaysia are
' Artificial '.
report abuse
disagree 5
agree 23
...
written by businessman, June 03, 2008 14:16:32
------------------------------------------------------------
ANAK TIRI AKAN JadI ANAK TIRI MACAM MANA PUN
------------------------------------------------------------

Tak kisah apa yang kamu buat, tak kisah apa yang kamu sumbangkan untuk keluarga ini, kamu akan sentiasa digelar anak tiri. Sampai bila hal ini baru akan berubah? Sudah 50 tahun tapi masih sama saja.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 15
...
written by simply_say, June 03, 2008 14:24:06
Great piece RPK

Look at the Chinese descendant in Thailand. The prime minister is chinese, the army chief is a chinese. But thai always call themselves Thai. When will be the time when we all call ourselves
Malaysian?
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 102
...
written by densemy, June 03, 2008 14:26:14
"You just can’t separate justice from Islam".... unless you are a Muslim

Its a pity they dont preach messages like this one of RPK's in the mosques
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 34
...
written by grandmarquis, June 03, 2008 14:26:54
Well we have to face the reality that the world is unfair, and yet we have RPK, a Muslim talking about fairness to the non-Muslim. But we hardly see any non-Muslim talks about fairness to the Muslim. Walk around the earth and whenever you see non-Muslim outnumbered the Muslim, they would be mistreated.

I do not agree with the statement of UMNO Johor. It could just come out of some stupid mind. But face the reality. If 90% of the Chinese are paying the tax, do you think the Muslim in this country has not been fair to them? We may not get 100% of what we want, but please be thankful to what we have. Malays, despite having all the privileges are also not getting 100% of what they desire.
report abuse
disagree 78
agree 15
...
written by aneed2k, June 03, 2008 14:30:43
Well said Raja Petra Kamarudin.
Very well said.

The simplicity of the situation is actually the arrogance of the ruling coalition. They have been the 'reigning champions' champions for 50 years and believe that its their 'special right' to be the party that wins. Many mistakes were made and eventually the Rakyat caught up and on 08/03/2008 we gave them a wake up message.
Being the 'undisputed champions' for so long, they can't seem to accept the fact that there is a 'challenger' for them. The problem is they have the intellect of a delinquent, teenage, ape. They think the 'challenger' is the Rakyat. The ruling coalition has forgotten that their main duty is to maintain their mandate given by the Rakyat.
Statements like 'party above all else' and 'i will not accept the post as its against my principles' have been slung which clearly shows that these are the politicians that actually are working for the party and themselves, not the Rakyat.

If i recall well, one of the UMNO 'big guns' was the Minister of Education, he introduced this concept called KBSK and KBSM. Sorry if I am wrong but I'm pretty sure its either Mr. Keris or Mr. C4. Through these two concepts, the ministry expected to grow critical thinking skills amongst the school goers which would basically teach them about the importance of questioning the teacher rather than the old school method of consuming knowledge and vomiting it back out.

During the implementation of these concepts, the PM of Malaysia was none other than our longest reigning despot. We all know what he did when he was questioned. Simply look at how he carried out Ops Lalang and also how he oppressed the Reformasi movement in 1999.

Doesn't that sound as hypocritical as it gets? On one hand they teach the kids to think and make decisions. On the other hand they arrest those who think for 2 years without trial. Hmmm. Malaysian justice at its best.

I mean no disrespect to the achievements that Malaysia went through under his premiership but also have to understand that with every gain he gave us, the lost was also sustained by us.

But when they start saying that giving non-Malays citizenship was a mistake, i guess they have stopped thinking completely. There is this phrase used in the Malay language to implicate the moronic acts of a particular person or entity. It's called OTAK UDANG! I guess thats the case now as they no longer have a medical doctor as their president and are finding it hard to cure themselves of such 'PRAWN BRAIN' symptoms.

Raja Petra Kamarudin mentioned about TDM and his fathers lineage which hailed from India. Well, if you notice recently in his blog, TDM mentions "Tamil Indians in Malaysia". The reason for this is, he finds himself to be different from the "Tamil Indians in Malaysia" with the fact that he hailed from Kerala the land of the Malayalees. I don't mean anything bad about the people of Kerala as i know that they are absolute gems. I have made a personal trip there and I assure you the people there are not even close to our autocratic Ex-PM. What i would like Malaysia to see is the fact that he classifies people according to race. It seems to be a in built genetic problem that he has failed to cure. Departure from India only made him find another race to champion here in Malaysia-the Malays which he coyly cried in every speech stating that he failed to change them into better beings.

Anyway, to my friend, dear, Raja Petra Kamarudin.
I am sure we, Malaysians are not really bothered about the fact that TDM's heritage is from India anymore. He has been out of our 'Corridors or Power' for almost 5 years now. What we worry about actually is the temple braking, corrupted, concession giving, people oppressing, RM 9 mil stealing, two faced, toll charging, Indonesian that was the last MB of the State of Selangor.The state that we all look up to because you hail from this state and you are the blue blood of this state.

The irony is that even with all those mistakes, every five years, most Malaysians would wake up one morning, do their normal morning rituals, go to the nearby school and strike a cross next to the picture of a "dacing".

This year was a different scenario though. 49% of MY COUNTRY stood up in unison and told our politicians that; WE ARE ALL MALAYSIAN AND AS A MP, YOUR JOB IS TO SERVE US!!!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 100
...
written by cahaya, June 03, 2008 14:30:52
Dear RPK, Thanks for this commentary on justice. This morning, while browsing some other articles (from Feb. 200smilies/cool.gif, I read one where you shared stories from your school days. Among other things, you mentioned your initial difficulty getting a blue identity card. What an injustice! After all several generations of your paternal ancestors having lived (born here?) in Malaya. (It is no surprise your late father “hit the roof” because of that injustice. Later, when older, you understood the meaning of discrimination.) Perhaps your personal experience of once being treated as a “foreigner” has helped you to appreciate how non-Malays must feel when they get the “foreigner” treatment.
Thank you for being Bangsa Malaysia, and helping others to understand what that means!
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 56
...
written by glock17, June 03, 2008 14:38:21
Sad but this is truely a fact in malaysia politics.

Have you guys watch goverment propaganda TV? Some of those Omnoputras ultra narrow-minded ethno nationalist even hold the title in Doctorate but can't even utter any intelligent word when asked about Ketuanan Melayu diminishing power.

This old school of thoughts still crocodile tear when the racist-corruptive Omnoputras lost 5 1 states to PR start harping about how to comeback in power. You can see in their venomous heart how they wish Datuk Harun or those past amok pahlawan was still alive to take lead in restoring their personal agenda.

This is the shit all of us have to burden when this beloved country is lead by racist-corruptive politicians that have rule for the past 50 years. This retards from Omnoputras (so called intellectual) can't take constructive critism like a gentleman, when cornered and humilated in debates or arguments....their behaviour is on auto-pilot to the past 1969 glorious war won in the name of Ketuanan (i think its more like homocicidal spree running loose in the streets).

Such racist mentality is never good for this country. As long there is systematic racist discriminative law in this country....we will always be caught in the never ending venom of Omnoputras.

Glock17
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 17
...
written by glock17, June 03, 2008 14:46:17
One word to Omnoputras...you are not the supremacist chosen people of Allah. The chosen people of God r the Jews in Israel which you luv to bash 24/7 in your propagande media. This people have better intellectual genetic make-up compared with your retarded baboonic genes which have not evolved yet.

Dun try to copy what is not yours ...!!!
report abuse
disagree 12
agree 21
...
written by shiokguy, June 03, 2008 14:46:57
a patriotic Malaysian reject the offer to study in Singapore despite been let down by her own country..

Read link http://shiokguy.blogspot.com/2...rship.html
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 8
...
written by jshewsbury, June 03, 2008 14:48:28
Last month, Umno Johor said that the greatest mistake they made was in giving the non-Malay immigrants citizenship in August 1957. Now that they have been given citizenship they show their ingratitude by voting for the opposition. Yes, non-Malays, even those born in Malaysia, are immigrants. And, being immigrants, they must vote Barisan Nasional. And if they do not vote for Barisan Nasional then they are ungrateful.


Well.. is that means that they regret to have Sabah and Sarawak join the then Malaya as well ? The Sabahan and Sarawakian are bumiputra but they are not Malay....

Does UMNO Johor regret to have us the bumiputra of Borneo as citizen of Malaysia as well?

Dear UMNO Johor..... answer that question please...

Dear RPK, may we know who is the person making that statement? can that be considered as sedition?

We have plenty of natural resources, if UMNO Johor believe that Sabahan and Sarawakian dont deserve to get the citizenship, tell your UMNO Head Office in KL to refund all the money that came from natural resource of Sabah and Sarawak....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 51
...
written by kent chong, June 03, 2008 14:52:56
Malaysia can send 1 ANGKASAWAN to space so proudly, can pay foriegn orchestra to perform. how come limit PSD? if this year we have total 100 Malaysian qualify then sponsor all, if next year we got 10000 Malaysian qualify for PSD then sponsor all lar. Why limit by malay and non malay?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 56
...
written by csgcsg, June 03, 2008 14:55:55
Generalization can sometimes lead to confusion..it is agreed it is better to call those idiots umnoputras or malays in umno
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 16
...
written by YSL, June 03, 2008 14:59:30
My Raja King Petra Kamarudin,
I said it before and must say it now and will, if necessary, say it for many times as possible that you are one hell of the Muslim that can really stand above all Muslims in Malaysia. Perhaps, the whole World!!!

I was not having reasonable knowledge about Muslim over the past 46 years but i do now. You have opened up Muslim and Islam on the right time, rightplace and for the right reasons.

I know that God has every reason to send you to Malaysia to address the confusion and hatred created by irresponsile Muslims that had had tarnished the beautiful image and peaceful purpose of Islam in life.

My Raja King Petra, thank you very much for the clarification. Today and from now on, i dare to decalre and say that Islam is truly a beautiful, peaceful and acceptable practice.

This further enhanced my knowledgge where there are close to 250 million Muslims in mainland China and that i have not heard of any problem created by them within a 1.6 billion populations of a mixed societies.

Once again, thank you my Raja King Petra.

May Allah always shine upon you being Allah's messenger to tell Malaysians what is Islam and what is Muslim.

Thank you, thank you, thank you and thank you very very much my Raja King Petra.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 59
...
written by Commonsenses, June 03, 2008 15:02:22
Rpk, another excellent piece of writing. In this country, the people that create the most racial problems are the mualaf and the mamak kutty. The have to be more melayu than malays.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 24
...
written by skc, June 03, 2008 15:03:24
If we have a good and just government, maybe today we will not be Malays and non Malays, we might have been just Malaysian. Just wonder how are we all going to pay for this crime when we die. Yes we are all at fault, no question about it.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 16
...
written by aryn, June 03, 2008 15:06:25
All the more reason why Umno must be purged and never allowed to rule the country again.

A party which use race to govern would not help the Malays and the country at all. As what happen now. We should be more progressive and develop than Singapore with all our resources but Umno's politics have prevented that.

