A+ | A- | Reset
Home arrow The Blogs arrow No Holds Barred arrow Elementary, my dear Watson

Elementary, my dear Watson PDF Print E-mail
Posted by admin   
Monday, 31 March 2008 14:32

Image 

Why can’t we build more universities? We spent RM100 million to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of Merdeka last August. That is one university complete with equipment, fittings, libraries, and whatnot. We spend RM300 million a year on the Terengganu Monsoon Cup. That would be another three universities a year.

NO HOLDS BARRED

Raja Petra Kamarudin

More than 50 years or so ago, when I was still a baby, my mother weaned me off my bottle in quite a shattering manner, literally-speaking of course. After I finished drinking my milk, I would hurl the bottle over the cot and it would go crashing to the floor and shatter into a million pieces. In those days, milk bottles were made of glass, not of plastic like nowadays. Plastic technology, then, was not as advanced as today so bottles were made of glass -- and tins from tin, tyres from rubber, car dashboards from wood, and so on. Today, of course, nothing is original any longer and most products are manufactured from synthetic materials. Even ‘wooden’ car dashboards and faces of certain Menteri Besar are made from plastic.

The cost to replace my bottles was certainly pretty exorbitant and eventually it became cheaper to carpet the entire room to cushion the bottles when they came crashing to the floor. One day, however, my mother removed the carpet and when I threw my bottle out of my cot it hit the floor and smashed into smithereens. My mother stormed into the room and raised quite a ruckus. “That’s it,” she said, “now you have no more bottle. You will have to drink from a cup from now on.”

When it came time for my next milk routine, my mother brought my drink in a cup and I of course refused to drink it out of a cup. I wanted my bottle. My mother then reminded me that I had just smashed my bottle that very morning so I would now have to drink out of a cup or else no milk for me. It was either a cup or no milk so I reluctantly agreed to the cup. It was I, after all, who had smashed my bottle so I really had no one else to blame except myself. Eventually the cup became second nature until I discovered that there are certain drinks that are best drunk straight from a bottle. But that would be another story for another time though.

When my wife and I got our first baby, the deal was: she had carried our daughter for nine long months so it was now my turn to suffer -- I had to wake up at 3.00am to feed the baby. The first week was very tiring and I went to office the following day feeling very groggy. The second week, however, I filled the bottle with plain water and after three days or so my daughter no longer woke up in the middle of the night. She probably did not find it remunerating enough to wake up just for a drink of plain water.

There is currently quite a bit of brouhaha about the continuation of the New Economic Policy or NEP. Even ‘progressive’ Malays like Shahrir Samad, surprisingly, are of the opinion that the NEP must be retained because the Malays are not yet ready for the removal of their ‘security blanket’. I suppose, as long as you still bottle-feed the Malays, they would continue to demand it. But once the bottle is smashed or you feed them plain water, they may decide to move on and not keep clinging to their baby ways.

There are two things about the NEP. One concerns education and the other business opportunities. The education part is actually not as complex as what some make it out to be. Sure, there are certain quotas allocated to Malays while non-Malays are given a token quota. And because of the limited places in local universities, the non-Malays have to pay for their own education, in particular at overseas universities.

But does this need to be so? China has more than 1,000 universities with more than 100 in Beijing alone. Malaysia, which has only twice the population of Beijing, does not even come close to the number of Beijing universities. Based on the Beijing population to number of universities ratio, Malaysia should have at least 250 universities as opposed to less than 10% that at the present moment.

Why can’t we build more universities? We spent RM100 million to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of Merdeka last August. That is one university complete with equipment, fittings, libraries, and whatnot. We spend RM300 million a year on the Terengganu Monsoon Cup. That would be another three universities a year. We are spending more than RM3 billion on the second Penang bridge. That would be about 35 universities. With savings from this, that and the other, we could have 100 new universities built over 10 years.

Yes, we do have money. It is only that the money is spent on the wrong things. According to Umno circles, Daim Zainuddin has transferred RM42 billion of our taxpayers’ money out of the country and has sunk this colossal amount into about ten banks that he owns in Africa and Eastern Europe. That RM42 billion plus all the other money that has disappeared into the pockets of Umno cronies could have built 1,000 universities, as many as they have in China though our population is just twice that of Beijing.

If our money had been well-managed and better-spent, today we would have more universities than students. We would be begging Malaysians to go to university because most of the lecture halls would be empty. Who would need the NEP? There would be no need for racial quotas. Our problem would not be about limiting places in universities so that these places could be reserved for Malays. Our problem would be about how to convince non-Malays to stop going overseas and instead go to local universities because there are just not enough students for the too many universities.

But the reality of the situation is, our money has been wasted. Billions have disappeared into the pockets of Umno warlords and their cronies. Billions have been spent on the wrong things. I have estimated that, over 30 years, Petronas has earned about RM1 trillion. One Petronas consultant tells me that I am wrong. The figure should be RM2 trillion, he says. RM1 trillion or RM2 trillion what’s the difference? Both figures are equally exorbitant.

If just part of that money had gone into building one new university a year, today Malaysia would have no less than 50 universities. They could have even built 100 universities over 30 years with RM2 trillion. And we would then no longer need to reserve places in these universities. We would no longer require racial quotas. And this means we would no longer need the NEP.

The NEP started in 1970 and has gone on for 38 years now. We started earning petroleum revenue in 1974 and have continued earning for 34 years now. But the petroleum money did not go into addressing what ails this country. And soon this petroleum money will dry up but what ails us will remain. We missed a golden opportunity to resolve our race problems with the income from the black gold. But we did not. And because of that we still need the NEP because, without the NEP, Malays would not have places in local universities.

The NEP is not just about education or places in universities, some would say. It is also about business opportunities. Sure, but is that an excuse not to solve at least half the problem; racial quotas in universities. If we solve one problem then we will have only one problem left to solve. Now, after 38 years, we still have two unresolved problems, and both involve race and racial quotas.

Okay, say that the government had solved the problem of racial quotas in local universities by building so many universities that there are no longer enough students, Malays or otherwise, to fill them up. This would still not solve the second problem of creating more business opportunities for Malays, many would argue. Actually this is not quite true. Malays have been in business since before 1969 and these Malays were actually very successful in their time.

Take Abdullah Ahmad Badawi’s ex-father-in-law as one example. Mahmud Ambak was a very successful businessman, as were his peers such as Safuan, Mat Jan, HM Shah, and so on. No doubt there was only a handful of such people and you could count them on your fingers of one hand. But the numbers were beginning to grow and, in the East Coast, the Malays were involved in all types of businesses and were even beating the non-Malays on top of that.

Then came the NEP and with it came the quotas and Umnoputeras. Eventually the rent-seekers and commission agents monopolised the scene. Furthermore, you had to be an Umno warlord to obtain businesses, contracts and quotas -- so eventually your Umno membership and not your business acumen decided whether you got ahead or not. The genuine businessmen soon folded up and the Ali Babas; Umno Malays backed by Chinese towkays; took over. And what we see today are products of the NEP rather than genuine businessmen who made it because they are good in business.

The NEP killed the ‘real’ Malays. In their place emerged the Umnoputeras. Without the NEP and with a level playing field, Malays would have made it -- but only the good Malays, not the commission agents. Granted, without the NEP, there would have been fewer Malays in business. But these few Malays would have been the quality Malays. Now we have the ‘low-class’ Malays who made it only because they are Umnoputeras and for no other reason. Why play the numbers game? Why go for quantity without quality? Would it not have been better to see the birth of the Robert Kuoks, Queks and Tan Chin Tuans of the Malay community, people we could be proud of?

To say that the Malays would never reach the level of the Robert Kuoks, Queks and Tan Chin Tuans without the help of the NEP is an insult to the Malays. I, for one, believe I can make it with or without the NEP. To say I am who I am because of the NEP and that I would be nothing if not for the NEP is a great insult and I take it as an insult. I believe that without the NEP and without the unfair advantage given to the Umnoputeras there would be no ‘ceiling’ above my head and the sky would be my limit.

But alas, I need to be Umno to get ahead and I need to be an Umnoputera to get my hands on quotas, contracts and permits to make it in the business world. It is not a level playing field and unless I am prepared to play the game according to the rules of the game then I had better not bother to play at all.

The NEP is our milk bottle. But eventually we need to grow up and discard the bottle. We are now 38 years old so surely we should stop drinking from the bottle by now. But we are still being given the bottle. And the bottle is in the form of the NEP. And because of that we are still babies even at 38 years old. And our ‘mother’ tells us that we are still going to be given the bottle over the next 50 years. I will not live another 50 years. I may not even live another ten. But I shall still be offered the bottle till the day I go to my grave.

Yes, we Malays are going to die as babies. We shall never be allowed to grow up. We shall never see that bottle go crashing to the ground and getting smashed into a million pieces. And because we have never be weaned out of the bottle we shall know no other way in which to drink our milk. And we will never learn how to eat rice because we do not know how to grow and cook rice. But one day, when the ‘mother’ dies, we shall cry and cry, asking for our milk that will never come. And the baby will die when the mother dies because the baby knows no other way in which to feed itself other than waiting for the mother to bring the bottle.

That is the sad future for the Malays. Do you now know why the baby does not want the mother known as Umno to die? This is because the baby needs its daily dose of milk which only the mother can provide.

Comments (147)Add Comment
...
written by RudyD, March 31, 2008 14:41:45
How many MALAYS out there will have the same thinking like you RPK??.. those are spoon-feed babies, they wont change for once, NEVER !!!!
report abuse
disagree 17
agree 355
...
written by hakuna, March 31, 2008 14:52:01
Well done Pete.
You have been writing differing articles but the essence is still the same - beautiful.
This one is really simple to digest - just like in the old days - economics made simple - the "simple" series.
This is RPK's "UNDERSTANDING MadE SIMPLE".
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 265
...
written by adzera, March 31, 2008 14:52:42
From reading this article, i come to 1 conclusion: DAIM IS A THIEF....HANG HIM!!!!
report abuse
disagree 7
agree 167
...
written by southallman, March 31, 2008 14:53:02
Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day....teach a man to fish and he will eat for a lifetime
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 200
...
written by toolan, March 31, 2008 14:57:07
Unfortunately the addiction of the NEP has set in deep in. Its now up to the remaining awakened few to initiate the least enviable task to reform this painful mindset. In this respect, the non malay should sincerely contribute in the spirit of encouragement.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 55
...
written by adiiskandar, March 31, 2008 15:00:43
It is very true indeed. In order to progress, we must compete on a level ground.
I have always believe that NEP caused more detrimental than good. Malays are to scared to even to let it go. If we want this country to progress, we must stand on even ground. We work harder, we gain better.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 91
...
written by voice of the nation, March 31, 2008 15:02:27
Mr Petra.

You are right. Education is priority. But do you think there is enough awareness among those in the corridors of power at the moment, to bring about the results we look forward to?
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 44
...
written by Ben Nordin, March 31, 2008 15:06:54
A great article, RPK. I don't mind Affirmative Action but it has to be for all deserving Malaysians and not just Malays. I have long believed that UMNO is the one who needed the NEP so that they can line up their own pockets. When the NEP is threatened then they would bring up the racial issues. Tasteless, really. Like one of the posters said, "Malays do not need UMNO but UMNO needs Malays so that they can bleed the country through NEP or Wang Ihsan or whatever."
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 126
...
written by tkahyap, March 31, 2008 15:08:44
Quote "To say that the Malays would never reach the level of the Robert Kuoks, Queks and Tan Chin Tuans without the help of the NEP is an insult to the Malays. I, for one, believe I can make it with or without the NEP. To say I am who I am because of the NEP and that I would be nothing if not for the NEP is a great insult and I take it as an insult. I believe that without the NEP and without the unfair advantage given to the Umnoputeras there would be no ‘ceiling’ above my head and the sky would be my limit."

Well said! I always think that Malays are just as smart as anybody else. I read somewhere once that some of the best Maths talents from Malaysia are Malays. Its unfortunate that because of NEP, each time even when a Malay achieve something by merit, go into Oxford, or Harvard, the Chinese and Indians will be sneering "you got there because of quota" or "you got the scholarship because you are Malay". Its terribly unfair, and it's tearing our nation apart.
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 87
...
written by RudyD, March 31, 2008 15:10:27
report abuse
disagree 13
agree 72
...
written by RudyD, March 31, 2008 15:14:08
report abuse
disagree 8
agree 30
...
written by grant, March 31, 2008 15:15:47
First, building 1000 universities in Msia would yield more otak udang students! Trust me... Seriously. I am not kidding. Today, with the number of universities we have, the govt is already trying their best to place and push the Bumi's into Uni. Irregardless what their Form 5 or Form 6 results, are as long as u are a Bumi, ur chances are bright.

This is fact and let's face it... And everyone will agree with me (though I dont give a fark if I get -ve votes again). Back in my time when I was in Uni, my class had 60 odd students with the non-Bumi making only a handful - to be exact less than 15.

I would categorize this group of students into 3 batches
- Smart and work hard
- Average and work hard
- Stupid and yet dont work hard

From this 3 categories, I would go a little further to break them into another 3 groups from grade perspective
- Hons 2nd Class and above
- General Degree
- Gagal Berhenti (GB)

Within the 1st mth in Uni, my class of 60 odd students were left with 40odd.. This category is what I would call - Bodoh Category! U know why Bodoh? These people think Uni is like a McD drive thru. U drive thru Uni, look see look see... thinking that Uni is a stroll in the park only to be proven wrong and finally leave after the first mth!

Anyways, to cut a long story short... by the time we had completed our degree, only 20 plus of us remained. And out of that 20 plus students, more than 50% were non-Bumis.. Out of that 50%, another 50% fell in the category of 2nd Class and above. That was the non-Bumi..

If I recall correctly, only less than 5 Malay students ( who fall under the average and hardworking) category made it thru Uni with 2nd class hons and above.. The rest were GB (Gagal Berhenti) or General Degree...

What does this tell u? If Msia had 1000 Universities, we will have more drop outs than graduates. And when the govt realizes this, everyone will pass without even having to worry about failing.. By then, we will have penarik beca who is also a degree holder... or perhaps a degree bus conductor..

My point is, irregardless how many universities u have, how much u can spend to build universities, what is more important is raising the level of education quality...
report abuse
disagree 21
agree 260
...
written by shooks, March 31, 2008 15:15:50
We, Malays, must realise that we are not as weak as UMNO makes us to be.

It is only when we think that we are weak that they can be the champion of the Malays. And what's worse, they rob the country blind in OUR name.

I, for one, think that the NEP should be abolished. I've been getting along fine with my business without the government's help, thank you very much.

Do I worry about the future of my children? The answer is NO for I'm raising my kids to be strong, smart, independent & capable to compete with the best of them.

Bring it on!
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 205
...
written by seek justice, March 31, 2008 15:21:32
Voice of the Nation wrote :

You are right. Education is priority. But do you think there is enough awareness among those in the corridors of power at the moment, to bring about the results we look forward to?

________________________

Elementary, my dear Watson

There is no awareness among those in the corridors of power, not now, not ever! What we want and what they want are different as night and day. We want to be represented, they (UMNOPuteras)want to be filthy rich by being politicians. Issues that matters to us are only addressed albeit via promises once overy 4 to 5 years. But we never learn!

NEP is hogwash. Bagai menyimbah air ke daun keladi. The UMNOPuteras would wait underneath the daun keladi to get the water -- they would stoop that low!

It would be good if some form of awareness campaign amongst the young, particularly those in universities is put in place to communicate to the masses how evil the NEP is. Maybe, varsities can organize and interactive type of program like debates to get the young to really understand the malice of NEP.

I've long started with my own children, if they do not really do well to deserve a scholarship, they will not get it. I ain't gonna approach a 'Datuk' or his wife or an old friend to get something that they don't deserve.

If I have the means, eventhough my children deserve the scholarship, I would (had done so, in fact) decline it to show my stance on the issue of quota system.

If you think about it, who are the Malays who are making a big deal about the NEP being scraped -- what do they care, they already are eating from a silver platter, sending their children abroad for studies, shop in international cities...