50 years on and we still quarrel about race supremacy. And it's all because of Umno. Kick them out!
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 27
...
written by KUMON, June 03, 2008 15:09:47
Bloody hell,,...I might as well blame everyone before me like my mother, grandfather ..great2 grandmother for cueing me to be born and bred in Malaysia. Look if I had a choice, would I want to be born in Malaysia?!! smilies/cry.gif, Even the so called Malays were from some cave/hut/jungle somewhere out of malaysia(like our forefathers) many many moons ago and came to conquer the peninsular.

Secondly, didn't the non-bumis contribute anything to Malaysia? If the Chinese pays more taxes than the bumiputras, what does that tell us? UMNO also mean to say other races like indians, kadazans, ect don't pay taxes and contribute to malaysia??

The non-bumis came to work, but the malays came to conquer. Thats why they endear power and they think power will be their only way to a comfortable life. The chineses think economics is the way to comfort and better life and I beleive indians think of working hard and perseverance is their formula.

The mixture and amalgamation of the major races feed each others strengths and not threaten each other. Under the constitution, everyone should be 'equal' but unfortunately, most politicians don't. smilies/sad.gif
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 17
...
written by budakindia, June 03, 2008 15:10:51
And if they do not vote for Barisan Nasional then they are ungrateful.
======================================================= ===============

What a "mature" statement made by UMNO Johor! It's a small wonder like Tun said if you put a dead log, they will still vote for that! I guess Tanjung Rambutan and Tampoi need to be enlarged to house all these retards! smilies/cheesy.gif
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 17
...
written by Negarakuku, June 03, 2008 15:26:03
WOW!

What an article YM RPK. This is what I call GENIUS!!! ABIM became LEBAM.

You are the real justice in Islam and justice for all Malaysians
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 22
...
written by Birdbrain, June 03, 2008 15:35:42
Everything was a OK in Malaysia until two men came along.....Razak and Mahathir!

If they have a choice, they would like to convert all non-muslims and give them each a name like.....Tiap Tiap Hari bin Kosong!

Malaysia was screwed upside down by these two Malay extremist and hopefully there isn't a third who also goes by the name of the first!

Maybe they do not believe in co-existence but they only believe in enriching their lives with ill gotten gains.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 23
...
written by gundam, June 03, 2008 15:43:27
do u believe the treatment on 'immigrants' will change if all of them converted to islam?
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 11
...
written by sararaj, June 03, 2008 15:46:06
well said sir...
i espect your courage and steadfast beliefs that we shud be know as malaysians... after 50 years... i keep wondering... aren't we ashamed sometimes that a country we let go from our federation some 40 odd years is doing so much better than us?? economically sound, educationally competent, the strict adherence to the rule of law... they keep saying we always look to the developed nations for an example but our dear neighbour which is so nearby, why can't we use them as an example?? we need to change our thinking before we can progress... no point having all this new techology and advancement when we still have a medieval mindset... majulah malaysia...
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 15
...
written by ksmaniam, June 03, 2008 15:52:13
Just when i thought i have put you on the highest pedestal. U up it again. you have put yourself at least in my mind among mahatma gandhi, martin luther king. I salute you my friend. With tears swelling in my eyes, I am honoured to be given as small space to write in this column. Thank you sir for showing that good people do walk on this earth. Thank you.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 28
...
written by AndyY, June 03, 2008 15:57:18
God recognises a person's heart not outward appearance. A person might perform worship through rituals and ceremonies but does not follow the worlds of God is basically useless in the eyes of God thus, those who claim to be leaders of the religion must take heed that whatever actions being carried out must be acted according to God's words as great responsibities have been in placed on them.

Justice will prevail when the time is right as set by God...
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 16
...
written by Mr Smith, June 03, 2008 16:01:17
Johor UMNO does not understand history or pretends not to. The question is, would the British have given Independence had the Indians and Chinese were refused citizenship? Does UMNO think that it won Independence without Indians and Chinese? Does UMNO agree that Independence was given to Malays, Chinese and Indians?
Fortunately, we don't need to whack the Malays since RPK are doing it for us. You see, when we say, it is seditious but when a Malay says it, it is accepted.
Remember how Mahathir whacked the Malays at every UMNO Assembly and they meekly kept quiet.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 37
...
written by wookew, June 03, 2008 16:06:38
then i should too change my name to omor bin ummo to show my gratitude for granted me malaysian citizenship.Nah!!!
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 12
...
written by gctham, June 03, 2008 16:49:06
If all Malay Muslim interpret Islam as what was interpreted and what was under stood by Raja Petra , I believe many Chinese will have no fear of Islam and are quit willing to be converted though.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 18
...
written by johntyc, June 03, 2008 17:04:56
I don't think generally Malay are unjust. But most of those bastards in Umno, well, yeah, for sure. No doubt!

One day we'll be able to kill those blood sucking, diseases carrier bastards in Bee Ann like mosquitoes. They suck our blood while we're sleeping. Wait till we wake up! We can kill them either by using Rid Sect, electric racquet, or just by using our bare hands!

We'll kill them for sure, yeah. No doubt!
report abuse
disagree 5
agree 19
...
written by VIPER, June 03, 2008 17:15:30
well said. Agreed. but there are some good apples la..... like you.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 17
...
written by leonardo, June 03, 2008 17:16:53

There are people that don't understand the meaning of being equal. They think that they are special; not knowing that by thinking so, they are setting paradigm and chaining themself to the ground, they will never be free, and will never achieve much. Yes, they will always be special if they are staying put under the tempurung.
Come on lah brader, let's come out and play, let's work togeather to create more cakes for everyone, no point fighting over a piece of bone.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 18
...
written by imdangel, June 03, 2008 17:22:08
Dearest RPK,
Thanks for voiced out what I always question:- why a muslim immigrated to this bumiland can gain the bumi status easily compared to a non-muslim like tian chua may not be treated fairly as bumi, even though his ancestors had been in this bumiland for >500 years.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 23
...
written by sickofitall, June 03, 2008 17:23:06
YM RPK

Good to see you print ABIM's article, and formulate a response that quickly. Please keep it going. This discourse if great not only for fellow muslims but also for non-muslims. Isn't it great, if we muslims can engage each other in constructive discussions, rather than use our emotions to convey our disagreement with things said by others??!

Keep this up and hopefully other will do the same
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 21
...
written by MT682, June 03, 2008 18:25:00
Tun Dr Mahathir’s father was born in India. But Tun Dr Mahathir can vote opposition. He can even oppose Umno like he is doing so now. In fact, he can even become the Prime Minister. He is not an ungrateful immigrant who should be sent back to India.

How does an ethnic Indian become a Malay?
report abuse
disagree 5
agree 38
...
written by tamansegar, June 03, 2008 18:31:59
UMNO will not dare to say this today if BN lose the 0803 Federal election. I think they UMNO still have not learn their lesson yet from the last election.
They will only change when they are total wipe out in the next coming general election. We as Malaysian must think as one Bangsa Malaysia and not divide ourselve as Malay, Chinese, Indian and others race.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 20
...
written by kooiseng, June 03, 2008 18:43:10
The biggest mistake the Chinese made was to accept Malays as the "definitive people" of Malaya. They did not realise the deceipt and hypocrisy that followed over the last 50 years. It was like the Arab and his camel - the camel slowly pushed out the Arab. This is what the Malays will want to do. Luckily, with divine guidance, the cancer has been stopped in its tracks. I am in my sixties and I am still staying in this country, paying more for everything than my richer Malay neighbours who don't seem to be worried about everything except that they may not get handouts like before. Many well off Malays are staying overseas, behaving "macham orang puteh" - enjoying their ill gotten money from Malaysia. Now with the present problems, it is obvious that UMNO and its supporters have failed the country. There is no ministry that can solve our country's problems without stumbling along the way. The latest is the petrol subsidy. Is there no one in Sharir's ministry that has a clear well thought out solution to it's problems? The country is paying the price for filling every conceivable post with Malays, even when they cannot handle the problems. More will come - as Dr M knows. That's why he is trying to come back - to use the big stick on the non Malays. If he comes back again, we will use a bigger stick than him. That is the only thing UMNO putras respect - the BIG STICK.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 39
...
written by myvoice, June 03, 2008 19:14:44
Salute you for the openess and imagine if all the Malaysia Mly people have such openess, this country, MALAYSIA will have peace till hari khiamat! God is great for having RPK in Malaysia.

Hope your writings is honestly accepted by them, those with double standard justice!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 15
...
written by Angel, June 03, 2008 19:22:56
All religions teach good human and moral values and when we vote it is according to these irrespective from which religion we are from. Just because we do not vote BN it does not mean we are ungrateful and do not deserve our rights to be Malaysians. If we are true to our religious beliefs we will not vote a ruling party that endorses corruption, greed, racism and the lot. So, UMNO should ask itself why they did so badly and rectify the errors. Enough is enough and our new generation of Malaysians, of all races, will no longer pack their bags and leave for greener pastures where their worth is more appreciated and recognised. I am glad that from the last elections we see lots of young people esp among the non Malays who are more involved in politics in wanting to make a difference to society. To leave Malaysia is easy but to stay and fight is tough. Yet they chose the more difficult route. BRAVO to these young blood. Malaysia needs you if we are to see better times for our children and grand children. We need to do things differently to get different results otherwise we will see the same sad scenario 50 years down the road. We can collectively make a difference and we are beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel!!

I have many Malay friends as well and would like to say that there are Malays and there are UMNOputras. The former are more open minded, tolerent and well read about the true facts regarding their religion. The latter are arrogant, greedy and believe that they are God's gifts to Malaysia. They are so swollen headed that they failed or refused to see the political tsunami heading their way. We must all pray for them to see the light!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 29
...
written by BukaJalan, June 03, 2008 19:53:32
Dear RPK,

Thank you for such insight.

The sad thing is the ruling executive invested so much energy towards manipulating & focusing the Malay Muslim masses attenion on dominace, special rights, privildeges, ketuanan etc. Unfortunately this has created an entire generation of inward looking Malay JPs (jaga pintus) - strong & kuat only in Malaysia - so long as they have these crazy "rights". In the true global village, ie the real (and cruel dod eat dog world) world - in the absence of such "priviledges", people from such a system simply die standing. I mean if one wants to be successful at tendering for global businesses, one has to be be "out there", street wise in the global village, armed with world class quality solutions and creativity, energy and competitiveness. Here the UMNOputras have degenerated an entire race - falsely making them believe that they are in fact superior (well they are so long as they "at home" with these protection). If they do not want to or is not given to compete at home, how the hell can they compete outside with the real dog eat dog real world out there. I mean the day will come. Wait till the South China Sea oil wells run dry - then true shit will hit the fan. The gravy stops - and the Malays will have to look outside of Malaysia. For such mismanagement we have TDM to thank - I mean seriously - he ought to be sent Saddam's way.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 19
...
written by Catharsis, June 03, 2008 20:12:44
RPK, IF THE PREMISE IS, "YOU NEED TO BE CRUEL TO BE LOVING" YOU JUST DID THAT.

I HOPE THOSE FROM THE EXTREME RIGHT WILL GET THE MESSAGE.............

ON THE OTHER HAND, THERE IS NO LOGIC EITHER- IF JESUS IS ACCEPTED AS ONE OF THE PROPHETS BUT NOT HIS BELIEVERS IS EQUALLY BEWILDERING. IF THE SCRIPTURES ARE DISTORTED BUT THE OLD TESTAMENTS ARE RECORDED IN THE QURAN A FEW HUNDRED YEARS LATER- WILL THEY MAKE THE HOLY QURAN MORE ACCURATE THAN THE BIBLE- HOW CONFUSING REALLY IS RELIGION.....................

report abuse
disagree 1
agree 6
...
written by harrbm, June 03, 2008 20:16:39
><

Hmmmm... i wonder what ABIM got to say . . .


><
.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 4
...
written by AsamLaksa, June 03, 2008 20:18:40
When I read the letter that ABIM posted I just shook my head. It's full of niceties but didn't address the issue of them questioning the change in quota. What the ABIM letter, as RPK rightly said is not about the issue of the quota but that RPK should not use name calling. I wouldn't even waste my time making such a letter if I were ABIM. Saying that, ABIM may have an action for defamation but we all know how 'badly' affected RPK can be with a defamation suit. smilies/wink.gif What timely reply this article is to their letter.



I was inclined to reply to the original ABIM post that stated that changing the quota to 60-40 is not the solution and say that of course it isn't the solution! The real solution is not to have any race based quota. The real solution is one based on needs. If you want to help the poor then provide scholarships for the poor regardless of race. If you want to help the brightest go as far as possible, then have scholarships for the brightest regardless of race. Thus set quotas based on needs, not colour.

Would it marginalise the Malays? Well, if there are lo*** of poor Malays then lo*** of poor Malays will get the scholarships just like poor Indians and Chinese. The scholarship may not send them to USA or UK as it's not about sending them to the best schools but rather to give them the opportunity to get higher education. Thus even giving them places in local uni, local colleges, ASEAN schools are sufficient.

Then with their basic qualification it's up to them to make a better life than they could originally only dream of. Thus scholarships for the poor should allow for lo*** of applicants but the cost of each scholarship need not be very expensive as the aim is to achieve as high a number of possible to get the poor out of poverty via education. Arguably there should not be a limit here as all the poor should qualify in line of eradicating poverty.

In fact such aids should already begin from day 1 on school perhaps even via poor family education trust fund to help them invest small amounts with generous top ups by the government so that by the time it matures they have all they need to seek further education. You can also have education aids to help the children get by with the daily cost needed to attend schools such as food aid, book aid, uniform aid. Still much cheaper than sending 1 student to UK to study for 5 years.

What about the scholarships for the brightest? Would it marginalise other races? Well, why would you want to send not so bright to the best schools and keep the bright ones at home for? What is your aim here? If you want your brightest to go to the best schools and come back to help the country, then it has to be absolute only the brightest should qualify regardless of race. These are the sort of scholarships which may incur high cost per student sending them to the most prestigious schools. The catch here is that there should be a strict limit on the numbers as you only want to concentrate on the brightest every year, not the 5000th brightest in the country. So the numbers should be based on how many students grad per year and take let's set it for the top 1-2% in the country.

For those who don't qualify for poor scholarship or the brightest, there should be education loans and flexible payment available for all local centres of higher learning. If you insist on going overseas, then that's your problem as the government should only provide what is deemed reasonably sufficient, not extravagant. Here there should be other forms of private education loan arrangements available.

But anyway, I can't expect dramatic changes so a quota change is a step forwards though I hope the eventual aim is to remove the quota altogether. I don't buy halfway aims.



BTW Grandmarquis, please stop it with your assertion that all man are not born equal thus inequality is valid. Itu dah kuno. Everyone knows that no one is born equal but that does not mean you are not entitled to be treated equally.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 25
...
written by Uncle, June 03, 2008 20:40:31
Dear YM RPK,

God must have felt the burning frustration of the Non Malays' for the practice of double standards ( by our leaders, politicians, civil servants, police etc ) and many injustice to them for so long.

SO HE SENDS YOU , A TRUE MALAYSIAN MALAY AND MUSLIM to speak up the truth for them !

This NO HOLS BARRED piece from you is so powerful and so real.

Yang makan cilli mesti rasa pedas !

YM, KEEP UP WITH YOUR GOOD WORK TO EXPOSE THE EVIL !!

God Bless You and Family.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 28
...
written by gctham, June 03, 2008 21:03:54
Religion is a double sword, if use it rightly one may get salvation through religion, but use it wrong it will be just as powerful and destructive as nuclear bom. It all the same for all known religion in this present time.

ABIM is just another group of people try to manipulate a religion for its own purpose, but it was very destructive because it happen in the right place, with the right people around it.

Again as what Raja Petra has mentioned the religion original text has been distorted after few thousands years. So in order to get back to the real true meaning of what all religion founders have to say or what it mean one has to study the original text and realise the true by own practices.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by gctham, June 03, 2008 21:15:41
Raja Petra has been very honest and very analytical in his writing. What he say was what exactly many people think but dare not to say it openly.

It was common knowledge that, Chinese are the major contributor to the federal taxes but yet this group of people has been always at the give side. One must be a Chinese only can realize how much emphasis a Chinese emphasis on education. So it was very sore to the Chinese if they are not given the opportunity to pursue their studies for all those who want and has the capability to further their studies.

One have to open up the mindset, let not just thinking along the line that if Chinese are given too much chance and become all powerful and well do in their studies they will control over other races. NO. It will never happen. One has to really understand Chinese mentality, History teach us and it has shown in more 5000 years civilization Chinese has never conquer over other nation and it will never do so in present time. If Chinese want to conquer any nation, it will happen long time during the Ming dynasty and the first to fall will be Melaka, by Cheng Ho the Laksamana. If this happen Ali Rustam will become Cheng Ali already.

report abuse
disagree 2
agree 22
...
written by Uncle, June 03, 2008 21:42:23
Is the info above true ?

Can that old cock be investigated under ACA ?

These are all black money and tax payers money mainly the Chinese cronies !
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 9
...
written by harrbm, June 03, 2008 21:55:48
><

SBennit, by god...where the hell did you got the info from? Aren't Banks under statutory duty not to disclose any infos?

I better close my bank account tomorrow.

><
.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 6
...
written by Panca Indera, June 03, 2008 21:56:08
To Gotham,
The Malays are not stupid to know that China has no intention of taking over or invading Malaysia.
Their worry is the large Overseas Chinese population taking over their adopted country economically and forcibly. Look at our neighbours. Dahhhh! You thick plick!

As for the article, Brilliant ! Can’t fault there.

Keep it up!
As for the Jews being the chosen people, ever wondered what happened to Ariel Sharon since his coma?

Well let me know will you! Last I heard he is neither dead nor alive being kept under constant watch while his body is withering away.

Hey Bushie baby! Can you show us the latest picture of your close buddy Ariel on CNN/NBC or FOX news?

Well, “What goes around comes around”, as the old saying goes.

So watch out TDM and all you Muslim fakers!
smilies/angry.gif smilies/angry.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/cool.gif
report abuse
disagree 26
agree 7
...
written by snowman123, June 03, 2008 22:07:55
Come on RPK, you are very wrong lah, of cource AMNO has reasons to regret and angry, the non-bumi are ingratitude.
example in Bdr Tun Razak, they have vote for a BN bumi, Tan bin ChaiHo all a long, how can they vote for an Opposition non-bumi, Khalid a/l Ibrahim now ?
report abuse
disagree 14
agree 4
...
written by SBennit, June 03, 2008 22:10:02
harrbm....someone sent me that (thats only part of the list, send me an e-mail if you want to see the full list), dunno if its true or not.

Anyway, read this if you want to know why Mahathir is a "pump head".

http://www.drmcdougall.com/mis...linton.htm


This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 4
...
written by Tokyobanker, June 03, 2008 22:25:35
I find it really amusing!

Within Malaysia, the UMNO-Malays (NOT ALL MALAYS) see the Chinese as their greatest enemy. As they wield power and wealth and go international, and when they get bullied by the Mat Sallehs (usually happen), suddenly they find out that the Chinese as their best friends, helping them out of difficult circumstances.

THE ENEMY OF YOUR ENEMY IS YOUR FRIEND!

As they go international, they work closely with the Indians to reach out to India, Africa and even Middle East. They work closely with the Chinese to reach out to Taiwan, China, Korea and even to Japan!

Please grow up boys! The world is much much bigger out there! Let's work together and make real big money from the world and make Malaysia really rich!

No amount of stupid narrow minded squabbling and Ketuanan within Malaysia can make the UMNO-Malays rich!

If the UMNO-Malays are really thinking for the Malays and for Malaysia, they would not have taken the stance they have taken so far!

They are only thinking for their own selfish enrichment and not even for the malays overall, not to mention Malaysia!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 15
...
written by Msian 2, June 03, 2008 22:34:54
Nice one Sbennit. Just hope it is true. This would be a mother of all news in M'sia. However no MS Media would dare to publish this truth or untruth.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by bigben, June 03, 2008 22:48:58
dear RPK

It's takes an exceptional person like your to make this a better world to live in. Your points are so well articulated it makes Abims denials look so stupid. Knowing what is right and wrong is so important. Simply put, wrong is something I would not want others to do unto me. Keep up the good work for the sake of our nation.

God bless you.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by harrbm, June 03, 2008 22:55:02
><

dear SBennit, i understand now why TDM is a "pump head". Poor guy huh.

Anyway I my head is all pumped up now. Not due to any post surgery thingy but these wonderful Vodka, Rum, lemon, a dash of black pepper, ice and cranberry juice mix. I called it The Pakatan cocktail. he he.

><

.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by harrbm, June 03, 2008 22:58:07
><

oops. . .
my email is This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

see, all pumped up.

><

.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 0
...
written by alarcarte, June 03, 2008 22:58:32
If Chinese vote opposition, they are being labelled by UMNO as ungrateful, what about the young urban Malays who vote for oppositions? Are you going to suggest to ask them to go back to Indonesia? I knew that my neighbour Malay bachelor boys all voted for PAS/PKR in my constituency, one of them told me, UMNO provide them free transport to go back to Kampong and on top of that each also received RM200 cash but they voted for PAS, are you a bunch of stupid idiots (UMNOPUTRAS)?

Say what you like, most Malays in Johor can trace their origin from Indonesia.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 9
...
written by Fernz, June 03, 2008 23:10:45
A distinction must be drawn between the state and political parties. Political parties are not the state. Just as Umno feels it has a right to rule, so do the Opposition parties.

People are free to vote for whomever they want. What's the point of holding elections if Umno feels the people should only vote for it?

By the way, citizenship is provided by the state, by law, and not political parties. So, the question of gratitude to a political party does not arise.

Umno leaders seem to have an infinite capacity to talk nonsense.

http://fernzjoefernandez.blogspot.com

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 9
...
written by Watcheyes1, June 03, 2008 23:16:22
YM RPK,

Thanks for speaking the mind and heart of non-Malays and non-Muslims. Thanks for pointing out the truth.

And yes, i will also come back to my country one day and contribute to the country and HER rakyat anyway i can.

You are a great and wise man YM RPK.