If they really care about the Malays, live like the Malays in Kampung Melayu Subang or Gombak or Kg Telok Mat Acheh, Yan, Kedah- culture, lifestyle and everything. Then, probably they can start to emphatise, if not have an inkling of what life really is as rakyats!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 46
...
written by Heikal, March 31, 2008 15:22:59
From my poiny of view, the NEP should go on, but not the way it is implemented. The Malays are lazy, like to procrastinate and tend to be emotional with critism(i know this because i am a malay myself). I propose that the NEP should be carried out in the means of helping them like teaching them how to run business and indutrial skills not by giving them special advantage and shotcuts like racial quota. Let's say that Lim Guan Eng never found a qualified malay to give contracts to, then let some malays to work with the ones that got contracts, therefore the malays will learn something and gained experience.
report abuse
disagree 13
agree 53
...
written by chin, March 31, 2008 15:23:29
I am not sure if the NEP has benefited the Malay businessmen at all. When a taxi driver and the gardener gets the multimillion dollar project instead of the overseas trained Malay engineer, I doubt many Malay engineer will go into business.

What I am sure of and I tell anyone who would listen is that UMNO oppresses the non-Malay in education so that the Malay appears to be privileged in this regards. It is illogical that a country with so much money would spend so little of it developing its people assets. LKY started Singapore with only their people’s brains, look where they are now.

UMNO brand of apartheid is worse than South Africa, it would condemn its non-Malay population and the country to mediocrity just because its serves their political control of the Malays.

The MSC and all these other “Development Corridors” are just bullshit if there are not enough qualified people to work in them. The government talks about moving up the value chain in manufacturing, but people assets are the prerequisite for this strategy. And I don't mean more Indon and Bangalah workers.

And the stupid Education Ministry is not helping by compromising the standard of education just to show higher passing rate.

Not only is the country NOT investing in education, it is destroying the standard of the existing local universities while all these UMNOputras send their children overseas.

While these UMNOputras rob the nation of its wealth, it is also robbing the common people of their future.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 87
...
written by malaysianohope, March 31, 2008 15:24:57
Greetings Pete,

"If one is still drinking milk at the age of 38, then something is seriously wrong especially when the Malaysian weather is hot and steamy. If the mother is no longer around who are they going to get the milk from???"

Seriously, for one to be successful in business one has to be good at networking, which is what Chinese are good at. Perhaps if the day the Malays treat the Chinese and Indians as equals as in 'Malaysia for Malaysians" then I believe everybody can be a Robert Kuok or Loh Boon Siew or Tony Fernandez(Ananda does not apply since he is tainted with political connections). That will be the day when NEP is weened off forever.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 25
...
written by notsosmart, March 31, 2008 15:31:23
............We would be begging Malaysians to go to university because most of the lecture halls would be empty. Who would need the NEP?..............


==================================================

It's not the quotas, actually. Logically and a little common sense, it's about apartheid and discrimination of the non-Malay in your very own country. That's why the Malays' should feel guilt and pity for those poor rakyat, especially non-Malay, that suffered badly by the ill-treatment from the gomen. Time for you to show your compassion and humanity to your fellow rakyat.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 22
...
written by chin, March 31, 2008 15:32:15
Dear Grant,

You left out the fact that only the mediocre Malays study in local university.

When I was in secondary school and that was 30 years ago, there were a few very bright Malay boys and girls in my class, none of them stayed in form 6, they all received overseas scholarships.

That may explain your experience in the local uni.

report abuse
disagree 2
agree 44
...
written by smalluncle, March 31, 2008 15:38:24
NEP NEP NEP - the only reason UMNO harping on NEP is for their UMNOPutras interest (looking at the way Sharir spoke - he is included) So, only way is to change the government.

Its TIME.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 19
...
written by bumi non malay, March 31, 2008 15:40:24
SO is that the reasons why Tun Dr Senile is being prodded to attack Anwar with his West link recently......With GOOD West link Central Bank can kosha with each other and dig up INFORMATION on DAIM, TUN, UMNO, BN....etc. smilies/shocked.gif smilies/shocked.gif

Perhaps now need to fast track the Fall of UMNO-BN in 4 months....anyway all those $42 billions will probably be worth maybe $10-20 billion now...due to sub prime, CDO, mortgage default.....and the money all trapped in Financial Crisis...Lets hope the UMNO DAIM Cronies invested Badly and ALL $42 gone belly up... Let the cronies go after Daim........and that is why Chaos 2007 have just begun...rather swiftly too....in no time I can sit back and watch the Malaysia Anger Show.......aim for ALL UMNO-BN Cronies Leaders....easy to identify tinted cars, have Dato, Datuk....and wife all have heavy make up BOTOX..... smilies/cheesy.gif smilies/cheesy.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/cheesy.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif

Keep UP the Boycott...the best time to tighten up and give UMNO-BN a CREDIT CRUNCH!!...let them Do A DOG eat DOG game
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 12
...
written by oknyua, March 31, 2008 15:50:38
I witness NEP in practice:

Sometimes in the year 2001, I started a small business where my clients, contacts were small Malay businessmen. Edie operates 2 restaurants that employs around 50 workers, Zul distributes fish waking up at 2.00 am in the morning to collect supply, Din has his own workshop and also a 10-acre oil palm plantation. A few more.

I am very proud of these people. They do not require the milk bottle at all. I am also proud that they do not see me of different language and skin. But they do need help from now and then. I provides advice on banking and finance - similarly I do not take offence when their children were selected to Sekolah Science or the local universities. I tumpang gembira.

If affirmative policies of NEP takes care of people like Zul, Din, Edie, Ah Chong, Muthu, Kadazan, Iban, Orang Asli - I am all for it. As a tax payer, I do not take offence to helping the deserving - we wrote cheques for the 2006 Johore Flood, didn't we? (Except someone who went sailing lah).

But my business also saw the ugly side of NEP. I see black Mercedes, and MPVs coming to my shop ordering goods that definitely were allocated for Class F and E contractors. They depended on all the "Waks" (Indon contractors), to make the order because they do not know anything at all. I hated it because I know them. They talk about golf with "datuk", meeting with MB, Peransang people. The "F" license was under wife's name.

What I saw: The rich took the milk bottle and the poor take the crumbs. (UMNO supporters, please wake up lah).
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 82
...
written by Raja Petra, March 31, 2008 15:53:12
In the 'old days', when I was still in school, MCKK had form 6. Then all the bright form 5 students were sent overseas and there was hardly a single form 5 student who went to form 6. So, eventually, they brought in 'outsiders' to go to form 6 and soon all MCKK form 6 students were no longer from MCKK form 5 but from other schools. Now they no longer have form 6 because no form 5 students from MCKK are retained but are sent overseas (they are just too smart for form 6). So these 'local' form 6 students eventually go to local universities. And these are the Malays you get to meet at local universities so you think that all Malays are bodoh whereas in fact the smart ones are 'hidden' overseas.
report abuse
disagree 4
agree 66
...
written by cruzeiro, March 31, 2008 15:53:37
Things will change the day, the Malays realize that it was never about "uplifting the Malays" (more so, since the time of TDM). What the common man got was simply loose change.

The "uplifting Malays" rhetoric, was simply blinders used on a gullible and insecure people.
Thru & thru, it was simply a means of maintaining a vice grip on Power, and enriching the "elite" (regardless of NEP) thru corruption - while creating an insecure & dependant group of people, paralyzed in all aspects of life thru this same corruption.

Just like TDM today, they would of course say that they never did anything wrong, as it was totally legal!
...........................
Denial is so sweet ...... just like stolen fruits.

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 17
...
written by tcng, March 31, 2008 15:53:43
TDM called it 'crutch', I called it 'ganja', but I like RPK's 'milk bottle' analogy better. Thanks to the Malay leaders, more than one generation of Malay had been brought up 'conditioned' to the milk bottle.
Let's talk about education aspect of NEP...
I completed my MCE(SPM) in 1978 & HSC (STPM) in 1980 in Johor. Many of my Malay schoolmates in Lower Six did not complete the year.... they were sent oversea on scholarship. Since 1980, there were many non-Malay students who could not get into UM/USM (the two better U then) or could not get into the course of their choice were accepted by the 2 University in SGP. Both NUS and NTU are more recognised worldwide than UM. How could these students qualified for NUS/NTU but NOT qualified for UM?
'Race-based Affirmative Action on eduction' is bad enough. What is worst is a fixed quota of U places for the MalayBumi. Even worse is fixed quota for teachers/lecturers. If you are sick, would not you want to be treated by the best doctor u can afford regardless of his/her race & religion? (If a Jew doctor is the best in the world in heart by-pass, may be even TDM will see him). Similarly, wouldn't the Malay parents want their kids to be coached by the most qualified teachers/lecturers regardless of his/her race/religion. I can understand why the Malay leaders want to have more Malaybumi in U, but I can NOT understand why they do not want their children to be coached by the best teacher/lecturer. (could it be these policy makers sent their kids to U in US/Europe?)
Even if the nation is to implement race-based affirmation action on education, it should NOT be in the form of fixed quota (such as min 65% of U undergr*** must be MalayBumi). It can be in the form that all MalayBumi are given 'x' bonus points in STPM result and compare their results with ethnic Chinese/Indian.This is somewhat 'insulting' compare to a 'fixed quota' solution, but it would spur them to work hard to achieve better result.Unfortunately, the Umno Government chose the easy way out - Many Malay did not go thru the STPM route to local U..they went matriculation or the better ones were sent oversea after MCE/SPM. A fixed quota smells 'Ketuanan Malayu'... This is Tanah Melayu.. Melayu leader says 65% of U places must be MalayBumi or 7% discount on house purchase, it becomes the law. It is a sacred cow. To question it is to challenge the special right of Melayu. (visualise the Keris kissing scene).
But is this good the the Malaybumi in the long run??? I bet some Umno leaders recognise that such NEP implementation is not good for their children in the long run (just like spoiling your own kids), but they can not change the system it because it is already too entrenched.

Can Anwar/PKR change the system? I don't think so! There need to be at least a few good Malay leader who 'think' like RPK as well as the political clout of Anwar. Not easy to find such people. The consolation is "I am a born pessimist
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 25
...
written by Atheist, March 31, 2008 15:57:14
Gee ... RPK, if what you said about the bottle is true, then we have much in common. But in my case, I went one step futher. Since I was baby and confined to the playpen, I decided that I needed to keep my thrill of throwing things going on. So, I would shit in the playpen and wrap it with my napkins. I would then target practice any moving object in the range of my playpen. After a while there would be no moving objects or object ware would move very fast while ducking.

So I guess this is what UMNO also did and that is why they 'lost' the last elections. I guess people in glass houses should not throw constipated shit around. Then again, I think that the NEP is not as transparent as the glass house .... before the shit hit the fan. (pardon the pun) smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/cheesy.gif smilies/cheesy.gif smilies/wink.gif smilies/wink.gif
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 7
...
written by yeechut, March 31, 2008 16:02:35
Much more sinister than the racial divide is the division between the have and the have not, the ruler and the ruled. The ruler – those who have, those who are in power, are intend to keep the population fragmented, as that is the premise of power mongering, subjugations and manipulations. The power mongers are absolutely not willing to share in anyway whatsoever. They want to keep the subjects fragmented, poor, helpless and ignorant, otherwise there is no way for them to maintain in power. It is all about money and power, and very little to do with race.

Any power that the warlords wield is but an illusion. They remain in power only to the degree the masses allow them to be. As can be seen in GE 12, the rakyat simply gave them a slight blow, and the whole power structure is already in self-destruct mode crumpling from within like a deck of cards. How disgusting, how pathetic.

I am all in favor of racial unity and equal participation of life opportunities. But NEP simply has to go. It has been used as a tool of power mongering and exploitations for too long.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 9
...
written by oct, March 31, 2008 16:10:06
My suggestion is that all the Malays should read the simple book called 'Who moved the cheese?'. When the cheese is no more there, either you die sitting and waiting for something that will not happen again or you will venture out to find where the new cheese will be. When you are complacent, you don't want to do anything but to remain static and bored. This is not what life is about out there. Out there, you have to compete. The more you compete, the more your skill will be sharpen to face any eventuality.

Let's wait and see when the cheese end and watch the interesting result.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 15
...
written by teo siew chin, March 31, 2008 16:10:11
"The rich took the milk bottle and the poor take the crumbs.."
------------------------------------------

nah. methinks the rich took the milk and all the time the poor is sucking at an empty bottle.

Dear Yang Mulia Raja Petra - may I ask what milk formula you were on cos you must have been fed good to grow up big strong and friendly ! smilies/grin.gif

As for universities, no point having 1000 grade-B ones.
Instead, money should be spent on improving education across the board.
Wouldn't be surprised if many local gr*** may not be smarter than a 5th-grader. smilies/wink.gif

can't fault them tho, it's the system that sucks.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 18
...
written by taufan, March 31, 2008 16:13:14
Spend the money prudently and wisely, that's what I would say.

They build Universities (take Petronas University in Perak) to look like one of the 'Wonders of the World'. The end result, graduates end up jobless.

We need quality and not quantity. The MMU (Multi-Media University) take students from all over the world. I knew of a number of Iranian students, and their proficiency in English, was most atrocious. Yet they graduated. I question the quality here!

Where are the think-tankers? What are those guys in EPU doing? Twiddling their *^#%@ !!!

Hoi wake up and stop emulating your great (small letters) leader!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by mgeo, March 31, 2008 16:13:15
While the plunder, waste and iniquity in allocation of university seats and scholarships is undeniable, is higher education not a privilege for the academically inclined based on merit? We already have an education industry gone mad, spewing out something like 100,000 functionally illiterate graduates.

We should be setting up more vocational schools. The higher expectations of these pseudo-graduates is contibuting to the influx of foreign workers.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by tcng, March 31, 2008 16:19:05

There need to be at least a few good Malay leader who 'think' like RPK as well as possess the political clout equivalent to Anwar's.
I do not know for sure what is Anwar thinking in his head.. He does have an axe to grind.. Is he sincerely want to correct the wrongs in Msia or is he just want to become the PM, one way or another? In addition, Besides Anwar, who are other prominent Malay leaders in PKR? Syed Husin?Khalid Ibrahim? I don't see people like Malik Imtiaz Haris Ibrahim in PKR org chart.....
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 8
...
written by andywongkch, March 31, 2008 16:20:58
Hi RRK, Greetings!

Always enjoy your writing as usual. There is another dimension to the malay dilema. Most of the civil servants are being HOOKED to the government loan schemes (eg in Sarawak, Petronesa) and the government is very well aware of it that the scheme is illegal.

In a nutshell, a koperasi would hire indepedent agents to go out and solicite business based on the purchase of electronic goods. But in actual facts, no goods transactions have even taken and the interests amount to astonomical perentage in which the borrowers need to take few years to pay principal back. I know for FACTS that these civil servants are desperate enough to borrow rom these koperasi and the governtment is not doing anything about it. The amounts are in multiple billions!

Think about it, how do u expect these malays (constitute large part of public workers) to survive?

It is about time for the government to crack down on these illegal activities.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by Kal El, March 31, 2008 16:21:16
And you guys insulted mahathir for his remark on 'The Malay Dilemma'.
What a joke!
give us a level playing game & we will put where our mouth is & make you guys eat every word that was said. smilies/shocked.gif
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 6
...
written by Gargamel, March 31, 2008 16:31:19
RPK, building more infrastructure (universities) is good, but what about the people to staff them? All the bright Malays, Chinese, Indians have gone overseas and few have come back. Who to teach in the uni, except people like that UUM vice-chancellor? 3rd class students become 3rd class teachers, who produce 3rd class students. Even if you offered to pay bucketlo*** of money, I doubt the smart Malaysians abroad would want to come back and work with these gundus.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 9
...
written by teo siew chin, March 31, 2008 16:32:02
"..faces of certain Menteri Besar are made from plastic..."
------------------

hahahahaha classic man!!!!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 7
...
written by sampalee, March 31, 2008 16:35:12
Malay have the material to be as good as the best in the world,if nurture align with nature.Just look at RPK,a MALAY ushered into the world weaned from bottle feeding by his wise mother and need we say more.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by RitchieLow, March 31, 2008 16:37:16
"Daim Zainuddin has transferred RM42 billion of our taxpayers’ money out of the country and has sunk this colossal amount into about ten banks that he owns in Africa and Eastern Europe." -- this is serious, there ought to be a "60-minute" program on this. Make a web-version of this Daimgate

Increased number of Us is the 1st step. Quality staffing is the next.