Thanks again Sir!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by activepro, June 03, 2008 23:18:58
Thanks again master pete for opening my eyes n mind.Sometimes I feel sad why I hv been born here and live blindly for almost 50 years struggling to build a career,raise a family n pay for every God damn things,under some extreme conditions and hardships.If I were a muslim long ago,life for sure would be a stroll.I feel sad coz now I know I have been denied equal opportunity in building up a meaningful n successful career.Now these scumbags putras feel threaten coz they now have less $$$ to suck so they tried their last ditch effort to remind the non-bumi that they still owe these bastards their livings coz they gave the non-bumi citizenship.If only I could stuff each and every mouth of theirs with C4 and blast them off the face of this earth,only then some of their sons n daughters may realise it's Bad to be SUCKERS.They should be overthrown asap,let justice rule!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by Badaksumbu, June 03, 2008 23:33:27
I don't actually like to add my name here after seeing enough names-but can't help-we should promote this idea of justice in the real ordinary meaning -I am a Muslim too, but I've never agreed the wayr UMNO impart education such s told by Raja to our young infinitely

Badaksumbu
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 11
...
written by fletcher, June 03, 2008 23:51:38
As usual Amno have inflict into Abim and all others Malay control NGO. The way they carry themselves, show that they are on the takes of Amno.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by seek justice, June 03, 2008 23:59:39
A brilliant write-up as usual. But really, I wonder how many Malay Muslims would sincerely hang their head and say "Malunya aku!". I, for one, am wondering how to face my fellow Malaysians who are non-Muslims when I go out tomorrow - how would they look at me, a tudunged Malay woman who hates being a Muslim in Malaysia!!

I love this country because I'm taught to love my 'tanah tumpah darah'. How I wish my great grandfather did not migrate from Kwantung, China in the early 20s to become a good Muslim living in Tanah Melayu. Malaysia is not Islamic at all and it is getting very, very challenging for me, a mukmin-wannabe. I feel like a hypocrite, a walking paradox I am trying to be a good Muslim in a country which is supposed to be Islamic but is actually very non-Islamic.

Only God knows!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 14
...
written by Motherchell, June 04, 2008 00:06:42
Its been 50 years and they are still molding bigotry in the sand ?????

Would UMNO want to be remembered as what MANDELA has done for the world or what IDI AMIN has ??????????????????? This they have to think about , from tonight-- as there isn't much time left with the rigormortis almost through!!!!!!!!

I can believe an Institution called "Mandela INSTITUTE of International Understanding""" standing all over the world , to see a UMNO Or TDM Institute like that is far fetched !!!!!!!!!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by SamBall, June 04, 2008 00:17:27
Good article Raja; one that all the non-Malays know and talk about. Still cannot fathom all the ass-kissing over your article being written by a Melayu sesat and all; oh well.. sorry la; just ribbing only..

I wonder how much Malaysia lost due to its discriminatory policies. I wish someone would do the sums; all the brain drain of its talented former citizens; must be huge. In your face, mamak old boy.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by Motherchell, June 04, 2008 00:19:09
A RPK FOUNDATION or an INSTITUTE will exist one day all over the world , for he seeks Justice for all Malaysians!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by Bigdawg, June 04, 2008 00:43:42
By indianputra
"Actually what am I asking for?"

What an interesting question!
Actually, it now sets me wondering what actually you think you're asking for.
But be good if you let us know!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by ctm999, June 04, 2008 01:41:58
Allow me to pretend to be an UMNOPutra for a while (I am not). This is my UMNOPutra idiotic logic: Since Chinese pay 90% of the taxes, then they will have no problem paying for their own education. Since Malays hardly pay any taxes that means that can't afford their education and thus need to have PSD scholarship 100%.

If Malaysia is like the fabled Goose that lay Golden Eggs then the UMNOPutras is strangling it half dead. Either we the RAKYAT get rid of the UMNOPutras or else Malaysia will be dead very shortly.

I agree from now on we should distinguish between the idiots UMNOPutras and good Malays.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by sheppardlight, June 04, 2008 02:13:57
RPK

The Malays who think that they are the Muslims is actually not muslims. Just check thoroughly the quran, there are many verses that confirms the malays meet the specifications of the kafirs. That includes you.
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 3
...
written by saintgeorge, June 04, 2008 02:25:48
Its for this very reason that I left Malaysia, and being a Malay, have always hated this notion that I was entitled or better than my Chinese and Indian friends. Only weak people use religion as a crutch to beat down on others.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 8
...
written by artfulone, June 04, 2008 03:08:01
RPK thanks for calling a spade a spade. It is not about race or religion even if there are no non malays in Malaysia there will still be other ways to saparate them and us to share the economic cake in a zero sum mentality. Look at Zimbabwe and Myanmar etc pray we don't go down that path. Malaysia's strength is it's diversity and ability to connect with every market in this globalised economy.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by artfulone, June 04, 2008 03:14:20
If Malaysia was like Singapore with our population and resources imagine where we would be in world rankings on economic performance. The people are the same the mentality is the same however Malaysians are not allowed and encourage to perform and excel in case one race does better than the other. We need to change our attitude the bigger the cake the more to go round.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 7
...
written by InEffective, June 04, 2008 03:19:25
All this hoopla because politicians want to hoard the OilMoney to themselves.

Where is my Beef (OilMoney)?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by doggone, June 04, 2008 03:52:08


RPK, you just wrote what most non-malays have been harboring in their heart all this while, much of whichthose frustrations are only spoken among themselves. You just penned what most of us wanted to say, but could not. Kudos to you.
--------------------
Wow, SBennit. You mean there is a longer list?

Can you give us a rough estimate on the total deposited.
Shit on toast man, what about the many other banks they have accounts with. Fungo !!!


report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by anakwatanKL, June 04, 2008 05:09:29
Dear RPK,

You are a thinking Malaysian Muslim and I am sure that there are many thinking Malaysian Muslims like you. The thing or beauty about you is that you voice out. I hope and pray that other thinking Malaysian Muslims will come together with other thinking Malaysians to create Malaysia for Malaysians.

As for Umno Johor, all I hear is regret, regret, regret..... Hardly inspiring for the future generations or even myself. By the way, the rakyat has given a term for the Govt. to prove themselves and this is what they do...sheeesh. Time wasters.

Mahathir may have done good but he failed to bring Malaysians together. Education wise, I was one of those who lost out to limited uni. seats due to race quota. That was a generation of thinking Malaysians that Mahathir did not tap into.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 6
...
written by ahmisk, June 04, 2008 07:45:26
I'm not sure what's the usefulness of blanket condemnation of the malays and muslims.

A lot of middle income people fail to appreciate how much suffering is being endured by all poor Malaysians, many of whom are Malay (but also, of course, Indians and Chinese and Ibans and Kadazans). These people have received little or no help from the government. Their incomes have been falling for the last 10 years due to spiraling inflation, increased automation, and wage suppression from the influx of millions of cheap foreign workers.

The truth is that the real story of Malaysia, especially over the last 20 years, has been the subjugation of the poor by the rich. Everyone is suffering, all poor Malaysians, but we seem to be obsessed with blaming other races instead of blaming the elite of our own race. Only when we understand this fact will we understand one another.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 7
...
written by journeyman, June 04, 2008 07:55:23
i agree with ahmisk's last paragraph. especially the part of "...but we seem to be obsessed with blaming other races instead of blaming the elite of our own race. Only when we understand this fact will we understand one another."

the elites of all races stand alongside the politicians who use the race issues to fan hatred in sharing the responsibility of the current huge divide.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Ken Liew, June 04, 2008 08:36:21
Justices only serve those normal people......

When justices comes to the BN's hand, they are above the LAW and nothing justices can touch them.....

Wonders of Malaysia, where anything is BOLEH!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by siewmei88, June 04, 2008 09:14:21
i've never read a more just article before! keep it up. we love your writings
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by DNA, June 04, 2008 09:23:11
Hats off YM RPK. wonderfil whack.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Tsunami08, June 04, 2008 10:18:47
Spot on! Islam and Malay unity is clearly misused by the racist UMNO and its ilks (e.g. ABIM) to manipulate people with the aim of maintaining power in their hands. 4 generations of non-Malays cannot qualify for bumiputra status while Indons, Pakistanis, Afghans and Filipino illegal immigrants become bumiputras within a few months of their arrival! Justice? It is UMNO which is being ungrateful. 90% of the nation's taxes are contributed by Non-bumis to pay their salaries. Talk about biting the hand that feeds you! Who really should not be paying their taxes to support this unjust and warped system?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by admiral Tojo, June 04, 2008 11:03:44
The truth has been put forth for ALL to see and ponder. Good on you RPK.

Shalom
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by cheekhiaw, June 04, 2008 11:23:19
JUSTICE ABUSED

To say that the antics of those people described above as varying types of justice is an abuse of the word as known to the civilised world.

Such behaviour would not even match a good dog's sense of decency...

xxx
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by akcc81, June 04, 2008 11:27:10
This is the ultimate truth, revealed without fear or favour. Thank you, Pete.

Really wish you would run for elections and be appointed the PM one day.

You are really enlightened and practise true Islam. Wish they were all like you.

Being a third class citizen, what you just revealed does offer some consolation.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by malaysianohope, June 04, 2008 11:53:42
Labisman,
I think the posting by SBennit about Chedet's ill gotten gains should not be removed since its people money we are talking about. Anyway its now all over the net. For those interested see posting in Susan Loong website under title Off the Edge & Down the Pipeline".
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Su Dhanoa, June 04, 2008 11:59:56
Dear RPK,

You wrote what I, and I believe most other non-malays have been harboring in our hearts all this while. You just penned what most of us wanted to say, but could not gather the guts to do so. Well like the saying goes - well said and done - You have relieved a great burden from our hearts.

THANK YOU!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 9
...
written by apa jadi, June 04, 2008 12:09:55
A much better written article that your previous one RPK. It pours out what WE wanted said, but held back for one reason or another.

Very much that we like to attack the British colonialists for the ill they did during their stay, THEY left behind a well administered system. Yet, these are the people who conveniently attack the British administration in Malaya, perpetuate bad things the British did for their political gains.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by apa jadi, June 04, 2008 12:17:34
malaysianohope,

understand some of the constraints this blog has. I don't blame them for being too sensitive to certain words or allegations. We can protest to make the administrator realise it is no harm. But the decision is theirs.

Good that SBennit revealed those figures be it true or false. I would appreciate if SBennit could provide us a link to those "facts". It is much easier for both parties. Would you SBennit?

Remember a few years back this old man was in Palastine and was refused entry into Jerussalam? He was breathing fire then. There was a joke then which linked to what SBennit put up. Get it?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by dmh1871, June 04, 2008 12:40:56
By nature the Malay are an accommodating race that why other races is able to be the richest man, billionaire, bankers, Chief Minister, Minister, Excos, Fed Coa Hc Judges, High rank in the army-navy-air force-police, DGs etc and yet the non-malays still say they are being treated unfairly and for that the Malay has to further compromise whatever rights they have even though it is guaranteed under the constitution.

And yet others can say that they are marginalised and the Malay are racial. They can say so coz they are not in power. Hello! what the non-malays have now is 1000 x more than what I can say about what the Malay gets as a minority in a neighbouring country where the non-malays are in power and call them self the land of meritocracy, level playing field and equal distribution and what do they give the Malay there (they are not the richest man and there is no malays billionaire, bankers, Chief Minister, Minister [except for one in charge of enviroment for years], Excos, Fed Coa Hc Judges, High rank in the army-navy-air force-police, DGs, fighter pilots etc) when they are in power almost nothing and no body made a fuss out of it.

Maybe the Malays here should learn from the neighbouring non-malays by not being so accommodating only then the non-malays here would appreciate what they have.
report abuse
disagree 16
agree 2
...
written by mamanur, June 04, 2008 13:00:47
imdangel,
only muslims immigrant from indonesia, thailand and phillipines can get bumi status. muslims caucasian have to wait more than 10 years, and some didnt ever get their PR status despite marrying malay muslim women.

its all about the color of the skin.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by cheekhiaw, June 04, 2008 13:47:02
MORE THAN ACCOMMODATING

Some Malays are more than accommodating.

They virtuously claim to accommodate 'outside' people who manage to make money despite continuously having to defer to their demands to accommodate their special rights.

They accommodate the orang asli by bossing over them and keeping them at the fringes of society while they keep the special rights to plunder to themselves.

They think their own Malays would stupidly accommodate them stealing and plundering even from their own poor.

xxx
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by panca, June 04, 2008 14:34:30
The Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.) addressed the people signifying that concept during his last pilgrimage, saying: "O People! Your God is one; your father is one; no preference of an Arab neither over non-Arab nor of a non-Arab over an Arab or red over black or black over red except for the most righteous. Verily the most honoured of you is the most righteous."

This is to assert that, in Islam, no nation (community) is created above other nations and therefore no nation can be placed above another. Man's worth in the eyes of men and in the eyes of God is determined by his skills, by the good he does, and by his obedience to God.

In another tradition, the Prophet, peace and blessings of God be upon him, was asked, "Who among men is most favoured by God?”

The Prophet replied, "A man who does the most good to people."

Excerpts of a speech by Imam Mohamed Baianonie at the Islamic Center of Raleigh, N.C.



If what umno preached to the malays to practice that justice is only for themselves then it is obvious umno is practising a deviant teaching from what islam taught. They should be quickly wiped out under ISA! Dangerous and detrimental to nation building, causes racial disharmony, the unmasking of umno goons. This article stated clearly the contribution to nation building of the non-malays, what they want is fairness for all Malaysian including the malays, (not umno). The malay must not blink an eye to this umno continuous act of bigotry.

The country needs a two-party system, not a two-justice system!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by The One, June 04, 2008 20:17:37
quietguy, that is just the way for him to whack us the Malay. take it as a cry to improve!
i also want equality in justice, but i cant deny what he says is true.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by talk2stop, June 04, 2008 20:31:00
WOW!! Mahathir's dad from India. You got to say he done well in Malaysia. I don't think a Malay can achieve that if he/she born in India with parents from Malaysia. Best wishes.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by Thinkwisely, June 04, 2008 20:39:10
Well well well. This is exactly what happend when leaders failed to upgrade the mindset of the community. This is similar to "Orang Asli" who refuse to accept morden development and prefer to stay in the forest for fear they will loose out all thier own self defined "heritage".

It is always a saying that being poor financially is just temporary because wealth can be pursued with strong mindset and fighting spirit but being poor in mentality will ruin the whole empire.

When I was small, my dad used to warn us that being Non-Bumi, we have to work lots more harder in order to survive in Malaysia. That is because we are going to compete among the best or in another words we must become best out of best in anything that we do especially in study.

Sometimes I just wonder why people just can't take the good example from the sports. In sports, do we set a quota according to race when competing with others countries? When we have our players in the Thomas Cup, do we see any races shout in support for others country where thier ancestor originated from?

The world is no longer as what we have been living for the last 50 years. It is all about fittest survive. We must always think on how to create bigger financial pie instead of keep arguing what % of financial pie that we should share here.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by sambal muncha, June 04, 2008 21:00:28
Hi Pete,

Thanks for having the guts to speak out for the fair-minded muslims of Malaysia

One observation though, Sharia Law (in almost all Muslim countries in the world) somehow doesn't quiet represent justice and fairness. As a Muslim, one would have grave reservations about Sharia courts delivering justice, and the individual is ultimately left with no choice. Any comments?



report abuse
disagree 1
agree 2
...
written by sambal muncha, June 04, 2008 21:17:26
Dear Pete,

I have to say it is our education system in Malaysia (ie Ugama class) that lays emphasis on form over substance. Hence the emphasis on rituals and more rituals without understanding the depth and true meaning of our actions. It's very sad.

It's all about having blind faith. I'll never forget being called a 'kafir' by my class mates for having the audacity to question certain aspects of our wonderful faith. It's only after learning and being in a 'non-muslim' country that I was able to rationalise and articulate my faith. Never would this have been possible growing up in Malaysia.


report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Eskay Lim, June 04, 2008 21:44:14
The trouble with the ordinary Malays who formed the majority is that most of them belong to the "peluk tubuh" group, and they easily apreciate everything on face-value. They are grateful when the Umnoputras shout the "Ketuanan Melayu", the 30% equity share ownership and the special rights thing.
But in actual fact, how many of the ordinary Malays really benefitted from the above? Many of them are still living below the poverty-level, working very hard "kais pagi makan pagi, kais petang makan petang" wth hrdly anything to save for the rainy days.
The people who greatly benefitted are those with plitical connections and the Umno cronies. You can see them living in huge multi-million ringgit bungalows, driving expensive imported vehicles, some even with drivers and also the entire-family holidays in foreign lands so many times a year.
Just open your big eyes wide... look around... only then will you realise that you have been had.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by SBennit, June 04, 2008 22:46:05
He is still around. Kat Hut Sung.

http://www.ataricommunity.com/...?p=9827242
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by SBennit, June 04, 2008 22:46:51
Dis you all notice. mahathir got RPK to remove the "list.



This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by Forex, June 04, 2008 23:11:21
"What if the non-Muslims were to say they do not recognise Islam or the Quran because Islam and the Quran have been distorted over the last 1,400 years? What if the non-Muslims were to say that Islam and the Quran have been changed and are no longer the original Islam and Quran that Prophet Muhammad introduced 1,400 years ago? If the non-Muslims say this then they would be committing a crime under the Sedition Act. The non-Muslims would face punishment because they are not sensitive to the feelings of the Muslims.

But Muslims are permitted to say they do not recognise Christianity and the Bible because Christianity and the Bible have changed and have been distorted over the last 2,000 years and are no longer the original Christianity and Bible which Jesus introduced 2,000 years ago. Muslims can openly say this in the Friday prayer sermons and it is not seditious, even if this is not sensitive to the feelings of the Christians.

And why can Muslims say this but Christians can’t? Because Islam is the official religion of Malaysia and Christianity is ‘tolerated’ as long as it stays out of the way of Islam."

T-up statement.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Panca Indera, June 05, 2008 00:55:10
Salam
As much as you guys love RPK dissertations, commentaries, hard hitting, soul bearing expositions on the subjects of Islam, Malay politics, general and specific Malaysians idiosyncrasies, please see them in the proper and correct perspectives. From the sample of the commentaries by viewers, some of you looked up to RPK as some kind of savior or Malaysian messiah.eg
1.you RPK, have the ability to see the truth and value true justice gives me hope for Malaysia.
2.i feel it is really God sent that Malaysia has a son which can be certified truely Malaysian.
3.Abang RPK how I wish you are the Prime Minister of Malaysia.
4.May Allah always shine upon you being Allah's messenger to tell Malaysians what is Islam and what is Muslim.
5.You are really enlightened and practise true Islam. Wish they were all like you.


The Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.) addressed the people signifying that concept during his last pilgrimage, saying:

And the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: "There is no superiority of an Arab over a non-Arab, or of a non-Arab over an Arab, or of a white man over a black man, or of a black man over a white man, except in terms of piety. The people come from adam and adam came from dust." http://www.answering-islam.org...zaynab.htm

Note: The “Red and Black person” is addition or Bidaah. There were no red people in Arabia in those days.

“ In another tradition, the Prophet, peace and blessings of God be upon him, was asked, "Who among men is most favoured by God?”
The Prophet replied, "A man who does the most good to people."”
It is not preferred to give the traditions of the prophet without reference as we cannot check the authenticity. This can also lead to false Hadiths as anybody can write anything that sounds good.

Imam Mohammed Baianonie is a small time scholar from Syria who operates from the Islamic center in the small town of Raleigh in NC, USA.No disrespect meant.

However If one wants to give credibility it would be better to quote from one of the “ four rightly guided Caliphs” or the trusted companions, unless they are considered less credible .

Give credit when credit is due, and RPK definitely deserves the accolades. However to elevate him to the same level as messengers or idol worship him is wrong and inappropriate.

Remember
1.To the “blind” the “sighted” is “God” and to the “handicapped” the fully limbed is perfect.
2.The beggar has the blues because he has no shoes until he chance to meet a man who has no feet.
3.Great men think alike and fools seldom differ.

Lastly I noticed that comments that does not support RPK views and those that criticized non Malays and Non Muslims are more oftenthan not, voted down and lowly rated.
So Much for No holds Bar, liberal thinking and freedom of expression. The pot calling the Kettle black?

smilies/tongue.gif smilies/tongue.gif smilies/tongue.gif
report abuse
disagree 10
agree 3
...
written by tenang, June 05, 2008 02:59:20
Dear Panca Indera,
I think you need not to concern about comments being voted down because the comments are still visible. Since they are visible, there is no curtailing the freedom of expression. The votes here serve as a simple raw feedback. Most people would be interested in how other people sees their comments.
If you want to exact a positive influence to the readers here, it certainly requires you to put up something having such effects. If you want to criticize, you are more likely to get voted up if you are able to criticize the actions instead of the actors. While the line between criticizing the actions and actors might be hard to define, I do notice most readers here are smart enough to tell when the comments are open for all to see.
It is a fair play here, or you can think of better arena?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by Super admin, June 05, 2008 09:54:51
written by SBennit, June 04, 2008 | 22:46:51
Dis you all notice. mahathir got RPK to remove the "list.

SBennit, the 'list', which was produced in 1999, is a fake. It was investigated in 1999 and it was found that the bank and bank accounts do not exist. Now do you know why the 'list' was removed? It is because you posted fake information and Malaysia Today does not deal in lies.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 3
...
written by Super admin, June 05, 2008 09:56:47
Panca Indera, there are people who also say that all Hadiths are false and were written more than 100 years after the Prophet died. So I suppose they have their opinions and you have yours.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by SUV, June 05, 2008 10:05:10
"O Mankind! We have created you from a male and female, and made you into nations and tribes, that you may know one another. Verily, the most honourable of you in the sight of Allah is he who has most righteous (taqwa) among of you. Verily, Allah is All-Knowing, All-Aware."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
male /female,is prusha/ prakriti,static/ dynamic kuasa/power/shkati...i



report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by SUV, June 05, 2008 10:08:48
O People! Your God is one; your father is one; no preference of an Arab neither over non-Arab nor of a non-Arab over an Arab or red over black or black over red except for the most righteous. Verily the most honoured of you is the most righteous."
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

it will require the sight of allah to fully comprehand this..which means humanity is ONE,mankind is essentially ONE.earth is also ONE...our skin colors,dan lain lain is just the expression of the ONE in infinte permutations n combinations n variations....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by cheekhiaw, June 05, 2008 10:21:18
OPINIONS FROM THE DARK AGES

Whatever one's opinion may be, it is altogether a different matter to insist that others' respect yours, backed by force if necessary, but not the other way around as some countries and legal systems have it.