"And because of that we still need the NEP because, without the NEP, Malays would not have places in local universities" -- You talked as if this is a genetic trait! Don't tell me people still subscribe to what TDM says in his stupid Dilemma book.

report abuse
disagree 3
agree 5
...
written by jshewsbury, March 31, 2008 16:40:37
I am a bumiputra, but other than being able to invest in that Amanah Saham Bumiputera (ASB) which I only have maybe less than a hundred now smilies/cheesy.gif (I'm broke but happy that I have enough for myself) I don't think I receive anything extra from this NEP (DEB), my SPM results is just average pass (Grade 3) so I didnt get the chance to go to any of the university, can't afford to go to private college, but over the years since leaving school, I work hard and find my way thru and now working in the banking sector just as a clerk... I wonder, what NEP (DEB) have done to me ? Nothing... so it means nothing for me... I never complained if other people (non Bumiputra or whatever) get better job or better pay than me as they work hard and they never get anything from NEP either, but I'm jealous that those Umnoputras can get rich thru this NEP and just because I'm not UMNO, I get nothing... Is this fair? How many real poor malay/bumiputra out there have taste this NEP really? Is this NEP manage to change their life?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 73
...
written by teo siew chin, March 31, 2008 16:48:06
Dear Jshewsbury

Get hold of all your frens who are in the same position as you and voice out! You cannot and must not keep quiet.
Your future is at stake and you now have a platform and means to MAKE THAT CHANGE!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 16
...
written by grant, March 31, 2008 16:56:58
Hi Chin,
Allow me to elaborate..

In my class back then, there was this smart mixed Malay guy and ironically his name was Khairy. I would say he fell in the category of Smart and Hardworking (maybe earlier I was putting them down too much). His father was a Datuk, a rich one; and had ties with UMNO. He didnt pursue his studies overseas but had chosen this path that we took many years back.

Let me say this. Back then, I joined the first full time out campus UTM degree programme. It was only 2 years. Super fast I would say in getting ur degree as opposed to a 4-year degree then. It was a private mgmt only thing the lecturers were from UTM, courses and syllabus all were UTM standards. Having said so, that the mgmt was a private one, we paid thru our arses. 1 semester was like RM15-18k. And we didnt get any fed govt scholarship likewise those under PTPTN or wat not.

When he graduated, he was one of the few among us all who graduated with a 2nd Class Upper, even beat a few average Chinese students. My point, not all rich people whether they are Malays or Chinese will choose to pursue their tertiary in overseas. If u had a choice to pursue ur tertiary in a local Uni, why not? Why wanna spend the additional expenses when u can save more locally and yet get an equivalent standard of degree?

Not all US or UK students who come back to Malaysia with their degrees are smart. Some come back even with a 3rd class degree having spent hundreds of thousands of our taxpayers money there thru a Fed Govt loan like PTPTN.

Tell me something. What is the percentage of Bumi students who get Fed Govt loan like PTPTN are based overseas? And how many come back with at least a 2nd Upper? And out of these percentages, how many has defaulted their loans?

To which to answer ur question. Only the elite who painstakingly know wat hardship is all about will truly make use of any scholarship they get and try their very best to get the best result possible in their respective Uni. Who is the elite today? Do u see any non Bumi in the elite? No doubt back then ur time, u had a bunch of elites but today??

It is not my experience in my Uni that has made me come with a conclusion like this. As I mentioned it is a fact that education in Msia is such. Why dont u get ur kid enrolled (if he or she is lucky) in a local U and ask him or her wat it feels like. Then u will understand what I am talking about.

Let me share with u another experience. My Chinese friend graduated from UM, supposedly the best Uni in Msia. He graduated with a 1st Class in Mech Eng (the toughest u can ever find in UM) and was shortlisted for the Dean's list. Before he could graduate, BAT (British American Tobacco) offered him a job. The rest was history.. My point here again. Even in UM, none of the Bumis made it into the Dean's list during his year. And only a handful graduated from his batch with 1st class. And that handful of people, none were Bumis... (which u will say "see my point was the smart ones will leave for overseas". So are u telling me that UM does not have smart Bumi students? obviously there are.. i dont deny that fact. but u hv to look at the bigger picture.. why smart Bumi students ur time can compete with anyone in this world but not now?)

So u gonna tell me that it is also his experience in local Uni that warrants for what I am saying now?
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 15
...
written by doggieread, March 31, 2008 17:02:48
I agree that quality not quantity that count, irrespective of graduates or businessmen. 
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by darienong, March 31, 2008 17:03:54
If the government could make good use of our black gold monies and build more universities as suggested, by this time Malaysia should have been produces countless numbers of bumiputra who can compete fairly without help by "mummy"!!

Competitive will make peoples stronger!! If bumiputra are become stronger in term of academic, do you think they are any less if compare to other non-bumi in business world?

Pak Lah.. pls allowed the change.. for good of all Malaysian, whether Malays, Chinese or Indian..
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Everbright, March 31, 2008 17:08:39
RPK, as usual you have a knack of putting across some excellent ideas. Reading through the many responses from your readers, I must say the solution is always found somewhere in between. I agree with grant, teohsiewchin, taufan and others. The motto is Quality not Quantity. Strike a balance. We need to introduce back meritocracy into our educational institutions. I agree with you - divert our Nations resources to upgrade our Universities, not just hardware but the software too. The change must come at the Top. If the right leadership is not at our Universities, I doubt meaningful changes can be enacted. Enjoy all your articles, keep it up! You are definitely an Agent of Change!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by grant, March 31, 2008 17:14:23
Let's just take English as an example... Elites ur time (40 yrs ago) like RPK, Elyas Omar and whoever else that I hv forgotten. English has got nothing to do with Universities but rather has everything to do with the education fundamentals and system...

Bumis back then like RPK, Elyas Omar and whoever else that I hv forgotten can speak THE QUEEN'S ENGLISH PERFECTLY WELL. Ok here I am gonna whack the Chinese as well... Why cant today's Bumi educated in the heart of Msia speak the Queen's English that well anymore? Let's not talk about perfection.. Let's just talk abt basic command of English. Even the Chinese Educated ones cant speak proper English... WTF??

R becomes L, Z becomes J.. I am not joking.. Chinese educated folks will say FERRY OR LORRY as FELI and LOLI.. U might laugh but that is a fact... And pronounce Zorro as Jollo! U can laugh all u want.. (in fact I am smirking.. haha!)

Bumi's today speak English as if English was a Malay Language. Again WTF?

Do u see where the problem is now? Do u know the root cause of all this disease? It is because our education system is failing... and with NEP, it is making it even worse...
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 11
...
written by Tornado, March 31, 2008 17:22:48
Last year, our MINDEF spend RM500 mil for "duit kopi' in deal buying 2 french built submarines, RM50 mil for sending tourist to ISS, RM9 mil for Parlimen Building etc.

With a lot of money, we can built a lot of houses for the poor, free uniform for our school children, rural water & electric supply & reduce university fees.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 9
...
written by sathia, March 31, 2008 17:37:20
Whoa! So much anger, so much hate! take a chill pill :-)

The comparison with beijing is not such a good one. yes, anyone can go to uni but it's mostly the young. agreed? whats the % of youth among china's 1.4 billion? most prefer to go to BJ or SH. Shenzhen has abt 10 million ppl. how many unis are there in SZ? or wuhan? So, for Malaysia, we need to adjust accordingly. We definitely need more unis, but need a bit of thought here.

It's about quality. many ppl commented on this. Unis r not just abt buildings. there r a lot of unemployed gr*** out there. why?

Someone said:
"Seriously, for one to be successful in business one has to be good at networking, which is what Chinese are good at."

I know I will 'kena kutuk' here, but there is some truth in that the chinese primarily network among themselves. why?

See the first comment. why capitalise the word "MALAYS" so negatively? there's no need to stress this. this is the other problem. Even if a malay does well on merit, the chinese and indians will look down.

It's like a vicious cycle lah!
report abuse
disagree 14
agree 10
...
written by tmf, March 31, 2008 17:39:15
NEP as practiced till now certainly destroys many of my Malay brothers and sisters.

Though not from wealthy family, when I was in UM many years ago, I did not apply for scholarship for fear that someone who needed it more would not get it. I earned my degree without scholarship. During the four years in varsity when I did not have enough, I survived by even rationing my food intake while many multi-scholarship holders spent their money on cigaretes and other forms of entertainments, many of them failed badly.

When I started my business, I did not go hunting for any special loan scheme as I believe that there are more needy people out there. Thank God, my business survives but I do know many of my Malays friends who received various easy business loans did not make it as they simply do not have any sense of ownership, it was simply OPM, aka other peoples' money that they were fooling about.

I am no longer young now, and I am very tired addressing a clearly failed policy with grand name and noble objectives, however, for those young dynamic malays out there, I urge you to value your own worth and make your life great by taking ownersip of your destiny by working hard instead of relying on support under NEP, whatever its new name is, be assured that your non-malay brothers and sisters will be extremely happy and proud of you, when you make it on your own.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 39
...
written by michael, March 31, 2008 17:42:18
Yes, the smart Malays are hidden overseas. I was a student in a Sydney High School 30 years ago and I have a Malay classmate, Fadzil who was there on a Malaysian government scholarship. He was a very bright, hardworking and humble young 18 years old Malay student, whose parents were poor padi farmers in Kedah.

It was then that I realized the importance of the NEP to help poor malays get a head start in life. It would have been such a waste for a bright young man to miss on an opportunity to excel in life just because he was poor as it would be much too tough for a simple malay padi farmer to support a kid in Australia. As a result I often spoke out in support of the NEP for many years, despite being discriminated against being a Chinese.

Mind you I don’t belong to the rich class. I was there initially on my elder Sister blood and sweat, and subsequently had to find work to earn myself through University, although this wasn’t allowed or encouraged by the Australian Government at the time.

There was also another Malay student in a top Sydney High School who was truly very intelligent and rich too, belonging to an aristocrat family. He sure didn’t need any Government Scholarship for financial reasons but was on one. He didn’t have to work or study at all, but he aced in all his subjects. I think he ended up doing well enough to do Medicine, despite the Australian quota system. Actually, I recalled he spent more time chasing skirts than anything else.

In Singapore PSLE results this year, the student that top their primary 6 exams was a Malay girl. Her scores was the highest ever in I think in 12 years! That’s an outstanding achievement considering that in Singapore the population is largely Chinese whose parents goes through extreme lengths to ensure their kids get the best education in the best schools to get the best grades.

I mean look here in MT itself. Can’t you tell that there are so many Malay contributors who are brilliant! So lets keep out our social prejudices about Malays being generally not smart enough etc out of our narrow minds.

In short, we ought to modify the NEP and it should only for the marginalized, disadvantaged and for the exceptionally brilliant citizens who we want to nurture, regardless of race, creed or religion.

And Yes, the 38 years old milk bottle with life-time milk supply dished out for UMNOputras Must Go! The Malays must be sick of drinking milk all their life, and it has sadly stunted their growth for much too long.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 49
...
written by yellowwoman, March 31, 2008 18:04:02
I would equate Malays with NEP privilege to rich men's children born with a silver (and diamond-studded) poon. I am sure most, if not all of you have a friend or two who are rich and because of his father's wealth, can't do much for himself. Why, he doesn't have to.

When you don't have to strive to get a place in university (unlike poor people like me - it was either I get into local uni or start working), you don't strive. Period. When you don't have to study to pass exams because grades are doctored to allow more to pass, you don't study. Period. When you don't have to work hard because the government will take care of your children's education, you don't work hard. Period.

If I were a Malay, just like if I were a rich man's child, I will not study. I will not work hard. Whatever for? Stupid meh?

Likewise, if the Malays really want to rise and feel good for what they can and are capable of, they would choose to play in a level playing field. They would study, work and live like the rest of us. Success that comes from your own blood, sweat and tears is sweet indeed. By now, all of us would know that Respect can only be earned, not inherited from your rich father, and certainly does not come "attached" to a certain skin colour.

Respect is sweet indeed. Success that is suspect is not. Living a life in which the rest of the world look at your success with suspect must be sad indeed.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by Barking out loud, March 31, 2008 18:04:32
I think that the NEP has not only created a dependence of the Malay's to this unfair advantage but it has also created a comfort zone for the non-Malay's thus making us less competitive as compared to our neighbours like Singapore, Thailand and Indonesia.

This I believe is also a very big contributor to the slower progress in Malaysia as compared to our neighbours. I believe that this is also another reason why major multinational companies would also rather invest in our neighbours as compared to us.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 6
...
written by grant, March 31, 2008 18:05:29
Dear Michael,
U are very wrong...

1. SG does not hv NEP. They have fair competition and yet this SG Malay girl can top her class with flying colors, what makes u think Msian Malays cannot do the same? The answer is they can just like the guy u mentioned - Fadzil.

2. If Fadzil is a smart and hardworking guy as u claimed, then why didnt he garner entry to a local Uni? Is it because he was too smart for a local U or was it because the govt wanted to develop him into a rocket scientist? What does he do now? Or did he come back to serve the country called Malaysia?

3. Fadzil could have garnered an entry to a local Uni and yet getting full scholarship under the fed govt. With his results, he could even get a state scholarship as well.. And let me tell u this - maybe u might or might not know. Local university fee is less than RM2k a semester (maybe even lower. used to be 800 only). And how much does PTPTN give out in scholarship or loan per sem? RM8k per semester! RM8k minus the fees of 2k gives u a balance of 6k for u to live like a king for the next 5 mths. If u tell me that a student at the age of 19 needs more than 1.2k a mth, then u are definitely a goner!

I dont see the logic of NEP at all. U think only Malays are poor? WTF? Have u seen Indians poorer than poor? Have u seen Chinese so poor that they live on 3 slices of bread a day, strive to get good results in a local Uni, single parent working 3 jobs a day just to feed her son and when the son graduates and works in an International firm like Intel only to be diagnosed with liver failure? That is not poor then u better tell me wat it is!

Screw u!
report abuse
disagree 20
agree 9
...
written by grant, March 31, 2008 18:09:07
Let me tell u 1 more thing Michael... Dont be too stupid and naive... If u can get free milk, who the fark wants to buy a cow?

report abuse
disagree 12
agree 5
...
written by JustinCH, March 31, 2008 18:10:32
It's a sad day indeed when one people, regardless of their origin, are spoon-fed until they cannot look after themselves. It won't be very long until the so-called mother dies, because the milk (black gold) runs out. And when it does, all the babies that have always sucked from the bottle and don't know how to feed themselves will die together with it.

Is that a future you want for your children? Better yet, don't you yourself want to grow up? To make something of yourself? Instead of depending on your mother to clothe and feed you to your grave.

Let this be a message to all who have grown up to coax the babies to do likewise. If we let the NEP continue as it is, Malaysia will end up as a country full of crying babies.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by megahyper, March 31, 2008 18:16:49
RPK, another masterpiece again!

Yeah it's basically sum down into: 1) Quota for Education 2) Quota for business.

Who's the main culprit that makes the Malay "ketagihan" for those? Yeah, I know, he's still not satisfied.

It's part of the plan to remain at the apex of power. It's not unlike, drug addicts. threaten their drug supplies, they would do whatever you want.

Worst is, NEP distort the rules of engagement. and its driving the "baby" further and further away from real world of business.

If the "know who" get you business and "Datukship", nobody would learn or care about the "know-how". And when they only specialise in the "know-who", of cos nothing can take "NEP" away from them.

And who is this master schemer? The one that we can't live without for 2 decade? The one that mass-produce "AP king", "toll concessionaires Kingpins" and all sort of maha....rajas to rules our sorry malaysian ass for eternity and beyond?

He who bend "NEP" to suit his purpose.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Chuang Tze, March 31, 2008 18:22:03

The real objective of the NEP from the start was to garner Malay support so that the BN Govt. can be in power ... forever ... by using the NEP issue to guarantee delivery of the Malay votes which would be enough to keep these Umnoputras in power.

This having been done, the cronies started minting their money !! Daim and his banks, Anandan and his satelite, Vincent and his licenses, etc.

You know what ?? The best incident of shattering the milk bottle into a million pieces was the March 8th elections ! Many Malays were weaned from the bottle that day, and the BNputras started getting jittery about minting their money. Now, the BN is in full flight and we look forward to new solid nutritious food to be introduced by our new nursemaid, BR !!

report abuse
disagree 1
agree 4
...
written by DontPlayGod, March 31, 2008 18:35:39
But UMNO wants the Malays to be always babies, and Najib has said that the NEP will be extended forever. Without the NEP, according to Najib and UMNO, the Malays will be lost. Without the crutch, they will not be able to walk. UMNO wants the Malays to be aware of that. And only UMNO can give them the crutch and the milk bottle.