The all powerful gods that are suppose to transcend everything, including time, choosing to 'reveal great/holy truths' through dubious men living in the dark ages, and in fringes of the then more civilised parts of the world but staying incognito/incommunicado in modern times should be telling.

With all their godly powers, the deities also chose to communucate only truths about human behavior through ignorant nom*** from the dark ages but not bigger things like the natural laws behind how the universe is organised to the much smarter men of their day (like Omar Khayyam) or today.

Some may think that all opinions are equal, but they are not. Some opinions are more stupid than others however holy they think they may be.

Omar Khayyam said pretty much the same 1,000 years ago.

And do you think that unto such as you;
A maggot-minded, starved, fanatic crew:
God gave the secret—and denied it me?
Well, well, what matters it? Believe that, too.
- Rubaiyat, Omar Khayyam

xxx
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by non conformist, June 05, 2008 10:58:46
Matthew 20:
25 But Jesus called them unto him, and said, Ye know that the princes of the Gentiles exercise dominion over them, and they that are great exercise authority upon them.
26 But it shall not be so among you: but whosoever will be great among you, let him be your minister;
27 And whosoever will be chief among you, let him be your servant:
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by non conformist, June 05, 2008 10:59:34
We read in the Bible"

24 God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands;
25 Neither is worshipped with men’s hands, as though he needed any thing, seeing he giveth to all life, and breath, and all things;
26 And hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation;
27 That they should seek the Lord, if haply they might feel after him, and find him, though he be not far from every one of us:
28 For in him we live, and move, and have our being; as certain also of your own poets have said, For we are also his offspring.
29 Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, graven by art and man’s device.
30 And the times of this ignorance God winked at; but now commandeth all men every where to repent:
31 Because he hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world in righteousness by that man whom he hath ordained; whereof he hath given assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead.

Acts chapter 17.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by Syah, June 05, 2008 11:18:49
Everyone is a immigrant to this world. No owns this world remember. It belongs to Allah swt and we are just mere passer by. Why draw lines and divide the human race according to their country of origin. They should rather get together and be as one as from the same originator.

People don't seem to see beyond race, colour and religion.This was and always will be our biggest challenge ever, even during the time of our great great great grandchildren and theirs and theirs.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by SUV, June 05, 2008 11:25:36
the sight of allah...

The action of the supramental sense is founded on this true truth of sense; it is an organisation of this pure, spiritual, infinite, absolute samjnana. The supermind acting through sense feels all as God and in God, all as the manifest touch, sight, hearing, taste, perfume, all as the felt, seen, directly experienced substance and power and energy and movement, play, penetration, vibration, form, nearness, pressure, substantial interchange of the Infinite. Nothing exists independently to its sense, but all is felt as one being and movement and each thing as indivisible from the rest and as having in it all the Infinite, all the Divine. This supramental sense has the direct feeling and experience, not only of forms, but of forces and of the energy and the quality in things and of a divine substance and presence which is within them and round them and into which they open and expand themselves in their secret subtle self and elements, extending themselves in oneness into the illimitable. Nothing to the supramental sense is really finite: it is founded on a feeling of all in each and of each in all: its sense definition, although more precise and complete than the mental, creates no walls of limitation; it is an oceanic and ethereal sense in which all particular sense knowledge and sensation is a wave or movement or spray or drop that is yet a concentration of the whole ocean and inseparable from the ocean. Its action is a result of the extension and vibration of being and consciousness in a supra-ethereal ether of light, ether of power, ether of bliss, the Ananda Akasha of the Upanish***, which is the matrix and continent of the universal expression of the Self,--here in body and mind experienced only in limited extensions and vibrations,--and the medium of its true experience. This sense even at its lowest power is luminous with a revealing light that carries in it the secret of the thing it experiences and can therefore be a starting-point and basis of all the rest of the supramental knowledge,--the supramental thought, spiritual intelligence and comprehension, conscious identity,--and on its highest plane or at its fullest intensity of action it opens into or contains and at once liberates these things. It is strong with a luminous power that carries in it the force of self-realisation and an intense or infinite effectiveness, and this sense-experience can therefore be the starting-point of impulsion for a creative or fulfilling action of the spiritual and supramental will and knowledge. It is rapturous with a powerful and luminous delight that makes of it, makes of all sense and sensation a key to or a vessel of the divine and infinite Ananda.

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by SUV, June 05, 2008 11:35:23
http://wahiduddin.net/words/99_pages/qayyum_63.htm

The Self-Subsisting, The Self-Existing One upon Whom all others depend


The One whose nature it is to exist. The One who is free of any dependence on anything else for existence.

The One through whom all things arise. The One by whom all things are eternally managed aright.

The Ever-Living, Self-Existing One who is the foundation upon which all things exist.


From the root q-w-m which has the following classical Arabic connotations:

to stand up, to rise up, to ascend, become high
to begin, to start, to come to pass
to arise, to set out
to be on-going, to exist
to be founded, to be built on
to undertake, to carry out, to manage
to make aright, straighten out, accurate, exact
to make righteous, upright

This name is used in the Qur'ân. For example, see 2:255

The attributes of al-Hayy and al-Qayyûm are often used to together, with al-Hayy signifying the attribute of ever-lasting life, and al-Qayyûm signifying the attribute of self-existing life. Thus, the attributes of al-Hayy and al-Qayyûm express two aspects of the One Life.

Abu Hurairah reported that whenever the Prophet, peace be upon him, was faced with a serious difficulty, he would raise his head to the sky and supplicate, "Subhan-Allah al-'Azim (glory be to Allah, the Mighty)." And when he implored seriously and strongly, he would say "Ya Hayyu, Ya Qayyum (O Ever-Living One, O Self-Existing One upon Whom we all depend)." (hadith of Tirmidhi)

The attribute of al-Qayyûm is also nicely described by the words on Acts 17:28 which say:

in Him we live and move and have our being

The name al-Qayyûm also has much the same meaning as the Hebrew phrase in Exodus 3:14



which is often translated as I am that I am, or I am that which I have become.

As Sri Aurobindo wrote in his commentary of the Isha Upanishad:

God is the only Being and all other existences are only His becomings.

The word mustaqîm, from this same q-w-m root, means straight, righteous, upright, rising upwards or ascending.



(Also written as al-qayyum, al-qayyoom, the Self-Existing: ya qayyum, ya qayyoom)


report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by fairnessforall, June 05, 2008 11:50:42
grandmarquis said
Well we have to face the reality that the world is unfair, and yet we have RPK, a Muslim talking about fairness to the non-Muslim. But we hardly see any non-Muslim talks about fairness to the Muslim. Walk around the earth and whenever you see non-Muslim outnumbered the Muslim, they would be mistreated.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

grandmarquis, i do not agree with your statement above, in indian the muslims are among other minority groups that enjoy special privileges such as job opportunities, university places etc, despite being a minority group. In fact in every country with the exception of Malaysia, special privileges are given to the minority and not the majority. The hindus do not make a big fuss and claim ketuanan despite being the majority and have accepted the special privileges given to the monority groups.

The problems with most muslims is, irrespective of where they are even if they are a minority, they always want to be boss and expect everyone to respect their religion their customs, practices, and claim the area to be a muslim territory etc but do not reciprocate. So what mistreatment are you talking about. In most countries all citizens have to abide by the same law irrespective of religion or race as other countries separate religion from law. No doubt I have many muslim friends who do not have such believe in injustice and believe in being fair to everyone and I only hope that all muslims can be that way and not become some fanatic religious retard and condemn people of other races or religion. Its sad that UMNO has chosen to use race to divide and rule the people, and if the malays/muslims are smart enough they will realise they are being used by UMNO and will stand for what a true muslims should, and that is fairness to all and reject UMNOs brand of politics. The muslims should realise without the other races, Malaysia could not have come this far, and last but not least before calling the chinese and Indians and others immigrants, they should realise they are in the same category and Malaysia did not belong to them. They only claimed that Malaysia belongs to malays after immigrating here and becoming the majority race due to ICs being given to Indonesians etc, so when it comes to bumiputra status, rightfully and legally it should be the orang asli's etc and not Malays. The ketuanan melayu concept is what will be Malaysia's downfall in the years to come, if changes are not made to instead become Ketuanan Rakyat as per PRs agenda.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 3
...
written by rams609, June 05, 2008 11:58:49
A bloody well written piece Pete.
Keeping the discussion just on the issue of Malays, I do think we Malays are
a 'mysterious' lot if not funny. You can never be sure. Many will shout ' I do not like dollah, I hate najib' and so forth. But on the very day they vote, they came back to their senses and say.." Aah..tak apalah...". worst still they come out defending their lousy choices. They may seem to be the new voice on the outside. Once inside they'll blend in and speaks the same lingo fast. Example, that Ezam fella. Indeed, it's the malay dilemma. Indeed, how many Malays will think like you, Mahathir, and me?

Give Malays another 100 years, and we will still be like who we are today. The UMNO bunch is a shiny example. We don't even need to talk about being competitive with the other races. Amongst Melayus ourselves, we aren't one!
Bila mau maju???? Macam mana mau progress? Wallahhualam.

All the best to you and fam Pete.


report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Hiley, June 05, 2008 12:50:41
Racism and Scapegoating

Unless you’ve been spending too much time at Malaysia Today (MT), you would have already known who the real perpetrators of racism were and still are – all this while. Why, even the perpetrators themselves knew it and probably sniggering with glee, that others, not they, are being branded racists.

It did not escape one’s notice that MT for all it good intentions and supposedly democratic fervour, have been swarmed by over-zealous and chauvinistic DAP-type kiasus. That’s the setback when you rely on the electronic or internet technology. Just ask Nita of Malaysian Idol or Faizal Tahir and Dayang of One in a Million. Sure, we’re happy for Daniel and Suki – after all they’re just reality shows – it’s no big deal! (you can bet that within minutes the piranha horde would pound on this and reduced it to LRC [show] piece - no worry, I'd be in the same league as Faizal!).

But to pronounce a conclusion that affects a whole community and condemn it in a widely read political blog is another thing! Scapegoating the whole of a specific community and even putting its religion in bad light - is just way, way too much and totally unacceptable! (And this is saying it mildly, I’d kicked asses if I could)

It’s interesting to note that when RPK says something like “the NEP has been hijacked by the UMNO-puteras” - the DAP horde reverberated longer echos of “NEP is racist, Malays are racists, Islam is racist” and curried by endless praises of how bold and upright RPK is. Yeah sure he is. It’s whether he realized what the end-game would be that I’m worried about.

But history don’t lie!

RPK is talking current events. And the sick UMNO have actually screwed up for the Malays, no disagreement there!. But let’s get it right. These UMNO idiots are not racists, far from it. They’re short-sighted, incompetent and greedy. Attributes which are applicable to the MCA and MIC idiots too. But racists..hardly. Why, many genuine Malay businessman hoping that some spin-off or residual businesses would filter down to them had been thoroughly disappointed. They’d actually be spot on if they’d accused UMNO-puteras of being anti-malay! There, I see the horde sniggering with glee again.

report abuse
disagree 2
agree 8
...
written by RickK, June 05, 2008 13:05:40
dmh1871 wrote:
"Maybe the Malays here should learn from the neighbouring non-malays by not being so accommodating only then the non-malays here would appreciate what they have."
I find it tiresome that people like you keep forgetting conveniently that NonMalays include the other bumiputeras like our Sabah/Sarawakian native and Orang Asli brothers who have at least as much as or not even more claim to being the original sons of the soil. So why are they not being "accommodated" in the high ranking civil service and army/defence positions. Surely it must NOT have escaped you that the recent Cabinet reshuffle did not include as many 'other' bumiputeras other than Malays even when they contributed significantly to BN's victory.

Enough of this "you should be thankful we didn't kick you into the sea,you ingrates,"rubbish. Did not ALL Malaysians build this country,from their sweat and effort and hard earned money.Or is our home merely a piece of land that the "owners have kindly and graciously allowed you to squat on,you greedy grasping bums"?

Did not Idris Jala,(a non-Malay bumi)thank God, succeed where other Malays failed in revitalising MAS?

We must recognise that no one of us has got it all together but all of together got it all.That's the key blind spot of people like you dmh1871.You only see "we gave you a place to stay"and nothing else.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by RickK, June 05, 2008 13:18:01
To grandmarquis,
In the west,with their obsession with political correctness,pluralism and human rights, even a squeak of protest from Muslims about being discriminated against would be made loud and widely publicised. Who would dare to mistreat them?It is precisely this kind of sentiment among the orang putih that would allow minorities to have an increasingly louder voice, public presence and more privileges than you have been led to believe.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by joeawk, June 05, 2008 13:53:15
Since Petronas accounts are not for public consumption, not even the MPs, we shall make assumption of how the money was lost and not used.

We shall assume that mahatir used a large part of it to bolster his position when he was PM thru'political corruption, bail out his cronies, support the alqeda terrorist movement and the separatists in Thailand and the Philippines.

No one knows except himself, right? What bullshit it is that a national corporation does not answer to the nation but to the PM. Just wonder if the accounts were auditted and by who?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by belljar, June 05, 2008 17:55:26
Last month, Umno Johor said that the greatest mistake they made was in giving the non-Malay immigrants citizenship in August 1957. Now that they have been given citizenship they show their ingratitude by voting for the opposition.

Who is the farker who said that!? Can we check his ancestry? The sheer arrogance and stupidity is unbelievable. They actually think we CAN only vote for them and no one else!

Our greatest mistake was to not kick UMNO/BN out sooner.......


report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Hiley, June 05, 2008 21:21:03
The method of execution in Islam for capital crimes is beheading with the sword. Swift and merciful! RPK’s protracted attempt at killing the wrongs of the Malays however seemed somewhat inhuman and unmerciful. He goes on and on and on, I wonder if the inmates at Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib - would fare better. Strike the sword and move on to more profound issues, RPK.

Okay, there are the UMNO screwed-up mutants who lead the malay community as well as the country and betrayed the trust placed on them. There were also the MCA and MIC co-conspirators who were helping themselves too. Alas!, there were also almost all the now big and successful corporations and tycoons who guided, misguided, manipulated and puppeteered the leadership for their own selfish ends.

But RPK, don’t you see that the real culprit and prime-movers of most misdeeds and mismanagements in our country may actually be the various special interests (tycoons and corporations –both malays and non malays- but since malays are mostly rent-seekers, can’t give them much credit here).

Okay I agree – the leaders in the government being the leaders must take full responsibility. Fine. They should. But if we keep on harping on it to nauseatic level, we are farting at the wrong tree.

Not many people in USA and the world like George W Bush. He is evil and also stupid! But is he the real author of whatever evil designs and hegemonistic policies USA put into operation? Of course not! Who then are the real perpetrators of evil working invisibly behind Bush? The Jewish interest, the military-industrial complex, represented by the neo-cons – these are the sort of interests that actually controlled Bush and his administration and even the legislative.

Hitting the malay leaders is like hitting a petty thief (okay, maybe they’re more like members of a big-time heist, but most of the time not the master-mind. Your story on Terengganu and Patrick Lim is a good example); and hitting the malay community would be like hitting a dim-witted victim. Tak kesian ke?
When things go wrong in a country, the people in the upper hand look for people to blame for whatever troubles of the time. When they see poor people getting caught in the ‘Along debt traps’ or their children becoming ‘mat rempits’ and drug-addicts, policemen and custom officers(with big families, many, many children, earning meager sums of RM 1,000 a month) taking bribes - they see these people as the problem. Rather than think about why such poverty and the widening income disparity are occurring in our country, they blame the poor and the underdogs themselves for the crisis. These poor-stricken and destitutes, RPK, are your people. Yes, your people – the malays!
This scapegoating, is a convenient way of control and manipulation by the powerful and people with the upper-hand and advantage. Blame the hapless victims! And between the UMNO leadership and the tycoons, corporations and other special interests, I regard the former (UMNO) as mere opportunistic stooges.
So when we talk about justice, RPK, I wish we’d go a bit deeper and profounder rather than badger poor dim-witted petty thieves. Or worse bullying the poor, impoverished but unwitting malay victims.
Guide me, big brother.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 6
...
written by Angel, June 05, 2008 21:23:28
It is true that the article has reflected the inner thoughts all this while of what the non Malays have been thinking but never had the avenue to express openly for fear of ISA, Sedition Act etc etc the previous regime had in place to make us toe the line. At least with the present regime there is a greater level of transparency and the ability to speak up, for which I am grateful. In the past all of the above comments would have had us locked up and keys thrown away. Today the political climate has made freedom of speech more comfortable.

I am especially glad that in the last GE the young has been more visible. These are now more politically aware of the goings on and are determined to strive for ideals for the greater good of the whole. I applaud them for this. They have opened our eyes to see that together and united we can make a difference and we were all pleasantly surprised at what had transpired. It was like a dream as we always thought the BN was invincible.

My view on religion is that our problem is in each religion claiming God for themselves when God the Almighty is for all. He is the God for all religions and we all belong to him, irrespective of colour, race or creed. He has claim over all of us and it is not for us to selfishly 'own' God for ourselves. We should see the bigger picture and think out of the box. Only then can we have peace on earth. AMEN.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 5
...
written by SBennit, June 05, 2008 21:33:05
Dear Mahathir

If the "list" was false, why couldnt you just say and leave it at that. Why the need to remove it?? We dont see you removing everything that is false on MT, do we??

Anyway Tun. I hope you end up in Sg Buloh, or even better. In Simpang Renggam.


This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by mahendra5, June 05, 2008 22:00:35
As a Citizen of Malaysia, be it a Malay, chinese or Indian he has the right of his choice to vote in the General Election for the political party of his choice. What has gratitute to do with this? Learn from America, where race
politics is gone and the Americans have nominated OBAMA (a Black) to be the next President of the United States of America. Lets learn to make the change for the better Malaysia rather than playing racial politics. Malaysians are becoming more liberal in their thoughts as the recent General Election
and the rythm of voting clearly endorses so.
Malaysia Today is doing a wonderful job by changing the mindset of our Malaysians. Keep up the good work Pete. Shakespeare's quote : SOME ARE BORN GREAT, SOME ACHIEVE GREATNESS, SOME HAVE GREATNESS THRUST UPON THEM. You have achieved Greatness in the eyes of our Malaysians. Great!Great!Great!
Mahendra
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by Panca Indera, June 06, 2008 02:32:24
Time for Chinese and Indian Bashing on RPK site just to see how they feel.

To those who say that RPK is the best example of true Muslim and feel and believe that he is the beacon of light that is missing in many of them, need to re-examine their he***

By doing a simple head-count on the comments these people deserves the shits that they been getting for being so ignorant of their surroundings.

That’s the problem of these people, watching Academy fantasia and spending too much time in the pubs, playing PC games, Chat sites, MSN , watching cheap pirated movies and loitering at shopping centers.

We are becoming a society of people that cannot think independently or be critical except following the crowd. These simple minded Malaysians cannot even see further than their noses. They are so into themselves, that they don’t understand or don’t want to know the real world. So they are happy that RPK is doing their dirty works. Shame on these bastards!

Thinking aloud there must be a conspiracy to defame,demoralize and marginalize the Muslims, especially the malays so that they can take over this country. Almost 70% percent of the Malays I spoke to, feel threathened by the present of Chinese and Indians in their mist who don’t practice the culture, speak the language properly and behaving is disgusting manners, ie.
1.Korek lubang hidong
2.spitting and coughing without covering their mouth,
3.Burping nosily
4.farting in public
5.tooth-picking
6.squatting by ro***ides
7.burning offering by ro***ide for hungry ghosts(really!) and don’t clean after that.
8.Letting their small children urinating in front of public places without showing respect to others
9.talking loudly and shouting without regards to others and much more.

That’s why they are too successful, NOTHING is Illegal or Haram to a Chinaman!
Even cheating is Ok as long as you are not caught.

Remember the only thing straight about the chinese is their hair!
As for the indians,there is a proverb in Fiji that goes, that if you come across a poisonous snake and an Indian, kill the indian first.



The Chinese holds 90% of the economic cakes and wants to grab the political and governmental leadership as well. That shows how greedy they are. They keep their names they keep their culture, they keep their schools, and if we are not careful they will keep this country as well.

Prove to the majority honest,cleaning living but slightly dumb,naive and unsophisticated Malays that they are wrong, Go on make my day!

Lets see some more non Muslims and non Malays bashing people and see how the other side feel.
smilies/angry.gif smilies/angry.gif smilies/angry.gif
report abuse
disagree 11
agree 5
...
written by mudtel, June 06, 2008 08:06:18
Well, we REGRET that we were given malaysian citizenship. If not, we would have been given british citizenship. We then would be able to see how this country rots and sink into powerty.

Our elected government officials are corrupted and have no intelligence whatsoever in country economic planning, management and governance. It will be no surprise that ringgit will continue to drop against the ASEAN countries. This country economic growth is mainly fueled by consumer spendings and the so called immigrant businesses. Its every 5-year development plan is to enrich a small group of privileged and connected individuals only, not for the people.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Panca Indera, June 06, 2008 11:44:13
Well, we REGRET that we were given malaysian citizenship. If not, we would have been given british citizenship. We then would be able to see how this country rots and sink into powerty.
LOL
Yeh! Dream on about the british giving you Guys Citizenship! They would rather send you back to China and India and even Palestine! Ha Ha.
Even now , with all the chinese and Indian in UK(just passed thru Passport control at Heathrow airport where a Sadar with turban said "(welcome to my country!", can you find Chinese/indian Schools and hugh temples there?
Can you Find Chinese Ministers or PM?
You can find chinese takeaways, which are usually nests for illigals and vices and where cats and dogs are not save and not far away from the menu.