But, the Malays(some) are beginning to wake up from UMNO's dreamland. They have now woken up to the UMNOputras lies and deceit. Imagine, billions of ringgit, probably hundreds of billions over the past 30 years have gone into the pockets of UMNOputeras. And these are only a few of them. Imagine, Daim can lay his hands of 42 billion ringgit, and being the cunning guy he is, all that money is invested overseas. And it happened right under the nose of the Tun.

We are still waiting for money politics of AAB who bought over the division chiefs with 3 million ringgit each. But more of that will come in the coming months. Just wait and see. Just before the nomination day for the UMNO elections, maybe AAB will do another Santa Claus act, dishing out 5 million to each division chief, in the name of development and maintenance. And the division chiefs will dutifully nominate AAB for the top post again.

When will the UMNO Malays wake up to all this scam and great swindle? When will the Malays hold their he*** high and take their place in this world as equals?

After more than 38 years, or 50 years after independence, the Malays still treat the NEP as a sensitive issue. Gosh!!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 9
...
written by Kedahan, March 31, 2008 18:53:37
spending money to send local students overseas is a good thing provided there is clear objectives in doing so. once these objectives should be a progressive one.

for starters the objective should be to have the BRAINS to satisfy the need of local business/industry and education system.

with the seed of top brains, the education system should be moulded so that we no longer need to send students overseas in many basic areas of studies. the researches from our universities should aid business/industry and government in decision making.

over the years, many student, good or mediocre, have been sent overseas. how well has the objective been met. or are there any objectives at all? it is nice to see individual cases of success, but we have to look at the big picture.

finally, local education system has to be solid in churning out good graduates. this would need the help of people that has been sent overseas to study using the people's money!

I paid for my higher education from my own pocket.. yups, worked my ass off and took bank loans to study in Singapore. and I'm glad I did so because of the quality of education there. it struct me that I'm not going to study in uni in Malaysia when I see top brains are still being sent overseas, meaning local universities are not good enough for them.

I hope the new government would set out a plan now. make sure schools are providing quality education. local universities can improve in the next 5 years. maybe not considerably, but at least improve! tell us how, and lets see work being done. if students needs an extra year of 2 in school, let it be.. push them hard, lets see quality students come out of every single school!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by Democrats, March 31, 2008 20:01:21
RPK....

Agree with you on the NEP part wholeheartedly, but I can't agree with more universities at this stage. The education system is so screwed up, they'll be more and more useless graduates in the market. For one, the entry level is bias with racial discrimination, so you don't have to know your stuff to get in.

Have you seen some of the graduates today? I 'm sorry to generalize but most of them from UiTM, UKM, UUM, UIAM, USM, UTAR, etc (apoligies to the brilliant minority from these universities... can't present themselve in any job interview, can't understand the questions, and can't even convince people why we should hire them. We need more quality, not quantity.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by freespeecher, March 31, 2008 20:37:26
Bravo! Bravo!Definitely one of RPK masterpiece!
God has given mankind freedom while DUMNNO has deprived many of those freedom starting with education.
Do you all think all non-malay are rich enough to go overseas for education ? Too many good students that were deprived of local uni were forced early into the workforce with just secondary school qualification...suffering along the way with meager wages and still trying to save enough for further education on their own.God/Allah/Higher Power or whatever He is called has given the country too many good human resources but was trashed away like dirt by Dumno. No wonder a lot says the downfall of dumno in GE2008 is a will of God. Beware! Somebody up there is watching. Singapore while without natural resources but they sure know how to maximize on their human resources that made them today what they are.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Navigator, March 31, 2008 20:57:28
RPK, This must be your masterpiece. Great thinking. Everyword is true. The baby bottle analogy is great. Can someone do a photo with Badawi, Mahathir and Najib each sucking a pacificier? We will post it all over the country.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 5
...
written by Thinker, March 31, 2008 21:15:34
Interesting write up. I'd like to know how many Malaysian undergraduates are sent abroad every year. I think sending a student to the US would easily cost the government up to 100,000 RM a year. Sending 1000 students would cost us 100,000,000 RM a year. That's an astronomical amount.

A much better way to spend the money would be to hire good lecturers for Malaysian universities. Make all undergraduates study locally and only offer scholarships for the best of the best to proceed for the PhD overseas with the condition that they return to teach once they finish. Then we could slowly wean ourselves on the reliance of foreign lecturers and as the quality of lecturers and the universities improve, we could build a large core of local researchers. Singapore tried to do the same and managed to build up the reputation of the universities but are unable to get a large enough population of local researchers because of their small population. We, however, do not have the same population problem.

Unfortunately, the government always wants to take politically expedient measures, and they do so by sending many students abroad, many to mediocre universities, rather than improving the quality of our local universities. It's a shame really, considering how many mediocre foreign universities are benefiting from our government's selfish motives and how many deserving students are deprived of an opportunity to further their studies.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by AlanCK, March 31, 2008 21:26:36
Ok, built more universities, get good lecturers and all those stuffs for a better Malaysia. People education with knowledge and moral values is the best asset a nation can ever have.

So please stop all this politics on NEP, racial or religions issues.

Malaysia, you need to wake up and grow up now. The whole world is not gonna to wait for you to "wake up and grow up". It is that simple ok!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by jokerman, March 31, 2008 21:29:08
Typical responses from people for a non Malay university graduate back in the 1990s:

1. If you graduated from local university:

- Wah you must be very lucky indeed to get into local university as it is quite difficult to get in even with good results unless you are Malay!

2. If you graduate from overseas university:

- Wah you must be very lucky indeed to have a rich father to support you to go to overseas as the local universities are all pro-Malay!

Well I personally got the 2nd response from most people I met (coz I went overseas) and some of my friends (who studied locally) got the 1st response from most people they met. This is what the dumbass Ministry of Education had instilled in the people's mind over the years! All of my non Malay friends who managed to get into UTM obtained flying colour results for their SPMs, however non of them were granted their first choice of selected courses. All of them had to either take it or leave it.

I remember one of my non Malay friend who obtained excellent results in her SPM were offered a course which according to her, was her least preferred and last choice of courses applied! She was very disappointed with the outcome because she told me that she had never studied this HARD for SPM to end up being offered this course by UPU. On the other hand she did applied for the course she wanted through a private college but had to think twice due to financial reasons. In the end, she had no choice but to opt for the least preferred choice in UTM and swallow it.

As for my case, I studied hard for my SPM and managed to obtain good results (7As) and were within the top 5 in my school that year! I applied for an Engineering course from UTM. I was quite confident with my application as my thinking back then was that as long as you have good results in your BM, Maths and Science subjects, your chances will be high.

Duhh...in a slap to my own face was I ever so wrong! Maybe I had forgotten that Im a non Bumi...how naive I was back then...My application was rejected without any reason given by UPU. So in the end, its either Form 6 for me or private colleges! Feeling disgusted and utterly disappointed with UPU, screw the Ministry of Education and STPM.

In the end, my family end up spending more than RM200k for my degree! At times I asked myself, why need to study so hard in the first place? Its not like the government is going to appreciate and acknowledge your efforts? Maybe the government will pay more attention if you are a Malay or an UMNOputera! I should have thought of that back then...hai...how silly and naive of me...
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 10
...
written by freespeecher, March 31, 2008 21:43:04
Whatever goes around comes around! Dumno deprived many from their basic rights now they all come back with a vengeance ! Law of Karma I guess !
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by cancan, March 31, 2008 21:58:05
The Power Of Marketing

Link: http://www.kingsmary.blogspot.com/
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 0
...
written by neos, March 31, 2008 22:28:27
Quality of education from primary, secondary, form 6 up to university in Malaysia have been deteriorating begin from early 80's and worst from mid 90's! Now we are not even in Top 100 in the world. All comes back to the rot created by that 4th PM of Malaysia! You definately have to pay for that !
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by miwaki, March 31, 2008 22:33:58
You are right RPK,competent government will never need quota for her citizens to enter colleges or business.Mahathir was incompetent but because he is the smartest among the UMNO's leaders,people follow what he did.Nobody ever thought of building more universities so that quota for entry could be scrapped.Maybe to build a university cost a lot of money so people did not press for it.

Now we know Malaysia can build at least one university every year until the government has to provide incentives to students who enroll at local universities.BN has cheated us for so many years,I will not vote BN for the next 50 years.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Hades, March 31, 2008 22:38:39
The quota system in Malaysia education should go away, period. A country can only be successful when all of it's people are given good education with any sort of discrimination.

The system that is currently in place is only doing the opposite, instead of making the Malays successful, it is making them lazy, because they are pretty confident that they will be given a seat in universities based on their race rather than their results. Make Malay's successful, but surely this is not the way.

It is about time, we Malaysians especially the Malays, to realize the harm this system is doing to us. Let's drop this system for a better Malaysia.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by malgal, March 31, 2008 22:38:55
they who got the milk bottles for so long shouldnt need more than diapers, rattles and baby tees. Is that why they are just goo goo ga ga ? If they refuse to grow up, they should be penned in the nursery.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by joeawk, March 31, 2008 23:06:06
Quality, quality, quality. Work hard and smart and if still lose, get back to work harder and smarter and come back to fight another day. There is no other way to improve. Improve, improve, improve.

Malaysia offers much hope. There is plenty in Malaysia still even though much have been squandered. Ask the immigrant workers.

Stop all the mega projects. They are at best only for show. They did nothing to the people in general.

Scrap the Penang bridge and extend the monorail. Downsize all the many corridors. Look at PutraJaya and CyberJaya, what the hack is it? What a waste of those big acres?

Grow from the centre and not from outside.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by Loh, March 31, 2008 23:09:43
NEP was initiated to justify May 13. The Malays then did not require any special assistance after having been treated well under article 153. NEP allowed the people in power to make Malays rich, and they were free to choose the beneficiaries. But to show the ordinary Malays that they were receiving preferential treatment under NEP, non-Malays had to be made to suffer. Education involves every family, and the UMNO government believes that when there are more complaints from the non-Malays against UMNO's racist policies, the Malays would feel obliged to keep them in power. The strategy worked for past elections, with some leakage in the recently concluded one.

Over the past fifty years UMNO have made Malays believe that they were the chosen people born with special entitlements. When natural resources dry up, Barisan Rakyat may be given the chance to pick up the pieces.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by mrgoh, March 31, 2008 23:12:59
RPK,

I must say that I totally agree with you. The NEP is only the milk bottle to only one baby: The Malays the other babies like the Chinese and the Indians had to make a living without a milk bottle at all.

This may sound racist but this has made the Chinese and Indian more resilient in the long run than the Malays (or Umnoputras or what have you) have.

I want to share my childhood story as well. At 6-7 years old I almost became asmatic and I was coughing for months - my lungs was not as strong as it should have been so my parents decide that I should take a sport where your lungs are going to be strecthed to its limits! SWIMMING! I was afraid to death of the water and when I was cast into the hands of a swim coach who I was convince is the Devil Reincarnated himself, all the sinues in my soul and body just crumbled. My parents just left me in the pool with nothing but my humble shorts! I had to take swimming seriously after that.

At 20years old, I trained to be a certified lifeguard. And I dare say this my lungs are different now. FYI, one of the test to to be a lifeguard is that I have to swim 25meters which is half the length of a full olympic swimming pool with one breath. At my peak, I can do almost do the entire length of the olympic size pool short of 5 meters - that is 45meters with one breath. Plus, I am confident I can squeeze another 10-20meters if I put my back into it right now.

It is quite a feat that I am proud of - thanks for leaving in the Devil's hands mom n dad!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 4
...
written by sharkpitt, March 31, 2008 23:22:29
I too share the same sentiment on NEP.it is so hard to convice my fellow mates that NEP enriches the UMNO goons!susah...dahla ignorant pasal politics....pagi susah.its high time the malays should just concentrate on working hard and istiqamah(work and never give up!)and bertawakkal after working hard.there is no short cut too success...this over dependency is like what RPK said and it is draining the economy......aduhai
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by KC Chew, March 31, 2008 23:42:36
As it is now, dear RPK, we are having sufficient academic staff of good standing filling our mere 20-25 uni (incl that guy who sued you). How could we, proportionally, match those in Beijing, which means we need around 270 uni in Malaysia tapi tak ada olang can ajar. Are we going end up giving 'special tuition class to special group' just before semester exam, just to justify the existence of these institutions?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by Victory or Death, March 31, 2008 23:48:43
Not only NEP sucks!

Practically the whole system sucks!

From education right down to every government institution, ministry and department!

How can we ever hope to correct it except with back to the drawing board wholesale plans.


Before NEP can go, BN must go.

Only with a new federal government can we go back to the drawing board!

Otherwise it’s all talk and dream only.


GO BN GO! Go away and don’t come back.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by cody8177, March 31, 2008 23:59:28
True to the bone, RPK. Sad but true. But what can they (the Malays) do about it ? When the milk is offered, tell me, which baby would be able to resist ? I bet even the Chinese or Indians if given this 'milk' will find the temptation extremely hard to resist as well, let alone the Malays. Whoa ! 38 years ! My God ! It's like being drugged in a fantasy world for too long. The senses are numb, the muscles aching, the mind rusty and you sort of becomes crippled (even though you're not).

Sadly, not many of the Malays realized this fact. The fact that they already grown up and that they need solid food now.

The Milk is UMNO's greatest strength, all its powers come from this milk they are feeding to the babies. But, as you point out, the milk will eventually run dry one day
but surely the mother will find other ways to feed the
baby ? Surely this is a bad omen for the non-Malays ?

We can only survive, live and grow if we depend on each other. No one is superior than the other, not the Malays or the non-Malays. We cannot live without one another. The only way to do that now before we are out of milk is for the BR under DSAI to show it to the Malays that they need not compete against the non-Malays in Malaysia but that they hand in hand with the non-Malays can actually compete against the whole world.

NEP Milk makes you drowsy and wanna sleep all time. But MEA Tonic will refresh you and make you feel alive in front of the world.

Hidup Barisan Rakyat !




report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by cklife, April 01, 2008 00:05:00
A very well written article.
I totally feel you RPK. I know what you mean.

No Pain , No Gain.

That's the rule of the world.
If you're spoon-fed all the time... you'll never learn to be stronger.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by michael, April 01, 2008 00:45:02
Dear Grant,

Thank you for your response. Somehow you seem “angry” and as a result appear to be reading my comments with “colored” filters, but I hear you and understand where you are coming from.

1. I did not imply that Malaysian Malays cannot be as smart as Singapore Malays. My point was that there are poor and smart Malays that needed help to excel, that’s all. (This does not suggest that there are no Chinese or Indians Malaysians who equally deserves help.

2.Fadzil as I recall, got into the engineering faculty and sadly we lost contact. I don’t know what has become of him since then. But he does appear to be one who would serve out his bond, if any.

3.I am not familiar with the scholarship funding details am I am sure it is generous enough to ensure that the students don’t have to live frugally and work to keep them in University, like I had to. The purpose was to help them focus on their studies and excel in their grades. Fadzil was living far more comfortably than me in a well equipped hostel, but that’s OK.

Yes there are also many poor Chinese and Indians as there are many poor Malays. In short, there are many poor Malaysians. The Umno government had adulterated the NEP overtime. There are many sad stories and as Malaysians we need to look forward and move on. Let the past go so that we can build a better todayThe NEP has to go in its present form and should benefit all races, especially the poor, like I said.

Yes people will generally not buy a cow when they have free milk. And the NEP has hurt the Malays more overtime. Like I said it has stunted their growth. Do you really want free milk all your life, Grant? If so, where is the challenge then to be a creative and contributing human being?

Grant, we need to let go of the past. Let the past not filter our present with your prejudices and judgments. Malaysia has to look forward from now. There is a lot of forgiving to be done and by doing so we all feel better and progress can take its path.

I suggest you re-read my earlier article again when you are less “angry”.

Bless you, Grant. May you have Peace and Joy, ALWAYS!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 12
...
written by SotPlug, April 01, 2008 01:08:39
I for one do not think Malays are stupid (as some comments suggested) but are more of lazy. And it's got nothing to do with their genes. It's the NEP policies.

They really don't have to work too hard for survival. They know they'll not starve. They know their children will not starve. They don't need to save for their children's education. Hell even buying house also got discount.

('They' here does not mean all, but 'the portion'.)

Consider this, Malays in China is more hardworking than most Chinese in Malaysia. Why? For survival. Put a Malaysian Chinese into China and he/she might not even survive.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 4
...
written by spliff_roller, April 01, 2008 01:32:41
Actually my reasoning is, for BN it wouldn't be in their best intrests to have well educated Malaysians because this would spell the death of their ways. Yes Rpk is right, if all those monies that have been irresponsibly spent, and siphoned out of this country.. Even a small portion of it would solve the country's education woes at all levels.

Of course they dont give a damn about education.. look at who Badwi appointed as education minister again.. that is all.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by sathia, April 01, 2008 02:03:34
Quality of education from primary, secondary, form 6 up to university in Malaysia have been deteriorating begin from early 80's and worst from mid 90's! Now we are not even in Top 100 in the world. All comes back to the rot created by that 4th PM of Malaysia! You definately have to pay for that !


Hmmm... who was the Minister of Education then?


report abuse
disagree 2
agree 3
...
written by sathia, April 01, 2008 02:07:24
written by AlanCK, March 31, 2008 | 21:26:36

Ok, built more universities, get good lecturers and all those stuffs for a better Malaysia. People education with knowledge and moral values is the best asset a nation can ever have.

So please stop all this politics on NEP, racial or religions issues.

Malaysia, you need to wake up and grow up now. The whole world is not gonna to wait for you to "wake up and grow up". It is that simple ok!


How true! Looks like this site is full of whining and racist ppl of a particular race!
report abuse
disagree 7
agree 1
...
written by Lim Lim, April 01, 2008 02:20:59
like it or not,NEP is the material umno use to make malay as their tools;tools for what??simple..stay in power so that their umnoputras can continue robbing n ripping off the nation n rakyat till eternity..so that they can continue gang bang the entire country with this racial divide screen shot till as long as they like!!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by Anak Kampung, April 01, 2008 06:32:54
Raja Petra,

I agree with the general gist of this article (except that I think we still need affirmative action for the under-privileged, just not based on race) however, I'd like to say a few things about building unis.

You said: 'Why can’t we build more universities? We spent RM100 million to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of Merdeka last August. That is one university complete with equipment, fittings, libraries, and whatnot. We spend RM300 million a year on the Terengganu Monsoon Cup. That would be another three universities a year. We are spending more than RM3 billion on the second Penang bridge. That would be about 35 universities. With savings from this, that and the other, we could have 100 new universities built over 10 years.'

I agree that there are humongous amounts of money being misspent in this country; however, building universities is not the solution. Building the physical part of the university is easy. Runing it is exponentially more difficult. It is always easy to build buildings. (Their roofs may leak later, but that is a separate issue.) Building self-sustaining academic communities is another thing. Look what happened to MUST. We've already seen to a certain extent the proliferation of unis that you advocate --- there is now a UiTM in almost every state, there are new 'state' unis like UniSel and there are uncountable numbers of private unis. From what I have been told, almost all of them are facing staffing problems. They cannot find enough qualified lecturers to teach at the salaries they are offering. This correlates directly to the quality of education the students are receiving and their job prospects afterwards. (We already have a situation where many of our graduates are unemployed and yet major industries are facing a shortage of workers --- this means that we are producing unemployable people. Giving them more lecture halls is NOT and cannot be the answer.) There is also the question of facilities, which can be addressed only partially by money: one can always buy more journals, but one cannot buy qualified technical support if no qualified people exist in the country.

More important than salaries and facilities is the question of working conditions and academic freedom. As long as we have a UUCA, a ridiculously low retirement age of 56, an Akujanji and other such things, we will continue to have trouble recruiting talent. Any academic with the least amount of intellectual integrity and honesty will think twice before essentially agreeing to being confined to an academic prison. And so the academic prisons continue to attract with few exceptions people with the mentality of prisoners --- people who are not pursuing truth for its own sake and for the good of society but who pursuing politicians for the sake of moving up the ladder...

Conclusion: building is fine, but it's not where the money needs to go right now. And in fact it's not really a money question at all.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 3
...
written by Naha, April 01, 2008 07:44:06
As Anak Kampung wrote, it is exactly these academic prisons that put professionals off teaching. Twice I have turned down offers from my ex-professor to join the ranks of Universiti Malaya academia. Why? It is these very reasons you stated, Anak Kampung, and there is much worse: the departmental witch-hunts and bullying of members of staff seen to be 'anti-kerajaan'.

I admit that I have benefited from the NEP, but not as a gravy train beneficiary, not because my father is an UMNOputera, not because he is politically connected. My mother, denied of education, pushed her children to work hard in school, pestered my father to fork out money on encyclopaedias, reference books and all the classic English novels (although she could not read English) and did all sorts of small businesses to get money to buy us books and send us money when we were in boarding school. We worked hard in primary school, we competed with traditionally 'brainier' Chinese classmates, we filled in boarding school application forms and then got offers, went and studied some more despite the horrible treatment we got from ultra-racist and fundamentalist teachers, the worst of the worst to have been vomited out of UKM in the 1980s (which explains my issues with ABIM, DSAI, Biro Tata Negara and PAS).

I applied for a MARA study loan, which was approved, came to England to study, subsequently borrowed money to go further than a first bachelors degree, and am now in employment and slowly paying back what I owe my bank and what I owe MARA. I don't envy other Malays who fully enjoyed the NEP - who were given outright scholarships, some even enjoying freedom when their JPA service contracts were written off, while I have to pay it back. I don't have the right to claim unfair treatment under the NEP, for while it was not a gravy train ride, I am grateful to God that I was given a fair chance at educating myself, though I am not grateful to UMNO as UMNO is not god.

To me it never was about 'special' Malay genes, and what went so badly wrong under UMNO is utterly inexcusable, but in future, I would like to see many more JPA sponsored Malaysian Chinese, Indian and other minority faces, whom I occasionally meet. Their fathers and mothers work as hard, pay as much tax, so why are they not given the chance to benefit? However, I feel not a shred of guilt, as I know my father worked hard and paid his taxes. I just feel a lot of anger that non-Malay children are robbed of their parents' hard-earned tax ringgits, which end up lining the pockets of career-criminal politicians.

People like me who worked hard get a bad name, because we benefited from the NEP. So I guess my generation of graduates voted BN out to redress the injustice.

To me it was always about working hard to reach a target, and those who work hard should get a fair chance to further their education, regardless of ethnic background.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 19
...
written by BillyH, April 01, 2008 08:18:19
Sad but true, most companies in Malaysia( except GLCs and Government) will not even consider hiring a Malay unless forced to. Of course, don't even think of them working overseas as then they will have to compete based on intellect and hard work.

And yes its true, everytime we hear of a Malay who has an international degree its automatically " he was sponsored fully" , he probably failed all the way and the government paid for his degree to avoid embarrassment". Which is probably true

I really feel bad for them, how can we help these poor Malays?

report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 08:53:44
dear michael, if someone really can get free milk all their lives, u think they wont want it? u think they will give it up? we are human beings man, my friend.. humans live on desire, greed, lust, pride and everything.. if u had the choice to live on free expenses for the rest of ur life, u are telling me u wont want it? aint that a form of free milk too?

common la... let's face reality.. the only difference today between the Non Bumis and Bumis apart from NEP is the fact that we the Non Bumis know we have to be hardworking and strive for our livelihood, future and children. We know the hardship and difference. If NEP were to be applied for all Msians, Non Bumi's will be equally like Bumis today.. Sorry to say that.. But it is a fact man!

And finally, I was pissed rather angry because u as a Chinese favor the NEP! And if u favor the NEP why the hell u studied in New Sydney? Because ur dad was filthy rich? Or u didnt get good results to push u into a local U?
report abuse
disagree 5
agree 0
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 09:11:42
And Michael,

I know where u are coming from. NEP has to be refined, retuned for the betterment of the Bumis.. I understand ur argument. But my argument is, NEP shud be abolished.. There are many Malays unfortunately who would go to the extent to kill anyone with that thought of abolishing NEP. So before we start abolishing NEP, we need to chg the mindset of the Malays that, "hey u hv to be like Singaporean Malays.. u hv to fend for urself.. u have to fight for ur own livelihood.. we aint giving u nep no more"... that is 1 hell of a mountain to climb... not impossible but hell of an effort..

Secondly, since u are not well aware of the fed govt scholarships and loans, then let me shed some light here..
1. Every year, the govt gives out millions of ringgit in scholarship and loan combined. As I said, how many come backs with a proper and respected degree?
2. In order to promote healthy competition, if u grad with 1st class, ur loan will automatically convert to scholarship...
3. Apart from fed govt loan, u can apply for state loan and yet get two loans altogether.
4. As i said, if u are based locally, ur loan amount is RM8k or so per semester.
5. If u are based in the overseas, the fed govt gives out full amount even up to paying ur toilet paper! u do the math urself. that comes out to almost RM300k - RM500k per student per course for a degree programme.

And when this people come back, they default their loans... Many years ago I still remember NST will publish a long list of names who default their loans.. and u know what is the % of Bumis who do that? Almost 99.9%.. U will be asking what happened to the 0.1%. That 0.1% makes up either for those who for the "dan lain-lain" race.

All this is solely because of NEP. And those Indian students who were in Russia (Ukraine) studying medicine, what did our farking govt do? De-recognize that university while our Msian Indian students were there doing their medicine..

There is also another Uni that Msia does not recognize and it is the 5th biggest (I think 5th biggest) Uni in the world. If my memory serves me right, I think top 3 in China. Unfortunately, that Uni is not recognized by Msia. And u know why? Because that Uni houses more Chinese than Bumis!!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 3
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 09:15:01
typo ........... U will be asking what happened to the 0.1%. That 0.1% makes up for the "dan lain-lain" race.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 09:18:11
Michael, pls read the comments by jokerman...(u have to find it).. Not our experiences tell us so as I claimed... The fact of the matter and what NEP is causing us...

"...written by jokerman, March 31, 2008 | 21:29:08
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by michaelT, April 01, 2008 09:19:21
reading what you wrote you are indeed revealing the truth of the NEP that it should be removed. The wisdom and understanding of this policy is over. What the BN Putras have done is now revealing the bad results. The Universal Law of Cause and Effect has indeed produce that results. The propaganda that the UmnoPutras are feeding the Mlays untill their mind becomes deluded and see nothing more then their rights.. Their frequent statements like Our Land, Our Priveileges and rights etc have make them complacent and morally decadent. Removing NEP and bring back quality and equality is a motivational way to self excellence be it education or business.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by michael, April 01, 2008 09:50:19
Dear Grant,

For the record, I did support the NEP for many years, but NOT for most of its time when I realised it was becoming more adulterated and had caused more harm than good.

NEP is just a name. It can be totally changed and still be called NEP. So try not to be attached to the name. The NEP I am talking about for the future is for All Malaysians and you can call it whatever you like.

Some who are attached to the name, are sensitive to the removal of NEP, so why not just keep the name for name sake. Coke filled into a Pepsi bottle still taste like Coke, though the bottle containing says it is Pepsi.

Hope you get my drift, Grant.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 2
...
written by informalaysia, April 01, 2008 09:57:56
Malaysians,

Please lah stop all this "NEP-made-me-less-competitive" argument. Especially my dear Malay friends (I'm a Malay too btw).

To me, the Chinese and Indians can blame the NEP for not getting enough opportunities in the universities and all. (But the Chinese and Indians now should be in a way grateful that the tough times they had before has INDIRECTLY made them stronger today)

But the Malays? We the Malays can blame NEP only for one reason. NEP has drained much of our country's wealth into the hands on UMNOPutera due to its wrong manipulation. But the Malays not being successful in business? NO. I agree with everyone saying that NEP did make our country less efficient but it didn't make us the Malays less efficient! Well, ok lah. Indirectly maybe it did for creating an atmosphere of "We've got everything so let's rileks everything will be alright" But see, ultimately, it was us! Kita sendiri yang salah, ok. We have been the ones not trying hard enough. Please la stop all this blame game.

When I was in secondary school, I had so many smart Malay friends. But when we were in form 5, not all of them really worked that hard for SPM. I knew what I wanted and I worked my ass off, woke up at 5 every morning to get a scholarship to go and study abroad. Results? Thank God I got a scholarship to study in the US. Now who says that NEP actually made some of my friends work less hard when we were in form 5? Say, NEP is gone 2 years from now. Do you think if the mindset and culture of pemalas among us Malays continue, it would make any difference by then? NO.

Business. Did you know how many "bantuan kewangan"s kerajaan has been offering to the Bumi-owned IKS (Industri Kecil & Sederhana) all these while? While the NEP is being misused, I must admit that it did TRY to encourage we Malays to go into business. But why not so many took the chance? My mom got into business in 1990 and she's now earning thousands every month. We're grateful for this because we did not get any contracts from the kerajaan, but when the time came for my mom to expand her business, she was reluctant to do so, even when she knows a lot of government agencies are ever willing to help. Why? Because it was her own CHOICE that she wants to keep things this way - sweet and sederhana.

Now, ask ourselves. Has it only been the NEP? Would we change if NEP is gone? Did we relax just because of NEP or it's because of our own attitude?

I for myself would like to see the Bumi's getting less help from the government. This will slowly change the mindset of the Malays for sure. But if NEP is continued, I will never be happy to see if any help is given to my dear Malays who are pemalas even if they're my own relatives. Why? Because if they don't work hard, until the end of the world don't give any help to them. They don't deserve it!!!

WAKE UP MALAYS! Don't only blame NEP. Blame our own attitude as well.

Cheers.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 11
...
written by coolandy, April 01, 2008 10:10:34
This article should be made COMPULSORY reading for all malaysians.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by alan cheong, April 01, 2008 10:26:43


SPOT ON, Peter. This is wot WE have been saying and trying to get across but numskulls (umno, ie untuk melayu no otaks) and their herd just refuse to grow up, and thus continue on their self-destructive lemming-like journey. Ironic.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by roche, April 01, 2008 10:42:30
@loh : good point! NEP was used to make the non-M's feel inferior so that the M's would feel superior : this was UMNO stays in power cos of the feel good factor. BRILLIANT!

malaysia has it backwards : Affirmative action is for the minority not majority.

as a local grad i do agree some unfair advantages are given to bumi students.

however i think that instead of having more uni's they should provide more funding/scholarships for malaysian students. This would help those who dont get into local U's so that they can try private local colleges. plus get better lecturer's. QUALITY anytime over QUANTITY.

AND they should pls stop the quota system/merit system for entry into local U's. its unfair to compare STPM with metriculation. Both exams are equal in content HOWEVER stpm students sit for one major exam after 2 years and metriculation students are given exams over a couple of semesters (results are pooled together from 2/3 exams). this is a clear disadvantage. PLUS even the grading system is different. for STPM is was how many A's and for metriculation it was their GPA. how to compare?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by densemy, April 01, 2008 10:51:35
There is one word to explain the appalling state of education in Malaysia... ISLAM

OK, you can stop screaming now and listen. I know all about Islam and the pursuit of knowledge and I also know that knowledge is one thing and the ability to think analytically is an entirely different matter. And its the ability to think that separated the sheep from the goats

Knowledge is all around us... so you dont have to travel to China to find it. At the ***** of a mouse button you have the knowledge of the whole world at your finger tips. But knowledge is fallible, it can be misreported, manipulated or downright wrong

What is needed from an education program is to teach the ability to access and assess knowledge, to analyse it and to reach an informed conclusion. The knowledge itself becomes secondary to what you do with it

The astute observer will have noted that Badawi had a brief flirtation with 'the ability to think'. He briefly spoke to students about 'thinking outside the box', about Malaysia needing x thousand thinkers by 2020 etc etc. Then someone obviously slapped him down and he went back to talking about knowledge as though it was the ultimate goal.

Islam like all religions deplores the ability to think rationally. Once people begin to think for themselves they soon realise that religions are based on ... Nothing!.

The threats which keep people devoted to their religions are non existent, they are simply the fabrications of someone's mind with no substance and not supported by facts.

The great irony of all this is that if there is a god the finest gift he bestowed on man was the ability to think rationally. And what's the first thing religions take away from you??

Just look at your whole educations system... its staffed by unmotivated non-thinkers, its based on learning by rote. The education environment both physically and philosophically is barren and unimaginative. Standards are constantly being lowered, results are manipulated to promote mediocrity. Staff selection is based on ability to toe the line rather than academic merit. Syllabuses are dictated by religious dogma. There is almost no injection of ideas from overseas. Universities are headed up by people who should never have been allowed anywhere near a tertiary institution. The privatisation of education has lead to a decline in standards to the extent that accountants rule and the quality of education slides to a level unacceptable anywhere but in Malaysia. The Malaysian obsession with exams does nothing but promote learning parrot fashion. Students cheat and nobody cares, students get tutors to write their assignments and nobody cares. Students fail yet they get their piece of paper

And in the end the country churns out masses of mediocre students which basically are unemployable .. And yet with the ego of the newly graduated they think they are the essence of the future.

Malaysia has always known that the oil would eventually run out , and the only answer to that day was an intelligent well educated and creative work force.

But someone or some organisation with an entirely different agenda has sidetracked that goal. Islam might gain but Malaysia loses
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 6
...
written by nanyangren, April 01, 2008 11:29:08
You see, that is where the UMNO has no foresight. Even if they have taken half the oney to build universities, all the people of Malaysia would have been educated locally, and think locally. They would have completely brainwashed them and they will continue to vote umm- no.

Now alot went overseas, some on government scholarships too...an dthey come back with a different perception. This phenomena is no different from the days where the Brits sent Tunku to England to study an dthey come back to demand independence....

The wheel goes round and round....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by Rhan, April 01, 2008 11:53:42
Anak Kampung,
When RPK says build more university, it doesn't mean only the physical part lah.

NEP biggest flaw is treating education as business. Business can have free lunch but not education. I don't really care on business NEPism as those who can't cari makan anymore will come forward to oppose it. But Education NEPism will affect many generation and again, i don't care anymore because most talented Malaysian now aim for foreign university and we don't have to pool our resources to develop education, let the foreign professional like US, UK and Singaporean do it for us. The best part is all this foreign university graduate will come back join BR.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 12:09:37
Hi Michael,
We can definitely argue until the cows come home which they wont in fact.

It is funny though u use the metaphor quite aptly that if u put coke in the pepsi bottle it will still be pepsi at the end of the day. If u were branding Pepsi that way from the sales and marketing perspective, that will be ur huge mistake.

U want to maintain the name NEP and change its contents. And yet market it as the brand new NEP.. It can be NEP, it can Gen2 NEP, it can New NEP, it can be Bumi NEP, it can be Msia NEP but bottomline is it is still NEP.

Similarly I am telling u that this brand new generation Proton Wira (still looks like the old 90s Proton Wira) has an Evo V16 twin turbo engine bla bla bla bla but the shell, the shape and the casing remains a Proton. Hell yeah! Definitely a good idea for sales! Will surely boost Proton sales! Unfortunately Proton failed several times.

When we failed in the next 12 years for not achieveing Vision 2020, lets chg the content, the gist, the ingredients, the charter, the purpose in Vision 2020 and yet still continue on calling Vision 2020 then..

My drift is... these names are failures in the eyes of Msians; as NEP to the Non Bumis and Proton to Msians. If these names are failures why do u continue on using them? If u want to rebrand it why not rebrand it on a larger scale, a total overhaul and we can call the New NEP as anyting we want but NEP!

As I said before... the Malays in the kampung take NEP (the word itself) as their holy bible, as their sole livelihood... Tak boleh tidak ada NEP.. Kalau tidak ada NEP kita Melayu akan mati.. Tengok Singapura.. Melayu sana semuanya sengsara.. Tanah tergadai, budaya tergadai.. But all this is not true.. They are staying in their own shell because the BN govt is not allowing them full access to the current and real situation.

So as u said, retain the word NEP and chg the content - why? To continue to con the Malays in the kampung that NEP is still NEP just that the contents are changed without them knowing? Doesnt that make us all hypocrites as well?

And finally, we Chinese dont need NEP. We dont even need a Brand New NEP for all Msians. Wat we Msians need is justice, meritocracy, fairness, fair competition. Just like Singapore!
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 1
...
written by dmh1871, April 01, 2008 12:18:33
well RPK doesn’t need NEP nor see the need for NEP to continue coz he got something better that is the family connection thus he can afford to say so.

From your previous articles what can be culled is that whilst some people with no connection has to languish under isa/jail/remand and yet due to your family connection only statement were taken from you and I believe this is also a form of privilege, nepotism, cronyism etc where is the "equality before the law" that u talk about and yet the way you wrote it with a sense of arrogance as if the authority is afraid of taking action against you.

Personally I've never benefited from NEP, as a student I took out a study loan and upon graduation employed for years and then open up my business by re-mortgaging my house thus I’ve the right to say NEP is not necessary but I won’t coz there is benefit from NEP for all Malaysian.

from my observation the Chinese control 80 % of the economy thus the playing field is not level for which most business they do is between themselves and if they do business with the Malay they have different rules except when they need the Malay for the later NEP benefit i.e. govt contract and/or APs. Actually the people who complaint not because of the NEP per se but coz they could not get to use the said benefit indirectly through the Malays.

some people use Singapore as a role model without truly knowing the fact. Yes there are Singapore Malay boy/girl doing extremely well in their study and that’s it, there is only 1 Malay minister in charge of same environment ministry for so many years, no key post is given, no high court judge, no senior govt officer, no general, cpo, no DG,no ceo post in GLC, no banker, billionaire and yet the Malay there is said to be brilliant.

Where as in Malaysia?
report abuse
disagree 15
agree 5
...
written by cruzeiro, April 01, 2008 12:55:54
Dear dmh1871,
While you may have some points in what you say, let me say that I voted you down.

Take note that RPK did not say there is no need for "Affirmative Action" policies - all he said was we don't need NEP (or rather MDP) as we know it.

You'll only be able to compete on a level playing ground, if you're forced to "grow up" & compete, instead of being perpetually dependant on the "milk bottle". Therefore, all who have achieved a certain level of economic standing, shouldn't be privy to the benefits of the "affirmative action policies" based on the race & religion quotas.
Doing so would only encourage mediocrity & hollow chest-thumping "ketuanan" ideas, as is seen now.

Make no mistake UMNO Baru is trying very hard to make the Malays think that they have "lost" the nation & and are doomed to failure.
It is this "seige mentality" rhetoric that gets many Malays "eating out of their dirty hands", and has perpetuated the corruption, mediocrity and uncompetitiveness of Malaysia in the "global village".

Cheers, mate.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 4
...
written by michael, April 01, 2008 13:05:58
Hi Grant,

Grant, I realized that you don’t seem to read my text very well and often mistake the meaning altogether. Maybe you are still “angry” with me. Trust me, it is not worth your while. For peace sake, maybe I should have written it with better clarity.

You mentioned that I said “if you put coke in the pepsi bottle it will still be pepsi at the end of the day.” What I said was “Coke filled into a Pepsi bottle still taste like Coke, though the bottle containing says it is Pepsi.” It means the content remain unchanged whatever you bottle it in, it is still Coke. The bottle naming is not the key issue. The content is more important than the context. Please re-read to verify this.

Yes, everyone .. well almost, is very caught up with the word NEP, which stands for National Economic Plan (I think) ….. anything wrong with the name? Sounds perfectly fine with me. No where does it say Malay or Chinese or Indian’s NEP.

Are there poor Chinese or Malays or Indians. You must agree that there are. Lets call them Malaysians for short. Are there bright children of poor Malaysian families that might not have the change to get further education if financial help is not rendered? I would think so.

You said, “ we Chinese don’t need NEP. We dont even need a Brand New NEP for all Msians. Wat we Msians need is justice, meritocracy, fairness, fair competition. Just like Singapore!”

Believe it or not, there are still a lot of poor families in Singapore, despite their justice, meritocracy, fairness and fair competition. In any rich society, there will always a share of their poor people, due to cost of living.

Singapore continues to help their poor children who need support to ensure that they don’t miss out on an education just because their parents are not able financially, by giving grants or scholarships. This is call recognizing that no system is perfect, and that there will always be gaps and that there is a constant need to look into closing these gaps. This is what make Singapore’s national economic plan so successful.

So as a Chinese, do you want really want to exclude the Malaysian Chinese from the NEP just because we Chinese are all much too capable and so don’t need it? I live it to you, Grant. Whatever your decision is, it is not right or wrong, but just an opinion; just like mine.

Thank you, Grant for your sharing. And Yes, I do agree that the cows won’t come home and I am not one person who wants to wait for cows just to be right about being right. We have to move on and I won’t be responding to this topic any further. .

Peace be with you Brother!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 3
...
written by michael, April 01, 2008 13:20:58
Hi Grant

One other thing. The NEP is not just about education, as you know and applies to businesses too. Since you see Singapore as a great model country, they also have assistance financial plans to help entrepreneurs kick start their new business ideas.

So you don't have to be very rich to start off a new business. So our NEP should also encourage citizens of all races (sad that I have to emphasize the race thing)to create a vibrant society for all.

So there are other spin offs to be in the NEP. Lets not exclude the Chinese.

Thanks

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Birdbrain, April 01, 2008 13:32:26
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=...re=related

The UMNO members do not drink milk anymore......they are addicted to candies provided by the Candy man.

DAIM chocolates!
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by Ben, April 01, 2008 13:41:34
Budaya Malaysia is not suppose to be about handouts. It is as the saying goes,

Berakit-rakit ke hulu
Berenang ketepi-tepian
Bersusah-susah dahulu
Bersenang-senang kemudian

So I say take away the milk bottle and let us grow together as one, Bangsa Malaysia. The election is over and the results are recorded. Governments have been formed and its time to work together as Malaysians. Let us correct all that is wrong and prosecute the wrong-doers according to the law. Let justice be served and break the shackles of oppression and stranglehold of corruption. Is it not time we work together for a better Malaysia?

Yes, it is difficult at first. Have we not had enough? Seen enough? What more proof do we need to know that we have been going the wrong direction the last 50 years? What atrocities do we need before we clean up this nation and restore its integrity.

Surely, we all know that if we work together we will overcome all the difficult challenges to bring Malaysia forward to glorious days ahead. We done the most unimaginable coup de'tat that even international observers have praised the courage and boldness of the voters to cause the change. The question now, is it a change for the better or worse? We need to change continuosly to move ahead. The axe is already at the root of the trees, and every tree that does not produce good fruit will be cut down and thrown into the fire. A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruit. Likewise every good tree bears good fruit, but a bad tree bears bad fruit. Therefore, make a tree good and its fruit will be good, or make a tree bad and its fruit will be bad, for a tree is recognized by its fruit.
report abuse
disagree 2
agree 0
...
written by bikerzon, April 01, 2008 13:45:56
Dear Grant,

I don't think the Malay are stupid. We, Anak Malaysia can do. It is just the attitude that need to be change. When I was studying Form 6, I had my Malay Literature teacher commented on the Malay students.
During that time, most of the student that wanted to study for extra time would use the canteen and the empty class to study (because most of them are from poor family background and rent a small room without proper table/lighting). And when my teacher saw that in 95% portion that actually use the empty classroom and the canteen make up of non-malay. The next day, he started to comment the malay student in the school. He look at it himself thru his own eyes.
If only the attitude could be change, I believe, the Malay can reach te same level as any other Malaysian.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by AlwaysMalaysian, April 01, 2008 13:50:28
Well say Michael.

The policies to help the poor should be always there. The term NEP has nothing wrong. What we don't have, it's a report card. On how much money has been spent, who had benefited.

"Some people" may argue that money did spent in helping the poor. I cannot deny that. But for every RM goes helping the poor, how much is being pocketed by those who walk in the corridors of power?

And again, the NEP is to help the poor Malaysian. Regardless the color of their skin or where their ancestors came from, so long as they are Malaysian.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 14:44:58
Hi Michael,
I know u wont be replying on top of my comment since u said so. Anyways, if we expand the topic of NEP into businesses then the cows definitely not come home...

In all that I have written, the following summary is this.

1 - Irregardless if NEP is abt education or business or anything at all, there are 3 facts here
1.1 Non Bumis definitely do not benefit from it
1.2 Bumis are taken for a fool to believe NEP is everything about and for them
1.3 Having said so, only the BN goons and those who rub shoulders with BN will profit from it.

2 - Since NEP (New Economic Policy) or DEB (Dasar Ekonomi Baru) is not of any help to the non Bumis, and taking advantage of NEP (name sake trying to help the Bumis) to enrich the corrupted BN goons, therefore we need to eliminate NEP altogether and start to practice meritocracy and fairness.
2.1 Yes Singapore helps the poor, helps those who venture into SME or SMI and if that model works, why cant Msia employ the same model? After all, if we wanna copy (since Msia likes to copy almost everything from the Eye of Titiwangsa to God knows wat), copy smartly and there is no wrong in copying.
2.2 Even if we dont hv NEP, the government can still help the poor. This doesnt mean that without NEP the poor will die of hunger. If with NEP only the poor Bumis wont die of hunger then wat about those poor Non-Bumis without NEP? We will be like Somalia...

3 - Why I focus on the name NEP so much? As I said (if u understand what I wrote in Malay), a certain degree of Malay and esp those (shunt from the truth) living in the kampung cant live without it. Go and ask around, for example, "Pakcik, kalau tak de DEB, macam mana?" Then you will hear the pakcik say, "ooh tak boleh tak de DEB. Orang Melayu akan mati kalau macam itu." U think I am not being serious? Last week somebody posted an article abt this, I guess u did not read it. U saw what happened in Komtar, Penang when LGE said he wants to abolish NEP. All those stupid folks wanted to start a war! So what difference does it make if u re brand NEP with PEN and PEN were to be for all msians? The Malays will still see it that they have lost their rights! They will see it that they are now equal to everyone, which that is what we the Non Bumis want and unfortunately the Malays do not want!

4 - Having said that, and that is why I said we Chinese dont hv to live and rely on NEP. If u say u want NEP for all Msians, then tell me in wat form of NEP u want to have it for all Msians? If u are telling me equality, justice and fairness, aint that my deliverance of message from the start? Which again brings us to Point 2. We can still hv equality in everything not only in education and business but everything. We go by eligibility and meritocracy. Isnt that what we should be shooting for than just rebranding NEP?

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 14:49:33
Dear Bikerzon... if everyone has the same thought and mentality like yours we dont need NEP. For an action to take place (or reaction), there must be a stimuli...

The action of being lazy, the action of being dependant on NEP, the action of taking things for granted, the action of resting on one's laurel, the action of being complacent and the action of having all this attitude are all caused by a stimuli called NEP.

If we are not dependant of NEP we wont hv this mindset as I mentioned above. And that is why I asked earlier in my comments why the Malay Elites back in the colonial days were among the cream of the crop but not now in this present time?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by megahyper, April 01, 2008 15:02:36
written by dmh1871
"Personally I've never benefited from NEP, as a student I took out a study loan and upon graduation employed for years and then open up my business by re-mortgaging my house thus I’ve the right to say NEP is not necessary but I won’t coz there is BENEFIT from NEP for ALL MALAYSIAN."

WA, ATOK dmh1871, ngkau mengigau apa ni? where you derive that NEP benefit ALL Malaysian? 99% comments here against it. Hindraf against it. Who like to finance the other rich bugger of their 10% discount on housing? membebel la tempat lain je.

written by dmh1871:
"from MY OBSERVATION the Chinese control 80 % of the economy thus the playing field is not level for which most business they do is between themselves and if they do business with the Malay they have different rules except when they need the Malay for the later NEP benefit i.e. govt contract and/or APs. Actually the people who complaint not because of the NEP per se but coz they could not get to use the said benefit indirectly through the Malays."

Atok dmh1871, Did you only observe BTN or UTUSAN? Patutla! Where you get the 80%? what is the 80% comprised of? land? building? air? perempuan? share? bulu ketiak? wtf is 80%? I think its Malay thats controlling 80% of GDP considering spending power of govt. and GLC! you ni typical la.....

alo tok nyanyuk, you suggesting that the practise of giving contract to UMNO Malay and let them sub to chinese is best practise? you seems more extreme than BTN. ALO TOK! malaysia bukan sekadar melayu, cina! There is Iban, Kadazan, India, campuran....macam macam ada!

Again, Typical AMNO racist statement and smells heavy like AMNO cybertrooper.

Atok dmh1871:
"some people use Singapore as a role model without truly knowing the fact. Yes there are Singapore Malay boy/girl doing extremely well in their study and that’s it, there is only 1 Malay minister in charge of same environment ministry for so many years, no key post is given, no high court judge, no senior govt officer, no general, cpo, no DG,no ceo post in GLC, no banker, billionaire and YET THE MALAY THERE IS SAID TO BE BRILLIANT."

of cos they are brilliant! They can compete head on with the world, not just compete with sing chinese or indian, as you fondly like to stress. And having a higher living standard than the semenanjung malay.

And best of all, they can stand tall without the NEP and even look down on you miserable old racist "baby" that keep stressing the wonder of sucking from bottle or titties.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 7
...
written by dmh1871, April 01, 2008 15:27:42
Dear megahpayer, no need to use harsh and @#$%& language eventhough you were born with it, try to foward your cohesive opinion (if any) without the drama.

Just imagine even as brilliant as they are what do they get now, geez just imagine if they were stupid.

By this we in Malaysia = einstein.


report abuse
disagree 4
agree 0
...
written by megahyper, April 01, 2008 15:49:31
dear dmh1871,

The language is actually quite plain vanilla considering the written piece revealed a true blue racist at work.

Nobody is born with anything except skin color, atok. Even a racist mind is molded by propaganda and the environment.

Btw, they are neither brilliant nor stupid. how did you get that assumption again? They just strive to be a human with no clutch. You are striving in the opposite direction.

Yeah einstein drinks bottle.

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by dmh1871, April 01, 2008 16:55:21
dear megahyper,

it is a fact that to certain extend we are all are racial but the question is to what extend?

I didnt say they were stupid, the word used "if they were stupid" and it was you who said that "of cos they are brilliant! They can compete head on with the world"

unfortunately non that we know of.

The fact they are being far more marginalised in comparison to the situation in Malaysia and even worse they could'nt even voice out their frustration.

As what I've said before i've never rely or received any benefit from NEP thus the suggestion for me to "drinks bottle is redundant and inappropriate" except for you to achive some weird form of self satisfaction.
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 0
...
written by megahyper, April 01, 2008 18:02:38
"it is a fact that to certain extend we are all are racial but the question is to what extend?"

Yeah racist, to what extend? I can safely say that we in malaysia are EXTREMELY RACIST. Look around the world, point me one other country beside ex s. africa that institutionalise their population according to Malay, Eskimo, Red Indian or Maori. You are also product of the system, I cant deny that.

Singaporean Marginalised? muahahaha...unfortunately non that we know of.

Dont kid yourself la racist.

They couldn't voice their frustration? Hello, the last time i heard the hindraf 5 are still in Kamunting. And they are voicing for a down-trodden lots and the unfairness and wastage of NEP and got jailed for that.

Sing Govt issue shares/money to all population below SGD1,500/= (RM3,500). Malaysian govt issue contract to cronies under closed negotiated tender in the name of NEP.

So you aint get no dime from NEP. You are angel top to bottom. You refuse the 10% discount. can I shake your hand, holyman?

But you egg on others to be NEP addicts becos Einstein benefitted from NEP too?
Malaysian=einstein? You really are genius.

dmh1871 wrote:
"thus the suggestion for me to "drinks bottle is redundant and inappropriate""

wow. when did i suggest that to you? what an delusional racist. You are the one suggesting and egging others to keep on drinking from bottles or titties.

Wasting my time talking to an illusional racist- I shall stop here.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by kksam, April 01, 2008 18:03:54
written by dmh1871, April 01, 2008 | 12:18:33
from my observation the Chinese control 80 % of the economy thus the playing field is not level for which most business they do is between themselves and if they do business with the Malay they have different rules except when they need the Malay for the later NEP benefit i.e. govt contract and/or APs. Actually the people who complaint not because of the NEP per se but coz they could not get to use the said benefit indirectly through the Malays.
...............................................................................
Aiseh man, if you still remember, two years ago that stupid PM said he will reveal the formula how to count the equality among races in malaysia, but until now, all was silent. It was a fact which BN admit silently that malays had gain a lot in terms of economy equality, and of cos it refers to UMNO malays.
It was also a fact that a lot of chinese managed to survive because of connection to MCA and BN, AND WHEN WE CALL FOR AN END TO NEP, IT WAS ALSO AIM AT THESE CHINESE DOGS, not only aiming at malays. What we want to see is a fair level of competition not one sided or closed tenders.
Wosrt still, it was said to be helping Bumiputera, yet look at Sabahan and Sarawakian, any improvement on them? NEP was used to enrich BN and their cronies, and it has to end for the better of MALAYSIAN.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by angfaulith, April 01, 2008 18:08:13
yes i entirely agree. the entire wealth of the negeri sembilan royalty - antah group is trough the corrupt practices of the nep. those fools at antah were just given contracts especially when the yang di pertuan was the agong.
now look at the fools now!!
get rid of the nep!!
it only helps the rich malays and corrupt royalty!!
we in pas support an nep for all poor malaysians
in an islamic state we will be free and fair to all
reject bodowi-khairy and support pas!!
hidup pas! hidup malaysia!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 18:17:10
dear megahyper... for u to hit out at us, Msians saying that msians do not know how sg is like, u are truly truly wrong! sadly wrong!

Sg malays stand tall among all Malays when compared to Msian Malays. They are proud to be Singaporeans though they dont hv NEP. And personally I came to know some Singaporean Malays who truly look down at Msian Malays... even when the taxi driver i was talking who is a Malay seemed so. imagine la... sgporean malay taxi driver looking down at msian malays! and u talk about sg malays being marginalized. hey, sama color kulit but different nationality looking down at the neighboring country. Tak malu kah?

Do u know SG mosque is far more beautiful, equipped and maintained compared to Msian mosque? Do u know how much the govt does for the SG Malays? Just because the CJ, DPP, PM, IGP or wat not is not represented by a Malay, thus you conclude SG marginalize the Malay. U definitely got a cock head mentality.

Sg govt even go to the extend to even help the Sg Malays in sports. Do u know how many of the Malays are representing SG who are well paid and rewarded in Sg sports itself? Almost 50%. How many Chinese (apart from foreigners) represent the Sg Football National Team? When SG was represented by a bunch of malay elite soccer players like fandi ahmad, malek wahab, how often msia beat them? msia had to even borrow services from them to play for Pak-hang! SG Malays can speak the QUEEN'S ENGLISH so perfectly well, wat makes of Malaysian Malays? We cant even speak a simple sentence... Tak malu kah? SG Malays can do mental Math faster than any Msian. Again tak malu kah? Do u see any SG Malay Mat Rempits?

Tell me which part are the Malays being marginalized in SG from the NEP standpoint?

If u talk abt SG marginalizing the Malays, why dont u use China or perhaps other countries like Philippines.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by grant, April 01, 2008 18:22:16
typo... dedicated to dmh1871 not megahyper... ..
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by cruzeiro, April 01, 2008 18:41:14
"The fact they are being far more marginalised in comparison to the situation in Malaysia and even worse they could'nt even voice out their frustration."
==========================

dmh1871,
You must be having blinders, mate!
How is it that you refuse to see reason, and choose to use your assumptions as "evidence"?

As there are marginalized communities in all nations, so will there be in Singapore. Should the be Malays among them, it is only becos they have not been able to compete fair & square.
I for one, have yet to meet a Singaporean Malay who wishes to become a Malaysian Bumiputra - doesn't that fact tell you something?
Much more could be said here, but it would be better you just ***** on the link (if you care to), if you wish to see a reply I posted on MT (in a similar discussion).

Ethnic Envy and The NEP - a reply
http://cruzinthots.blogspot.co...reply.html
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by gorshan, April 01, 2008 18:58:07
baby dont know how to drink from cup.
try taking away botol from baby and baby will keris you smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif smilies/angry.gif
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 5
...
written by ckhoon, April 01, 2008 19:11:01
Referring to Pak Lah's recent remark that "Open tender is not necessary fair".

Nobody said that the world is fair, the problem in Malaysian economy was never a racial one. The New Economic Policy (NEP) was a policy created with the wrong target, it was not meant to help the poor, it was meant to just restructure the distribution of wealth among races.

The NEP was created with the noble idea of creating a level playing ground for all races, but in return it has further widened the gaps between the races. On one end, the NEP has created dissatisfactions among the non-Malays, and on the other end, the NEP is jealously protected by the Malays because they think that their rights will be taken away once NEP is scrapped.

Malaysians need to know that in the world of capitalism, nobody is better than another. It is the survival of the fittest, and it is certainly NOT FAIR, because only the strongest will survive. However, it is not fair NOT because of race (or the Chinese for that matter), but it is because the nature of capitalism that favor the RICH!

It is then imperative for us to resolve the flaws in the capitalist system, NOT by giving more opportunities to one race over another races, but by reformulating the capitalist system to favor the poor!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by jokerman, April 01, 2008 20:05:30
Anwar Ibrahim once said in one of his ceramah:

"Kita boleh tolong orang Melayu, tapi kita jangan sekat orang lain!"

Capabilities can be obtained over time through hard work and initiative. Meaning to say anyone regardless of skin colour or religion will stand a chance as long as they are willing to work hard for it. This is still a dream for many in Malaysia I guess.

If you are born a Chinese or an Indian, then you are what you are, you cant change that. Should you be born a Malay, then hooray, you are eligible to be an UMNOputera or be "protected" under the arms of NEP, but should you be born a non Malay well there is always MCA and MIC around or else sorry lah brother, maybe next life lah! smilies/grin.gif
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by informalaysia, April 01, 2008 20:22:23
LOL. Just look at these arguments.

I don't really care whoever is right or whoever is wrong. The fact that everyone is talking and arguing is in fact the beauty of this new culture. Read more and we shall improve in time.

Bravo. Keep up the arguments going, Malaysians!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by mikewang, April 01, 2008 20:44:05
One other point.

If everyone is rich, what then is wealth as a Japanese may tell you.
You have to be super rich.
So in order to feel comparatively richer, there must be poor people for you to compare.

So I suspect UMNO must have thought that if they deprive other races so that we can have more poor Chinese and Indians, that would make an average earning Malay feel rich.

And that's elementary, my dear Watson. smilies/smiley.gif
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by mgeo, April 01, 2008 21:27:35
densemy identified religion alone the cause of deterioration of education. To me, the main ones are mediocrity, communalism and nationalism. If we are not careful, we will end up like Americans. Notice that in their articles, books TV programmes, they address only other Americans, and even then ignore any diversity: everyone is expected to be a WASP. This is the Middle Kingdom effect where you think you are at the centre of the world.

At least the Europeans are better. We had better realize before it is too late that our diversity is a great asset.

On a more pragmatic note: rulers will always ensure that that there are not too many clever people to question them. The education system can go to the dogs because their own children are overseas. You clamour for more university places and they pretend to comply, especially for "backward sections of society", but they certainly don't want you to wise up.

Anyway, does education come from universities?
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by M0nd0man, April 01, 2008 23:47:22
well said!!
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by thiamjoo, April 02, 2008 01:30:14
It's not a matter of whether UMNO wasted billions and cannot afford to build more universities, it is more like UMNO is very selfish. Even with the current number of universities, the govt. have trouble enrolling deserving bumiputras so much so they have to lower the standard of entry to allow more bumiputras to go to universities. If the govt (UMNO) build more universities then it will be for the Chinese and Indians, and that wouldn't do.

This selfishness on the part of umno has cause many non-bumi families to make many sacrifices for the sake of their children's future. For the rich non-bumi, money is no problem but for the normal wage earner, it is really hard. And when the non-bumi study overseas and decide to work there, they are labelled as unloyal to the country or even a traitor. Whose fault is that?

We are all Malaysians. We are born here and we will live and die here. If we go overseas, and are asked where we are from, we will definitely say "We are from Malaysia". We can't say we are from Taiwan, China, or Singapore because that will be a lie.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Beautiful Mind, April 02, 2008 01:43:57
Many years ago, when l was still in Malaysia, each time when the issue of NEP and Special Malay Privilege were brought up in discussions, there will always be someone who would barge in and said with his neck sticking out...'you cannot argue and dispute Malay Privileges, it's a sensitive issue, you go to jail if you keep discussing it'.

So these issues were not discussed in the open and the Malays who have been benefiting from it would not argue about it...never mind the Chinese or Indians. They dare not open their mouth in front of their Malay friends about NEP / Malay Previlages. The Malay kept a tight lip about this. After-all, it was the Malay students who got scholarship and offered places at universities even with lesser results from their Chinese or Indian friends. It was the Malay who got a 10% discount when buying a property. It would be stupid to argue something that is benefiting oneself.

Today, when NEP issues were discussed in open forum, it created a heated debate. Many Malays also see that this has been unfair to other races. And Malays were arguing with other Malays accusing one another of all sorts. Traitor to the Malay race an accusation and a remark often thrown to the faces of those who criticises NEP.

NEP has done it's time. Like an automobile, it requires a complete overhaul. Besides, NEP was supposed to have ended a decade ago but still been practised uptil now. NEP is the reason why there is lack of unity among Malaysians nowadays as Malays will always feel that they are a better race. The Malay Agenda which the Malays uphold and strongly defend till now will always favours the Malays against other races in terms of placement at Universities, project contracts, promotions, employment etc.

Surely, the objectives now must be taking Malaysia forward shoulder to shoulder with the rest of the develop nations. And we cannot achieve this by churning out mediocre students from universities. We cannot achieve this by offering contracts to cronies. There need to be competitions and the best should win. The debacle of some major Projects in Malaysia with the constant flooding from government offices, cracks on bridges are proofs that the work qualities are not up to standard. Projects should be open to tender and the best company which can offer good value for money and work qualities should win.

For our Universities to progress, we need to bring in students with good brains. Not just to fill the numbers. And in the job market, people with good qualifications, those with excellent aptitude with good negotiating and inter-personal skills, language skills and ability to perform should be the criteria rather than some Joe Blogs who happened to know a Datok or a Tan Sri somewhere.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by Vampiress, April 02, 2008 06:49:58
We are all Malaysians. We are born here


I not born in malaysia but i call myself malaysian wor! Can or not? smilies/grin.gif
report abuse
disagree 6
agree 2
...
written by Vampiress, April 02, 2008 06:51:28
we will live and die here


Oso, i don't want die here. How? smilies/grin.gif smilies/grin.gif
report abuse
disagree 7
agree 1
...
written by cutejams2004, April 02, 2008 11:41:05
NEP should be scrapped off and a new economic agenda that is fairer and more transparent should be drawn...As a student, I have gone thru the pain caused by the unfair and bias quota system imposed in the Malaysian education system..After years of being in a national school, singing Negaraku, being nurtured to be patriotic and all, at the end of the day, i was denied a rightful place in a public uni despite having good results, good brains and hardworking..The reason given was-Im a non-bumi! So i wonder whats the point of teaching kids in school to be patriotic and to mix around without any bias feelings of race religion and background, when the education system itself practices all these negative traits..
Hopefully, with a newer economic agenda, future Malaysian kids would not end up being heart broken like how the non-bumi generation of my time was, are and will always be heart broken by the way we were treated..
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by NCantona, April 02, 2008 12:45:26
Dear RPK and bloggers,

We have discussed about the NEP and its inequality to accomodate all the Malaysians into varsities. But have we ever thought abt our education system as a whole. I think many of you would have watched the "Are you smarter than a 5th grader?" in Astro. Have guys had a look at their questions. At the age of 10, they are already answering about the periodic table in chemistry. Whereas, in this country we still not asking them that type of questions. The question of using money to build more uni is not a intelligent one.

RPK u have been a great teacher to me. And you showed me how to stand up for your own opinion. In this topic, i have to be the student who go aginst the sifu. Lets all forget about the NEP. NEP comes into effect in Uni. But before uni we have 12 years of schooling education which is equal to all i hope. My time the teachers nvr saw us as Malays, Chinese or Indians. Everyone is equal for them. And I know it's still the same.
Lets get a microscope view over our education system especially schools. Till the age of 12 we learn all basics of science and maths. My time was even worse when we had only alam dan manusia which bears no effect at all. My opinion would be by the age of 12, the kids should start learning basic of chemistry, biology and physiscs. Hence, when they enter the secondary schooling we could start them on the basics of engineering, medicine, and literature even law. How many of us understand the basic laws of our country?
If this is done in secondary schools, uni learning can be done more practically which would produce more quality engineers or doctors. We need to revamp our education system to suit the globalization which happening faster than we are thinking. We need to equip our school students with these basics so it would be helpful for them to choose the course they like and will lessen the students who drop out from uni or colleges.
Another prob is, we are to exam oriented. Students don't study to learn the subject but to pass the exams. After exams, the students dun remember what they studied. We have to go less on the exams and more on practical theory.
How can our uni be in top 100 of the world, when the equipments in their lab is shared by 3 or 4 students at a time. It's time we changed. A reformation of the education system is needed. Then we can talk about building more uni or colleges. We need quality education system to produce quality students.

My two cents opinion.
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 1
...
written by skc, April 02, 2008 14:12:35
Ah now I understand this a lot better, so our soon to be ExPM also depend on his Ex Father in Law (Mahmud Ambak was a very successful businessman), so why should he not give his current SIL a leg up also. Hahahahahahaha
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by Xerxes, April 02, 2008 15:37:34
What about the opportunity cost of those money wasted and the universities NOT built? If we Had built those universties and educated all those non bumis who were forced to leave Malaysia and never return, these people could have contributed to Malaysia's development and brought Malaysia to even greater heights.

The NEP is not "milk". It is drugs. UMNO has fed the NEP drug to the Malays so much so that they are so addicted to it they can never let go. They won't die as babies when Petronas money runs out. The Malays will die as "NEP drug addicts"
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by dkkl, April 02, 2008 16:26:17
Well, I like to bring you back to 18th Century when British invade China thru an Opium war, in which China was lost. In order to rule China easily, the British introduce Opium to the chinese. Unfortunately chinese got hook and rely on Opium heavily. Thus they became very weak and was rule by foreigners in the end.

Therefore, I would like to hightlight that NEP is another kind of Opium. UMNO wants to rule Malaysia(after they lost election in 1969), so they introduce this NEP to the Malays in order to get support from the Bumis.

If you think inside the box, yes... they got special privileges. But if you think out of box, the NEP is actually weaken the Malays. In long run, they become addicted to the NEP just like chinese addicted to opium in china in the past. In other words, without NEP they will never survive.

So, if the Malay were trained to stand on its own feet without depending on the NEP, I believe they can be far more succeed compare to other races. Therefore, the NEP should be abolished. That NEP is a dinosaur system. Not suitable for the new Generation.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by kindaeasi, April 02, 2008 16:57:15
Forgive me but whenever I meet or come across a “Successful Malay” be it a professional or a business man, my first reaction is, that he got there because he is a MALAY. If a Malay says he is in local or overseas university, in the back of my mind I would be saying this, because you are a MALAY therefore the NEP just gave it to you even when you didn’t deserve it. I have every little respect for these people.

How about Amanah Saham Bumiputera (ASB)? ASB for Bumiputeras only, earns about 12-18% yearly. While Amanah Saham Wawasan (ASW) and other schemes for all Malaysians (including bumis) earn 5-7% only. Why can ASW earn the same interest of 12-18%. This is because it is a fund that non-bumis participate in. Have a fund instead for all MALAYSIANS irrespective of race paying 12-18% interest a year.

So when I see a MALAY having a good life, driving a big car, having a big house, going overseas, ect, I have no respect for ALL the achievements in his life. Sorry to say this.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by Uma, April 02, 2008 17:22:36
Here's my story : At the age of 4, I threw away my feeding bottle because I wanted to be all "grown-up" and drink from the cup just like my grown-up siblings. To me, it was childish and baby-like to be bottle-fed and I wanted to show that I was capable to drink from a cup on my own. I remember my mom proudly announcing that to all our relatives whenever they came to visit...

The moral of the story being, the moment the Malays are willing to stand-up and tell the rest that they are, indeed, capable of being resourceful and excel in business and education just like the non-malays, they will instantly win the respect and admiration from NOT just other races in Malaysia, but beyond that, globally, as well..(if you've been reading news on CNN and BBC during the recent election, you'll know what I mean)

I mean, my malay friends, are you really THAT incapable? In fact, are you THAT ruthless and selfish that you seriously think that it is your birth right to have some quota reserved for you for business and education, whereas your Indian friends get labeled as "Gangster dari Kelang" and your chinese ones as "toukey VCD"?

Has it ever occured to you that no matter how intelligent a Malay is, he'll normally not be looked upon as THAT intelligent because "the government probably helped him"?

Don't get me wrong, this is not about bashing the Malays. The Indian who was given the mandate to help other Indians in the government was more interested in things other than exactly what he was mandated to do. And the chinese should learn that there is more to life than making lots of money, even illegally.

But let's not play the bashing and blaming game - the election is over and we now know that people want to see a better system being put in place. One that is corrupt-free, fair, growth stimulating, fair, fair and oh yes, fair. Maybe we can learn from the country I have adopted as my new place to live now, Norway. I am after all an immigrant here but I get more rights and privelege here than I used to get in my own country of birth. A week after I received my work permit, I received a brochure with the tittle "Your right as an immigrant". Among others, it says that I enjoy all the same rights as a native norwegian. A month later I got a letter saying that I'm part of the National Insurance Scheme and something, in a nutshell, to the effect of me not having to worry about having kids and getting old....

Now Malaysia, I dont need National Insurance from you, just give me something that'll make me feel wanted in my own country of birth.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 2
...
written by sathia, April 02, 2008 20:11:06
...
written by kindaeasi, April 02, 2008 | 16:57:15

Forgive me but whenever I meet or come across a “Successful Malay” be it a professional or a business man, my first reaction is, that he got there because he is a MALAY. If a Malay says he is in local or overseas university, in the back of my mind I would be saying this, because you are a MALAY therefore the NEP just gave it to you even when you didn’t deserve it. I have every little respect for these people.

How about Amanah Saham Bumiputera (ASB)? ASB for Bumiputeras only, earns about 12-18% yearly. While Amanah Saham Wawasan (ASW) and other schemes for all Malaysians (including bumis) earn 5-7% only. Why can ASW earn the same interest of 12-18%. This is because it is a fund that non-bumis participate in. Have a fund instead for all MALAYSIANS irrespective of race paying 12-18% interest a year.

So when I see a MALAY having a good life, driving a big car, having a big house, going overseas, ect, I have no respect for ALL the achievements in his life. Sorry to say this.


Hmmm... really says a lot about you as a person!!!
report abuse
disagree 3
agree 1
...
written by NancyL, April 02, 2008 20:21:53
RPK......AUWWWWWWWWWWW.....how could you did that to your baby.....giving her plain water bottle so that she didnt ask anymore milk at nite ....her stomach was too small then to indulge bigger amount of milk.....babies get full and hungry quickly.....you are cruel!!!!...HUH!!!...MAN!!!...THAT REMIND ME I WILL NEVER EVER AGAIN LET MY HUB LOOK AFTER MY BABY!!!... smilies/angry.gif smilies/angry.gif smilies/angry.gif...
Since I had my first baby 6 yrs. ago until my third baby which is 3 now...I had....not even once slept for a one whole full nite...not once....well....

Therewas a story....when a man approached Prophet Muhammad...asking him..."Who does he have to answer first when both his parents call him?"...then Prophet replied...."Your Mum"....and he asked again...."After that?"....answer was again.... "Your Mum"....and he asked again.....for the 3rd time...and it was still his Mum...until the 4th time...then Prophet said..."Your Dad"....
And the love of a mother is soo high in Islam that it said...."Heaven is under the feet of your mother"......mum loves is different from dad's love...the bond is too strong....only women will understand this!!!smilies/smiley.gif smilies/smiley.gif smilies/smiley.gif ....

A mother will only try to stop her baby from crying for milk at nite ..only when she realised that she is big enuff....that is when she start proper weaning....that is when the time is right...she will wake up at nite no matter what until her child no longer need her to...thats the love and sacrifice of a mother....

I understand why ur mum didnt give you the bottle but to agree why you didnt give ur baby the milk thats a different issue......

I know that the main point you want to make here is that "Your love for Malays is like the love of a father"...thats what you want the Malays to know ...and that no matter how bad you said of them is actually just like an act of a father to his child....

OK...About building more UNIS.... I agree with you strongly ....and I disagree with the opinion that more UNIS will create more non Quality Graduates....this matter to me can be fixed by solving the roots of the PROBLEM...we should concentrate in making better education at the earliest stage ...

i.e QUALITY BASED KINDERGARDEN & PRIMARY SCHOOL....

I disagree with the educ System now...that make a primary school kids projecting their teacher as a different entity....I remember when I was small...I was scared of my teacher...infact they should make a system that the children will project their teacher as teh source of education and asking question to them is a norm and inturns make them feel that going to school is the best thing that ever happen...the teacher should be trained in how to build confidence in children...this can only be done from the support of the govt...
....the govt should put more money in creating Quality teachers.....

STUPID OR SMART OR CLEVER OR GENIUS...WE WERE NOT BORNED WITH THEM...NEITHER WERE THEY BEEN CREATED OVERNITE....I give salute to the Chinese and Indians parents becus I know they really worked hard to make their children smart....
I remember about 15 yrs ago...teh Malays were so scared to send their kids to science stream becus they scared it would be too difficult to their children....thats their mentality....and I remember I felt so envy when I saw my chinese classmates of how they brought themsleves up with confidence in class and how their parents encouraged them...compared to my mum as she never even once checked my homework...that for honestly Malay mentality that time...I cant blame her...becus thats how she was brought up......

IF WE COULD...JUSTCOULD....CREATE QUALITY SCHOOL KIDS...THEN THERE WILL BE HONESTLY WILL NO WORRIES OF ANOTHER NON QUALITY GRadUATES...WITH GOD WILL...

"QUALITY TEACHERS - QUALITY SCHOOLS - QUALITY STUDENTS - QUALITY UNIS - QUALITY GRadUATES - QUALITY MALAYSIA" = THUS MORE UNIS MORE QUALITY MALAYSIANS THUS NEP NO MORE NEEDED!!!!


As you said RPK.....

"The NEP is not just about education or places in universities, some would say. It is also about business opportunities. Sure, but is that an excuse not to solve at least half the problem; racial quotas in universities. If we solve one problem then we will have only one problem left to solve. Now, after 38 years, we still have two unresolved problems, and both involve race and racial quotas."

Thats one problem solved..instead of the money go in a waste....and we as Malaysians should indeed solve these matters together instead of just pointing finger and blaming one after another....that knid of mentality is of the lowets of the low.....SOLVING IS BETTER THAN BLAMING...

IF ONLY RPK WHAT YOU HAVE MENTIONED ABOVE CAN BE PUT IN PAPER AND BE PRACTICED INSTEad OF JUAT ANOTHER CYBER CHAT.......
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 3
...
written by NancyL, April 02, 2008 20:25:30
that knid of mentality is of the lowets = that kind of mentality is of the lowest...

sorry wrong typing
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 1
...
written by bill, April 03, 2008 01:41:29
Dear RPK,

Building more Universities is not a problem. How are we to maintain the operational cost and more importantly the quality of the graduates? Ultra Malay extremist wants to have more Malay professionals and graduates than non malays at all cost without looking into quality. This is as if non malays do not contribute towards the development of Malaysia.You are right to say the Malay elites in UMNO is using the NEP to enrich themselves and to hang on to political power in the country. They are even prepared to lie on the percentage of bumi ownership in the equity sector.
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by raybeam, April 03, 2008 08:55:46
LETTR TO MALAYSIAKINI

Hats off to all those who brought change
Alfred Ho | Apr 2, 08 4:08pm

The people of Malaysia have finally spoken and a quiet revolution of sorts has taken place. I think that the election results would have been even more impressive for the opposition had the Election Commission acted impartially.

However, at least the opposition has now denied the Barisan Nasional government its two-thirds majority in Parliament and that is certainly a good start. I am glad to have been able to play a small part in this quiet revolution by urging Malaysians to bring about change by voting for the opposition.

I equate the election results to ‘People Power’ and with the winds of change. The MIC and Gerakan are now both irrelevant. The MCA and the PPP have also been dealt a heavy blow and I am sure that the leaders of the Barisan Nasional will have to do a lot of soul-searching to do.

Let us hope that the three successful opposition parties can get their act together and rule efficiently the five states that right thinking Malaysians have delivered into their hands and not fail the many citizens who have helped
bring about this change.

As a blind individual myself, I hope that discrimination towards the disabled community will be a thing of the past and that we will be given equal opportunities where jobs are concerned. As a singer, musician myself, I hope to be given opportunities to perform at government and other public functions.

Finally, I wish to thank all those who campaigned tirelessly to bring about this change and these include people such as Raja Petra, the Lim combo, Anwar Ibrahim, Jeff Ooi, the list goes on. I also wish to take this golden opportunity of saying special thanks to the alternative media for giving us a platform to air our views during the run-up to the elections.

Let us hope that the Barisan Rakyat will keep its promises to the people by looking into their interests and that corruption and cronyism will be things of the past.

While I am on this subject, it is my sincere hope that all those who have been involved in corruption during the former administration be charged in court and that the full force of the law be brought to bear upon them for their misdeeds to teach them a lesson that they will not forget in a hurry.

report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by fandi, April 03, 2008 12:17:11
Malay Sial Bolih.

This slogan is terrible, yes because the NEP makes it bolih, but after that everything that is bolih crambles.Yes I agree with comments by the Malays who are genuine achievers but looked down by the other races because of the NEP, malu tak malu sebab NEP buat dia itu.Now is the time that the Malays grow up by themselves without the NEP as this will make them stronger, more resilient and self reliance.
Now that more Malays are in the opposition can the Government with the minority Malays say that the NEP can be achieve when thay are not helping out the majority Malays in the opposition with the NEP, as NEP is only for UMNOputras only.What Penang is now going to do is correct open tender for all Malays who are able and capable, and no more favours for any partisan Malays.The UMNO forum recently held by the former PM still shows the arrogance by those in the forum.This arrogance is blatantly the downfall of BN, I pity the other component parties that make up the BN when they see this happening whether Paklah going to be still PM or better be an astronut, then there is a reason for other component parties to cross the floor.What is wrong for a Malay to cakap English in any forum or ceramah as it is easier to understand for all races.Remarks as hey cakap Melayu lah always irritates the other peoples impression of dominance and they tend to walkout in any function, because people are always sensitive.
Well if you say that NEP has not been achieved, try go for a buka puasa in any 5 star hotel,family members scavenging for food at hundred over RM per head is this not NEP
being achieved.I better stop here as people are really getting sore with me.There are better ways to spend money as there are plenty Malays who are not better off then you, think about it as they are not UMNOputras
report abuse
disagree 1
agree 2
...
written by zhugeliang, April 08, 2008 15:46:15
I agree that we need more quality graduates. But then does our universities have quality lecturers? Is our university education is comparable to overseas or S'pore university? Remember our university ranking is now off the chart. Again, if too many smart people, then they will overthrow UMNO people (which does not have smart people). So, to keep those Malays not so smart, they prefer not-so smart graduates and not-so good university. :-)
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0
...
written by NancyL, April 08, 2008 23:38:20
Hi Zhugeliang....

If you really know what UMNO was based on then I dont think they would be feared of "majority smart malays"...they might be feared of "majority smart Non-Malays" ...but again...if the government can create a system of education which in long term create clever and critical thinking school kids....and which atleast overall influence the majority malaysians..this will indeed create healthy competition among each other......and to ensure whether the lecturers are within standard then there should have a Quality Audit Department specifically for improving the education system in this country.

Anyway thats why we have PKR isnt it?...I mean the opposition party.....if they try to build and improve teh quality of existing universities and succeed in it...then like it or not UMNO has to do the same also inorder to win the hearts of the voters....so again create healty competition.

BTW try to have faith in your own people....we too can create better Universities than S'pore and the others...

Eventhough this takes time...but if our people are smart enuff....maybe the fastest would take 10yrs. if the govt committed with this 24/7...and i.e if we still stick wit the VISION 2020. Thats what vision for isnt it?....

Without Vision there will indeed be no Mission....so basically that means the blind le*** the blind.....
report abuse
disagree 0
agree 0

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
 

 
** SPONSORED LINKS **
Will NATO become a global army? More..

Sponsored Links

World Futures  Close down the NATO, says the conference statement on the recently concluded and successful International Conference on NATO & Its Policies in ASIA.

Future Fastforward  A controversial analysis by a controversial analyst, Matthias Chang, the lawyer-writer who unabashedly calls a spade a spade and offers no apology for doing so.

Internet TV 3000+ Channels  Pick your favorite internet TV channels straight to your PC! Yay!

Some Images Hosted With
Thank You ImageShack!
 BLOGGERS AGAINST ISA

Powered and Optimized for:
Malaysia Today by MT-TEAM