You guys should go, its never too late.At least we have more room to fack ourselves up without any slant eyes or tamil tigers trying to upset the apple cart or blow our asses off.
Does it hurt yet?
Only Muslims have the ultimate right to Govern the World, not the jews nor Christians nor anybody else!(scare yet?)
WE shall cut off only the offending foreskins but but the whole thing so that they can't reproduce(sound like Hitlerish)

smilies/tongue.gif smilies/tongue.gif smilies/tongue.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif
report abuse
disagree 10
agree 3
...
written by Panca Indera, June 06, 2008 12:33:35
While the Malays dispute among themselves and let their guards down, look at

Defending the oppressed nation of Palestine and opposing with the octopus network of Zionism are part and parcel of the revolution.
He said the Jewish state was weak and unable to survive without outside help:
There are two reasons for its standing on its feet. One is the contemptuous support without any preconditions of the U.S. and the other reason is that Arab and Islamic countries do not support the Palestinian people. Israel is a forgery and an imposed country in the region, and if the Arab and Islamic countries support the Palestinian nation, the circumstances in the Middle East will change entirely.
Much of Khamenei's speech focused on Iran's domestic situation. He said the turbulent and ideologically first years of the Islamic Republic served as a guide for today's leadership.

"The political will of the late Imam Khomeini should be the manual for running day-to-day routine of the country now and in the years to come, generation after generation," he said.
In his speech, he allowed for no possibility of changing the system to keep up with changing times:
The Islamic revolution is like Islam, as the religion is comprehensive. It is political, social, cultural, religious at the same time and that is the secret of its survival. No one has the right to ignore or separate one part of the Islamic revolution's values, simply because circumstances in the world have changed. Nobody has the right to forget the anti-despotic and anti-alien forces character of the revolution or to ignore religious values of the revolution. This revolution is alive with all its revolutionary slogans. This revolution belongs to all walks of society and it is not exclusive to one specific walk or class.
The worshipers and pilgrims at Khomeini's shrine responded with uproarious praise. "Oh, free-minded leader," they chanted, "we are fully ready."
Khamenei likened Iranians who failed to support the revolution's values to those who break the Ramadan fast before dusk but also appealed to Iran's nationalism. Islam, he said, strengthened the Iranian nation.
Our Islamic revolution is a contribution to the progress of the nation. Enemies of the nation for years argued that progress is mutually exclusive with religion. On the contrary ... the spirit of revolution has empowered the nation in all fields. Islamic revolution has been a short cut between backwardness and West-toxification.
"Death to America!" the faithful chanted. "Death to America!"
"Today," he continued, "a cold war against the Islamic revolution is taking place and it's waged by the arrogant powers in all aspects of life. In the cultural field the enemies want to undermine the determination of our nation, especially the youth, by spreading narcotic addiction and promoting debauchery among young generation. Every single member of society should fight against narcotic addiction and debauchery so that young people channel their energies into innovation and scientific progress."

America and Israel are thruly truly facked Inshallah! smilies/cool.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 3
...
written by DontPlayGod, June 06, 2008 13:35:59
UMNO has been in power so long that they have come to believe that only they have the right to govern the country, that only they are the true Muslims and Malays, and that there can be other Malays. Hence, all non-Malays owe their allegiance to UMNO(and now ABIM) and to no others. To support other political parties or NGO's is tantamount to being disloyal and being traitors.

And thus we can see MCA subscribing to this ideology by being 100% subservient to UMNO. Even an UMNO division head dare to insult the MCA president, and the MCA president will quickly duduk diam diam.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by DontPlayGod, June 06, 2008 13:40:35
Sorry, line 2 should read...."and that there can be no other Malays."
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by mrbean, June 07, 2008 19:16:57
fark the remarks of umno johor for saying that they made a mistake by giving us chinese citizenship. as far as i am concerned , the citizenship is worthless because we are not treated like citizens. you can have it back. read your history books and find out who are the true bumiputeras of malaysia.. they are the orang asli people.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by mrbean, June 07, 2008 19:22:03
To panca indera w.r.t to your remarks below;
the only reason your type of people and religion thrives is because you are living in the 1st century and have the mindsets of a nomad. sorry to say, it is already well known to be a backward relgn associated with terrorism and extremism...


Well, we REGRET that we were given malaysian citizenship. If not, we would have been given british citizenship. We then would be able to see how this country rots and sink into powerty.
LOL
Yeh! Dream on about the british giving you Guys Citizenship! They would rather send you back to China and India and even Palestine! Ha Ha.
Even now , with all the chinese and Indian in UK(just passed thru Passport control at Heathrow airport where a Sadar with turban said "(welcome to my country!", can you find Chinese/indian Schools and hugh temples there?
Can you Find Chinese Ministers or PM?
You can find chinese takeaways, which are usually nests for illigals and vices and where cats and dogs are not save and not far away from the menu.

You guys should go, its never too late.At least we have more room to fack ourselves up without any slant eyes or tamil tigers trying to upset the apple cart or blow our asses off.
Does it hurt yet?
Only Muslims have the ultimate right to Govern the World, not the jews nor Christians nor anybody else!(scare yet?)
WE shall cut off only the offending foreskins but but the whole thing so that they can't reproduce(sound like Hitlerish)
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 0
...
written by mrbean, June 07, 2008 19:23:39
and the british gave the hongkies british citizenship..they would have given the chinese in malaysia too.. but one thing for sure they wont give people like you who are lazy and useless and has one less foreskin
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 0
...
written by Panca Indera, June 07, 2008 21:07:15
"but one thing for sure they wont give people like you who are lazy and useless and has one less foreskin"

You hear that , all you Melayus. That’s what the majority of the chinks think of you LAZY and USELESS!. They are here to take over your country!!! Wake –up

Note: By not having foreskin we don’t have tahi palat underneath,that white smelly think has to be constantly unsheathed to clean. Yeh you stinky tahi palat, Keh keh
Medically proven too of less chance of catching STD.

Is it true that your pussies are horizontal, kah, kah
smilies/tongue.gif smilies/tongue.gif smilies/tongue.gif
report abuse
disagree 9
agree 3
...
written by Siapabohong, June 10, 2008 03:21:47
Dear RPK,
Indeed an excellent piece of writing which I believe many non-Muslims must have been thinking to write but do not know how to put it on paper and of course the seditious nature that the ever sensitive authority look at it. Most of my friends are Malays. Naturally they are very nice, gentle and friendly people whom pay lots of respect for others, something like the softer side of the Chinese cultures in the old imperior period in China.
However, once the powers that be indoctorined their minds with policies that directly or indirectly put a very bad pictures on the non-Malays especially the Chinese and the sole monoply of the religion which I can put as Islam solely belongs to the Malays, so even the non-Malays who converted to Islam is still regards as outsiders, would be worse if the non-Malay Muslims do not really embrace the Malay culture in their daily life. This I believe put off the non-Malays to know more about or to embrace to Islam and promote wrong perception about the religion and the Malays themselves. Why should the non-Malays bother to know if the religion is taken as non-entry domain and doesn't belong to the non-Malays. I think this is one of the reason the non-Malays, especially the Chinese hates the powers that be but not the Malays. The other day I come to read about that the top guns of in the powers that be asking among themselves why the Chinese hate them and their party so much. I think they should come to accept the reality that they themselves created this situation of hate among the people in this country and a very superficial friedliness among them with and the non-Malays. They themselves created the suspicious nature and among the races in this country. When one dies and to meet God, I come to know that the dead person would be asked questions in the grave such as 'who is your God and your prophet and what is your religion'. Would the dead person be punished in the grave if the person answered, my God is your God, my prophet is your prophet but I was not allow to profess Islam as my religion by the authority because I am a non-Malay.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by CJ7, June 10, 2008 10:12:58
err...afterall, god or no god, we need capable ppl to run d country, not only d prime minister but at all level...we talk too much but no action
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by purpleshoppe, June 10, 2008 11:29:35
Pardon me but I am but an ignorant Malaysian educated in the national system designed by the Ministry of Education of Malaysia. If I remember my Sejarah correctly, which I diligently read from age 14 to 17 - it says that the Malays of Nusantara migrated from the archipelago of Indonesian islands to Malaya. The rightful owners of Malaya therefore (non-immigrants), could be the deprived orang aslis living in Sabah, Sarawak and jungles of Perak now, no?

I have not been privileged to the superior education perhaps enjoyed by the Johorians who made that remark - so I could be ignorant. Just a thought, perhaps the orang aslis would wake up one day and say the exact same words to the Johorians. Perhaps....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by Jit Dharma, June 10, 2008 13:58:20
Sometimes I feel sorry for my countrymen/women. The gravity of the situation,
that is the many complexities of our reality can produce a serious unbalancing
of their humanity.A little consideration for your fellow passengers on this
frail enterprise called Malaysia, as it sails into the vast unknown would certainly improve your disposition.Consider his/her humanity before you chop
them up into bite sized cliches that will further aid your misunderstanding
of them.








report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by Leon, June 10, 2008 17:38:43
Well said, YM Pete! AMEN!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by DontPlayGod, June 11, 2008 00:47:24
As far as I am concerned, the situation in Malaysia is hopeless for the non-Malays in the coming years(perhaps within the next 15-20 years).

UMNO is bent on playing the race card. They have openly said that they have made a mistake in giving the non-Malays citizenship since the non-Malays have become traitors(by voting non-BN parties is tantamount to becoming traitors). I don't see the leaders of UMNO or the police charging those who said these as being seditious. I wonder what, if any, is the response from MCA, Gerakan, and MIC. Elegant silence, I think. UMNO leaders can say anything and get away with it. They will never be hauled up by the police for an 8-hour session of interrogation.

Can we trust UMNO to govern the country fairly? Sometimes I wonder why MCA, MIC, and Gerakan keep on hanging on to the sarong of UMNO.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by DontPlayGod, June 12, 2008 12:01:52
mrbean wrote:

"Yeh! Dream on about the british giving you Guys Citizenship! They would rather send you back to China and India and even Palestine! Ha Ha."

You must be real ignorant. Those born in Penang and Melaka before independence are granted British citizenship on request. And the constitution also accepts dual citizenship for these peoples in Penang and Melaka.

But people in Penang and Melaka prefer to stay(and remain) and be loyal to our country. Is this wrong? Is UMNO fuming over this? Maybe you can blame your Malay leaders then for not sending all the non-Malays out of this country at independance. Blame UMNO for making this "mistake".

The day will come not so long in the future, when the Malays have exceeded 80% ratio in the population(Mahathirs's dream), then all this race, and religous issues no longer arise. The Malays can then truly tell the others to leave if they are not happy. Malaysia will then also truly be on the way to a full Islamic state. The non-Malays will then no longer have any say in the running of the country. Yes, that is the vision of our TDM, latest by 2025, if not by 2020. UMNO can then rule forever.

The non-Malays, by then, will also willingly leave, as without the oil money, the country will be another Zimbabwe, or even like another Myanmar. For your info. the exodus started from the 70's, and still continuing.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 

 
** SPONSORED LINKS **
Will NATO become a global army? More..

Sponsored Links

World Futures  Close down the NATO, says the conference statement on the recently concluded and successful International Conference on NATO & Its Policies in ASIA.

Future Fastforward  A controversial analysis by a controversial analyst, Matthias Chang, the lawyer-writer who unabashedly calls a spade a spade and offers no apology for doing so.

Internet TV 3000+ Channels  Pick your favorite internet TV channels straight to your PC! Yay!

Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM